+20% swing speed
Crit on enemy: 2 seconds of stun
-40% damage penalty
10% fire vulnerability

pros:
+ 40% faster swing speed
+ crits when it would normally mini-crit
cons:
- 25% damage penalty
- 50% fire damage vulnerability when active

+20% swing speed
+ stuns enemy for 4 secs
+ mini crits stuned players
-20 damage penelty
- fire destroys weapon ( like the spycicle)

+20% attack speed
+25% longer charge time duration
~Ignites foes on hit after an enemy Pyro burns you for 5 seconds, but will break after 15 seconds
-30% damage penalty
- +15% fire damage vulnerability while active
-Fire vulnerability will remain even after you switch weapons until you stop burning

Pros:
Splinter: 2HP bleed effect on targets every 1/2 second for 10 seconds.
Lightweight: +.8 seconds of charge.
Lightweight: +20% Attack speed.

Cons:
Flimsy: -20% Damage
Conducter: +20% Vulnerability to fire.
Wind Force: No crititicals while charging

Originally posted by Mr. Bones' Wild Ride:

+25% firing speed
+22.5% longer melee range
-30% damage penalty

Crafting recipe: Claidheamh Mòr + Chargin' Targe

i'm ok with this!

Originally posted by dankscoper:

+25% Firing speed
-10% Damage

Firing Speed?

Just like the rocket jumper, it deals no damage to let you practice hitting your enemy ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

The Woodcarver
Level XX wooden sword

+ 25% Faster swing rate
+ On hit : Enemy bleeds for 8 seconds

- 50% Less damage
- 15% Fire damage vulnurability ( Can't you see the bloody WOOD? )


Just for extra fun : Crafting recipe =

Tribal Man's Shiv + Persian Pursader = The Woodcarver ( Hope I spelt the two weapons used in crafting correctly )

Originally posted by Lapis:

+25% firing speed
+22.5% longer melee range
-30% damage penalty

Crafting recipe: Claidheamh Mòr + Chargin' Targe

I would say add a 15-25% vulnerability to fire and it would be both realistic and balanced.

-50% damage
-short range (same as default bottle)
+25% swing speed
+friendly pyros can light your weapon to set enemies on fire

+40 movement speed
+25 attack speed
-40 dammage penalty
breaks when caught on fire

A rather fair setup would be something like:

+15% swing speed
On Hit: Bleed target for 5 seconds
+15% fire damage vulnerability
-20% damage penalty

Great design though

Originally posted by Lapis:

+25% firing speed
+22.5% longer melee range
-30% damage penalty

Crafting recipe: Claidheamh Mòr + Chargin' Targe

+on hit enemy bleeds for 7 secs
This would help the weapon a little bit.
Also splinters