Ranking TOS2 Roles by Personal Enjoyment

Here are the rankings... (explanations included)

Admirer - D tier. Only above F because I can end the game feeling useful if I end up outting an evil through a Toxic Relationship. Too risky to propose.

Amne - Goes C tier because they used to be able to remember anything. Now you are forced to be in town, and you are useless N1.

Arso - Mid B tier because has one of the most satisfying victories in the game, yet is extremely hard to pull off

Baker - Terrible. Incredibly hard to pull off, and the most underwhelming NA. D tier bc I like saying :Bread

Berserker - Mid B tier. Juggernaut in ToS equivalent. Personally I wish I could attack every night

Bodyguard - I hate Bodyguard so much. Very quick role to get lynched, and you end up dying in a 1f1, not enjoyable.

Cleric - Another role to get lynched easily. Slightly more fun than Bodyguard bc no death on heal.

Conjurer - Goes close to S tier in high A tier. Incredible moments for coven are possible with Conjurer. Amazing asset

Coroner - Easily F tier. even with the new buffs. Typical evil claim

Coven Leader - A tier right next to Conjurer. You feel very powerful as CL. Possibly one of the deadliest roles in the game early on

Crusader - Id rather play Crusader than any other TP. A tier

Cursed Soul - Low C tier because I haven't played enough to form an opinion. However, I like the RNG aspect it adds.

Death - Most memorable moments come from not being found out Day 6 when many ppl are alive as Death. Incredibly satisfying, so S tier

Deputy - S tier. Say all you want about RNG shooting but shooting an evil and swaying the game in Town's favor is a tradeoff im happy to make for being a potato the rest of the game (but a confirmed potato, now you can lead town)

Doomsayer - A tier. I am biased because I recently got a N1 win.

Dreamweaver and Enchanter - both go same spot in C tier because they are easily outperformed and make for lackluster gameplay.

Executioner - A tier because its so easy to win and fun. Seer fake claim moment

Famine - D tier, if you manage to get there. Worst horsemen in the game

Hex Master - B tier. Considered A tier because of the feeling of landing a Hex Bomb in game.

Illusionist and Medusa - Worst coven roles ever. Low C tier

Investigator - Low B tier, can find killers which makes for satisfying lynches.

Jailor - Low A tier. I managed to execute 3 covens as a jailor before. However, the sheer stress of being the most powerful town role gets to me and that's why Its not in S tier

Jester - S tier. I use a new strategy every time and when it works, I leave my computer and do something more worthwhile than play this game.

Jinx - B tier. Better than Hex Master only slightly. But fails when you get noticed by more than one visitors

Lookout - High B tier. Balanced, astral, allows you to find evils and win games

Mayor - A tier. I rock Mayor scrolls so I can relax and watch as Town votes me up, then I reveal, than TPs kill each other staying on me, then Lookout finds the evils. EZ

Monarch - Step below Mayor, but the added defense allows you to be more aggressive. Not a fan of knighting N1!!!

Necro - Retri's coven cousin. Not B tier because often times you cant do much. C tier. U are the last coven often

Pestilence - C tier. Good luck not getting outted by coven/NK

Pirate - Personal favorite role. Can get frustrating but I love being Yellow #Vigilante. Highest A tier

Plaguebearer - C tier. If you become Pestilence fast enough, I consider bumping it up to B TIER.

Poisoner - Tavern Keepers's cousin. Can fake claim Tav easily but it's not fun to role-block townies, or die to SK til you have book. C tier

Potion Master - Step down from Witch in A tier. Combined with a Ritualist and you have the deadliest combo in the game

Prosecutor - Im gonna be honest, I don't like Prosecutor. Why? Ending the day when you would rather just shoot someone as Dep and then lynch another is much more satisfying. High C tier

Psychic - You end up staying alive a lot, so B tier

Retri- Corpses don't rot. Nuff said, B tier

Ritualist - A tier. Part of one of the deadliest combos in the game. Insanely fun to kill yet another person along with the book-holder

Seer - High B tier. Its stressful to be one of the most powerful town roles in the game. Its worse when people dont trust you.

SK - Low B tier. Rampage on 2 kills really bumps this guy up to a murdering machine.

Sheriff - Classic sheriff. High C tier. Finds too many Jesters as sus these days

Shroud - I find its incredibly hard to convince town you are not Shroud. I fake claim Spy a lot. BUT when it works, it satisfying AF

SC - D1 Solo SC ( A TIER )

Spy - Ok the bug feature I feel is a step down from seeing what every evils visited. Still useful though, and ez to be confirmed/lead town B tier

Tav Keep - AKA Drunk Lad. Not a fan of not being able to RB someone continually. Low C tier

Tracker - I'd rather be Werewolf and try to win for myself than be Tracker and try to win for town. Mid B tier

Trapper - There has only been a teaspoonful of games where I liked Trapper. It is satisfying though when you do kill an evil. However he is such a slow player, so low D tier

Trickster - I LOVE DYING IN 1 FOR 1S! Only low B tier because you can easily pair up with TP, or narrow down evils quickly.

Vampire - NOT ENOUGH PLAYERS! S tier.

Veteran - Allows you to be the most creative in your approach to the game. S tier

Vigilante - Would be S tier if you could shoot N1. Just sayin

Voodoo Dude - Low B tier. Silence people and get them up its fun

War - Recently got buffed, better than Werewolf tho

Werewolf - B tier. Fake Tracker buff lets you enjoy the game more

Wildling - A tier because you end up surviving long if you confirm yourself faking LO/Tracker

Witch - A tier, step above PM due to controlling abilities

Agree, Disagree? Let me know

[Cv]

Jest: I use a new strategy every time and when it works, I leave my computer and do something more worthwhile than play this game.

:fireemoji: :fireemoji: :fireemoji: :fireemoji: :fireemoji: :fireemoji:

[Cv]

Pros: Ending the day when you would rather just shoot someone as Dep and then lynch another is much more satisfying.

you... can do that. as pros. pros someone and then lynch another person. and you can do this TWICE. dep does this once.

[Cv]

Vig: Would be S tier if you could shoot N1. Just sayin

troll much? statistically speaking, random shooting hits town more than coven if town has majority.

[Cv]

adding on to spy, "x was killed by coven" has got to be the single most useless thing in the game. yeah EVERYONE can see that someone died to coven. its in the graveyard and the screen at the start of the day

[Cv]

Spy: ez to be confirmed/lead town B tier

what? spys bugs dont trigger like half the time. and how are you confirmed spy? that only happens if u see something very unique like exe target, illu. and you hang the person to confirm your bug was real.
ANYONE can say "x is doused and plagued", even the arso and pb themself

[Cv]

Adm: "Too risky to propose"

what? thats literally the ONLY thing you do. you just gonna sit around and not propose like some Survivor?

[tntcraze]

Aint no way you put VAMPIRE on the top. I would say its A tier minimum

[woolly26]

Thanks.

[gani]

Noted wooly. Im going to update this list based on the new roles added and prosecutor changes.

[woolly26]

Also Poisoner can roleblock Veteran, and poison targets with basic defense which makes this role a high B in my opinion.