Rate Campaigns worst to best?

[1984]

RIght now playing thru Curse of Osiris and finding it really stupid and boring. I bet it is the worst. The first campaign was ok.

[Shimona]

I would say the Red War was the best, then Forsaken, then Shadowkeep, then Warmind and lastly CoS

[MOSLEY]

From best to worst (IMO):
Forsaken
Shadowkeep
Warmind
The Red War
Curse of Osiris

[Lusus Symphonia]

Best to worst?

Forsaken
Release Red War.
Warmind
Curse of Osiris
New light red war.
Shadowkeep.

Shadowkeep just doesn't settle with me, reused assets, bounty story quests, like 5 campaign missions IIRC.

Story and raid quality is another story.

[-{SALT}-]

For-♥♥♥♥-saken
Red Meme
MemeKeep
War Meme
Meme of Osiris

[Bisexual Space Wizard]

Personally

Shadowkeep
Forsaken
Warmind
Red War (before new light. Not sure how it is now)
Curse of Osiris

[Lusus Symphonia]

Originally posted by ZERO KAY PER CENT:

Everyone is mentioned New Light. But I just started playing Destiny and beat that campaign 1st. How is it different?

Not starting from scratch, all subclasses unlocked, no atmosphere or feeling of hopelessness after losing your light, campaign doesnt include adventures or strikes anymore, it just dilutes the atmosphere of the whole campaign.
I personally enjoyed leveling up and unlocking my subclasses.

[Emurinus]

Worst to best imo:

Curse of Osiris
Warmind
Shadowkeep
Red War
Forsaken

[-blam!-]

Best to worst imo:
Forsaken
Red War
Warmind
Shadowkeep
CoO

[Forrest Gimp]

Worst to best:
Shadowkeep - for price they're asking, this castrated prologue of a campaign feels like a total ripoff.
Warmind - Pretty sure there have been tons of Doom memes about this one. But campaign is still quite good.
Curse of Osiris - very beautiful and interesting one.
Forsaken - very beefy for a DLC. Long, well paced, lots of new stuff added.
Red War - great introduction to the title. Can't really say if it's better than Forsaken or not.

[peepoSad]

From best to worst

Forsaken -because they brought back random rolls on weapons + they added a bunch of new features as well

Warmind - the story was decent, mars is cool. Brought a cool game mode E.P.

Shadowkeep - only above the rest because they suck. Moon is cool but the story was bad. But as a D1 player the "bosses" in the story were lame with the immunity phases. (They are reused bosses from D1 and they never had immunity phases back then)

CoO - Shortest story of all time, beat it in under 3 hours the first time I did it and was very under whelming the whole way through, plus mercury is just boring to this day why go there?

Red war - the story was generic as hell, good guy vs bad guy. Bad guy wants to steal the light to power himself. Good guy stops bad guy.

[Emil]

best to worst
foreskin
OG red war (amazing rewards)
shadowpeep
warmind
CoO
new red war with bad rewards

[Flyci]

~

[TheVoidSpirit]

My list, from a Lore nerds perspective:
1. Forsaken
2. Shadowkeep (Bonus points from the Pyramid reveal)
3. Red War
4. Warmind

Curse of Osiris never existed and shouldn't be talked about.