The trinket does work. It still appears and causes fire to drop extra stuff. However some enemies (notably in the mines) leave fire on the ground which you can douse and those fires also drop pickups.

Unfortunately I haven't bought Repentence yet. I'm totally out of the loop. Based on CondoSlime's comment, are you guys loading this up in Repentence and it just works?

Once I familiarize myself with the new DLC, I can support this mod again.

i need this mod for repentance!

Great gideon's fire spit counts as fire for this trinket, dropping pickups. The same might be true for ultra war's flame. It also counts for fire rock spiders.

Hi, is this updated for Repentance?

Will you add a gold version of this trinket?

i knew it was weird that fire didn't have a petrified poop

Okay, thank you

I, uh. I didn't. Petrified poop is in the normal trinket pool, so I left emeber in, too.
However... you could look into MC_GET_TRINKET and MC_POST_PICKUP_SELECTION; I know MC_POST_PICKUP_SELECTION lets you return {variant,subtype} to override what was going to spawn before, but I haven't messed with GET_TRINKET yet. You'll want to see if your trinket was selected, then roll something else if it was.

Hey creator, I'm making my own trinket mod, but I need help. How did you make it so that your Ember doesn't drop from the trinket pool?

An update's out! EID compatibility as well as an interaction with Mom's Box. It's also been refactored to use my new API, but still works without it because I respect you.

Oh, i see.
Now I definitely like this mod :)

"When not holding ember, fire drop RNG is unaffected (aside from the 1% chance to drop ember)."
This means that you'll still get your regular coins and hearts and stuff, but maybe ember will decide to drop whenever you don't.

So w/o ember i can't get anything from the fires except that trinket?

Why wasn't this put in the game in the 1st place, again?

An update's out! I finally listented to everyone saying that ember was appearing too often, and decreased the odds of it spawning. Hopefully finding this trinket will feel a bit more special.

Likely Warm Cabin: yeah it feels much better to make this trinket more unique.

Ooh, that's really good to know. I had suspected that it was working when I tried it on subsequent times. I think I was just really unlucky the first time I tested it.

dd: How would you feel about tweaking the drop chances from 2% to 1%?

LixieLorn: The way trinkets are coded, any trinket is automatically compatible with smelter and gulp! All those items do is make the HasTrinket call return true.

Nice one but ember spawns too often, I do get ember every 1/2 of the first floor because it can be burning basement and it gives you too much chance.

Love this mod. Such an obvious thing that should always have been there! Any way you can get it to work when eaten with Gulp! or Smelter or such?

An update's out! This is a good one: ember is now compatible with all heart and coin types. Try and get a lucky penny!

The ghost...?

0/10, Not worth the ghost.

@ValidGamer You have/had linger bean item?

ATM it's bugged for me as it leaves a cloud sprite of some sort that does nore dissapear

you should rename it to petrifire

Great idea

I want to see this in Booster Pack #4

definately gonna be in the next booster pack!! great mod!

9/11 while 420 blazin it this mod is Really awesome!

It always seemed to me that having such a trinket in Isaac would make sense because poop and fire behaved similarly in the game in terms of random drops when destroyed/extinguished (and we also had Petrified poop since Rebirth but had no counterpart for fires). In my opinion, this should've been in the base game since the very beginning alongside aforementioned Petrified poop. It's really nice to see it implemented at least as a mod. Good job there! Let's hope it gets added into the game in a future booster pack

Update's out! Ember should only spawn once per run, and I've replaced my programmer art with PJ's super cool sprite.

Np, glad i could help ^^

I literally have a line of code that prevents that exact scenario from happening........wtf
Well, I'll go ahead and add the "can't get it more than once from a fire" bit, along with the new art later this weekend. That'll probably fix it.

Ummm... i was holding ember when dropped the second one xd.

Oh, whoops. My logic only prevents a second spawn if you're HOLDING ember. Should be a pretty easy fix.

Put that only can spawn one time per run from bonfires, like petrified poop. I just got 2 in less than 1 minute from bonfires. Could spawn from mom's box and chest more than once.

Oh, dog, the sprite's shit. You can say it. I've got a couple other people who said they want to draw something, so I'm gonna wait a little bit to see what they come up with.

I actually just cheated to play two burning basements in a row, and put out every fire in sight--no ember appeared.

The sprite could use some work, but it's a neat idea! I always have this habit of putting every fire out, and this will make that much more beneficial.

I really like PJ's sprite.

As for the 2% drop rate, petrified poop seems to drop pretty often when you destroy poops so I think that's justified.

Interestingly, ember is already compatible with sack head! I guess the sack head code intercepts ALL coins, keys, etc. dropped, no matter what the source.

As for double hearts: As fun as it would be to add some of the more exotic hearts and coins, I just don't have the data for the probability on those. A lot of them require achievements, too, which sounds like a whooooole can of worms. I'm kind of holding out for a GenerateRandomHeart function, but if it comes down to it, I can always make up a few numbers and see how they feel.

2% drop rate is a bit high in my opinion, otherwise it's pretty cool.

@Legit_McName. 32x32 is the max, but trinkets are usually 20/25 max, counting double black outline.

Mine is 32x32 just resized. And pits wanted say bonfires, a typo :P. Will send the img.

Oh, PJ, not sure what you meant by pits. But that sounds like it might be an idea for another mod.

I like it, PJ! The orange glowy bits are exactly what I had in mind. Legit_McName, I've sent you a friend request. I'm gonna check out what everyone has to offer before I add anything in. In general, I'd say keep it about 32x32, but the game seems to resize things and I don't really get how (like PJ's art, which is like 800x800).

Since i'm going to sleep soon and you didn't connected to accept the PM. I did a sprite for ember, if you like, i will send the img: http://imgur.com/a/1OJib

@Legit_McName same, I was thinking that it'd be charcoal or something

I always thought of this trinket, but more along the lines of
"Petrified Fire"
How does this even happen

And I would be happy to try and sprite something if you give me the dimentions for it