Odd, I'm not aware of anything that I did that would cause that so unfortunately I don't really have an explanation - I wonder if there's some more complicated rerolling logic or something else going on.

had a bug where after re-rolling 4-5 times, my 10 or so passive items (including holy mantle) would just stop re-rolling, they all became fixed. very weird, had to abandon that run (the items all sucked)

Agreed, and if they don't I'll at least try to ensure that this still works if possible.

Hopefully they add this in Repentance

Thank you to who gave me the community award - that was very kind of you.

Sonicblast - did you perhaps pick a new save file recently? I ask since I just tested and it still worked fine for me, but it does rely on having the achievement to start with it.

does not seem to work anymore, not sure if there was an update that changed this, the only other mod I am using at the time was Polling of isaac

will make my life so much easier

well, it gave me some additional items, don't know why

Thanks for info,
!

It changes a random item into holy mantle, or more specifically it removes a random item and then gives you holy mantle.

hey im jc how does the mod work? i mean does it change a random item into holy mantle, or it just can't be rolled like these items i said below?

Np. Btw great mod

Very cool - I didn't know about most of those. Thanks for the info.

The D4 does not re-roll Dead Cat Dead Cat, Halo of Flies Halo of Flies, Key Piece 1 Key Piece 1, Key Piece 2 Key Piece 2, Missing No. Missing No., The Polaroid The Polaroid, The Negative The Negative, or Added in Afterbirth † Tonsil Tonsil. :P

Interesting - yeah I didn't do anything around it so it's probably just a funny coincidence.

TheGeekyHen - you should keep holy mantle in this scenario but the dead cat item will roll away. One thing I don't recall is if dead cat gives you nine lives that you keep when you reroll away from it - I think that might be the case similar to how rerolling an HP up for another character will let you keep the HP. The dead cat interaction (assuming it works like that) is unrelated to this mod.

This is something that should've been in the game from the start. Nice job.

Weird, I just tested it myself. I used the d4 in a curse room and was able to get out just fine myself. I then went to greedier in case it was specific to there. I used it in a room and was able to get hit twice before dying (a bug mentioned much earlier that I think is ok). So... I haven't been having a problem with it, but that's just me.

ok that makes sense then. I'm not positive what's causing that, but I don't think it's a bad enough bug to try to fix now - it helps it not be too too powerful.

stickfight 2 by it gets hurt he means when using the d4 the holy mantle sheild breaks for that room
(because the game tries to reroll holy mantle causing the effect of the first holy mantle dissapear)

"it gets hurt when you use the item is this supposed to happen. I'm asking because i died to it in greedier mode"
Could you give some more details? I haven't touched this mod in a while and there's a chance it's broken due to general game updates. As for using 'the item' - are you referring to the D4? It shouldn't hurt but it might be something I'd need to look into.

it gets hurt when you use the item is this supose to happen im asking cause i died to it in greedier mode

I love it! Now the D4 has some use!

This should honestly be added to the main game. Lilith keeps incubus after a build reroll, why shouldn't the lost keep the holy mantle?

Darktenki - do you have AB+?
Do you have the mod enabled in the list of mods?
Do you have the lost unlocked and starting with holy mantle?

Sorry, but I couldn't get this to work:(

I love the 2nd holy mantle bug it makes it so much more worth holding on to the D4 as the lost. Wierdly enough its kinda balanced since you have to reroll your current items to get a second mantle.

THANK YOU!

Aha, thanks!

Thank you for the feedback! I've uploaded the latest version.
Fixes:
Now works with greed and greedier - it will not reroll the restocking shops item.
Now works without the achievement - it won't activate itself until you already have the holy mantle in the run. That means if you do pick it up you can still keep it after rerolling, but if you don't start with it it won't replace your first item.

Two holy mantles still exists as a small bug. It's only for the room that you do the reroll in (it resets when you leave the room), so I might not fix that one.

Any way to tell if the player has unlocked the lost's holy mantle?

I know fixing this would kinda make this mod redundant, but when picking up the first item without a holy mantle, it gives me the holy mantle instead.

Kind of - it gives you the holy mantle for the room, which means if you already got hit you can get hit again. It shouldn't last forever though. I'll double check that as well next time I'm looking through the bugs here. Thanks for the feedback

It seems like rerolling gives you two holy mantles, which means you can take two hits of damage
before it disappears. Is that intended or what?

Thanks for letting me know - I'll look into it this weekend though I don't know what could be causing that bug.

I found a bug in greed mode. it works as intended but it also rerolls shop refresh, giving me a 2nd item and making greed mode a lot harder. hope this gets fixed :)

this is super cool somthing that should honestly be in the game already

it is helpful,thanks

Alright, I think you can probably handle that in regular update functions - though you'll need a few private variables to keep track of some stuff... though health down might be tricky. (what I can think of would turn health downs into health ups).

Keep track of player health - if they ever have a red heard replace it with soul hearts by giving them health down and a soul heart.

Undroppable trinkets I haven't really looked into so no guesses there but I like the idea.

Unrerollable items would definitely work like this - set a variable if they ever get it, and check if they ever lose it. If so remove a random item and give them it.

Hope that helps a bit.

None so far.

The Blue Baby health is mostly part of a mod idea, in which every character has blue baby health.

Determining how to make trinkets undroppable is also part of a mod concept

Unrerollable items would let me make a item that gives you increased chances for dice rooms, and let a player uses all of them without giving up one or the other of them.

Yeah I've had the concept of trying to force a trinket onto the player but didn't investigate too far into it. What are you trying to do regarding blue baby health? You could probably get away with keeping track of health yourself and whenever there's a health up add a soul heart instead. I did a bit of health logic in my coop challenge runs mod so I *might* be able to help, though it does sound like you know what you're doing. Any luck with talking to the devs?

Yeah, I've def tried to hack around that through the real world asking the developers of this game to make that bit of logic acceptableness.

Missing No. has the immunity to reroll as well.

I'm also interested in figuring out how to access the tick trinket can't be dropped, as well as blue baby's interpretation of health (i.e. adding heart containers instead adds soul hearts, and health down effects affect current soul heart)

Interesting - I think key pieces have never been rerollable (even when not in a daily), though I'm not sure about that. It's worth looking at the code, but I think there are some things that aren't really doable without writing it yourself - i.e. when modding you aren't able to call every exising piece of code inside the game.

Apparently challenge run starting items are no longer rerollable. (like key pieces and the two mom's picture items.)

I'm hoping that I can figure out how to use the same code that the game uses to enforce that for Eve, and Sampsons starting items.

ok that makes sense. I didn't think of it originally just since she doesn't start with a d4. Yeah that would be made almost identically.

That's what I mean.

Eve needs to keep it the most, because her character is the most built around her starting item (no other character depends on an item to get an effect 4/3 x damage multiplier.

He likely means so Eve keeps Whore of Babylon through rerolls

What do you mean? That Eve always has the effect even when at more than one red heart?

Can you do a similiar mod for Eve and Babylon?

I can at least explain how mine works. Whenever you are the lost but don't have holy mantle, it tries to remove a random item other than d4, d100, or clicker, and then it gives you holy mantle whether or not it succeeded in removing an item (i.e. if you didn't have anything it'll give it to you)