Complete Gift Guide

A complete reference of all dateable characters' liked, loved and rejected gifts.

Notes

A few quick notes before we jump in:

• Gifts are not unlimited— if you gift them to someone once, they're gone for good
  
• The Racing Game and Love Letter are universally loved
  
• The guide is pretty solid at this point, but if you do notice a mistake please let me know!

Enjoy wooing your baeblades.

Gifts A-L

Gift	Rejected by (+0)	Liked by (+50)	Loved by (+75)
A Dozen Red Roses	-	Sawyer, Seven, Valeria, Leah, Jonah	Sunder, Isaac, Pocket, Rowan
A Potted Succulent	-	Rowan, Seven, Valeria, Sunder, Leah	Sawyer, Pocket, Isaac, Jonah
Ballet Tickets	Pocket	Sunder, Rowan, Sawyer, Jonah	Isaac, Seven, Valeria, Leah
Black Nail Polish	Isaac, Jonah, Leah, Pocker	Sawyer, Rowan, Valeria, Seven	Sunder
Blue Lipstick	Seven, Isaac, Jonah	Pocket, Valeria, Leah	Rowan, Sunder, Sawyer
Bouquet of Daisies	Seven	Valeria, Isaac, Sunder, Rowan	Sawyer, Pocket, Leah, Jonah
Bracelets	Isaac, Jonah	Seven, Sunder, Rowan, Sawyer, Pocket, Leah	Valeria
Cat Toy	Isaac, Sunder, Valeria, Seven, Leah, Jonah, Sawyer	Rowan	Pocket
Chocolate Truffles	Sunder	Seven, Valeria, Pocket	Sawyer, Isaac, Rowan, Leah, Jonah
Concert Tickets	Pocket	Valeria, Isaac, Leah	Sawyer, Seven, Sunder, Rowan, Jonah
Crimson Lipstick	Isaac, Jonah	Sunder, Sawyer, Seven, Pocket	Valeria, Rowan, Leah
Dark Eyeliner	Isaac, Jonah	Seven, Pocket	Rowan, Sawyer, Sunder, Valeria, Leah
Digital Camera	Leah	Valeria, Isaac, Sawyer, Jonah	Seven, Sunder, Rowan, Pocket
Fine Bourbon	Rowan, Pocket	Seven, Sawyer, Leah, Jonah	Sunder, Isaac, Valeria
Fine Gold Chain	Sawyer	Pocket, Valeria, Isaac, Sunder, Rowan, Jonah	Seven, Leah
Fine Leather Gloves	-	Seven, Sunder, Sawyer, Rowan, Leah	Pocket, Valeria, Isaac, Jonah
Fried Mackerel	Sunder, Jonah	Valeria, Isaac, Sawyer, Rowan, Leah	Seven, Pocket
Frying Pan	Leah, Pocket, Rowan, Seven, Sunder	Valeria, Isaac, Jonah	Sawyer
Glitter Eyeshadow	Pocket, Jonah	Valeria, Isaac, Sawyer, Leah	Seven, Rowan, Sunder
Gourmet Cupcake	Sunder, Pocket	Isaac, Rowan, Valeria, Jonah	Seven, Sawyer, Leah
Lighthouse Keychain	-	All	-
Love Letter	-	-	All

Gifts M-Z

Gift	Rejected by (+0)	Liked by (+50)	Loved by (+75)
McQueen Perfume	Sunder, Pocket, Jonah	Seven, Isaac	Rowan, Valeria, Sawyer, Leah
Mystery Novel	Sawyer	Pocket, Isaac, Sunder, Jonah, Leah	Valeria, Rowan, Seven
NetTV Subscription	Pocket, Isaac, Valeria, Rowan, Sunder, Jonah	Leah, Sawyer	Seven
Opera Tickets	Pocket, Sunder, Sawyer, Leah	Valeria, Jonah	Isaac, Seven, Rowan
Paintbrushes	Isaac, Sunder, Valeria, Jonah, Leah, Rowan, Seven	Pocket, Sawyer	Valeria
Pepperoni Pizza	Sunder, Jonah	Sawyer, Isaac, Valeria, Rowan	Seven, Pocket, Leah
Racing Game	-	-	All
Raspberry Liqueur	Pocket	Isaac, Seven, Rowan, Valeria, Sawyer, Jonah	Sunder, Leah
Red Rose		Valeria, Seven, Pocket, Sunder, Sawyer, Jonah, Leah	Isaac, Rowan
Sewing Machine	Isaac, Pocket, Sunder, Valeria, Sawyer, Leah, Jonah, Seven	Rowan	Leah
Silver Ring	-	Isaac, Sunder, Valeria, Seven, Rowan, Sawyer, Jonah, Leah	Pocket
Single Malt Scotch	Rowan, Sawyer, Pocket	Seven, Leah, Jonah	Sunder, Isaac, Valeria
Sneakers	-	Isaac, Sunder, Seven, Sawyer, Valeria, Rowan, Leah	Pocket, Jonah
Sword Cufflinks	Valeria, Leah	Sunder, Sawyer, Pocket, Jonah	Seven, Isaac, Rowan
Surfboard	Isaac, Pocket, Leah, Valeria, Sunder, Seven, Rowan	Sawyer	Jonah
Teddy Bear	Valeria	Sawyer, Sunder, Issac, Rowan, Leah, Jonah	Seven, Pocket
Tarot Deck	Isaac, Pocket, Sunder, Sawyer, Valeria, Seven, Jonah, Leah	-	Rowan
Travel Guide	Seven, Rowan, Sunder	Pocket, Isaac, Leah, Jonah	Sawyer, Valeria
Vodka	Valeria, Sawyer, Rowan, Pocket	Seven, Isaac, Leah, Jonah	Sunder

Thanks

I just wanted to say a HUGE thank you to all of those who took the time to comment and share their findings— it is very much appreciated by not only me but the entire community. Extra special thanks to users Sy and Dayashi for their continual input <3

Update: HUGE thanks to Dayashi again for providing all of the updated gift information after the addition of Leah and Jonah

[Shysr]

NetTV Subscription; Lighthouse Keychain; Digital Camera; Crimson & Blue Lipstick; and the Concert, Ballet, & Opera Tickets (i.e. the gifts purchased from stores rather than crafted at your workbench) are actually unlimited—you can repeatedly purchase an additional copy after gifting the one currently in your possession.

[ηιgнтмαzє]

"Straight from the horse butt"

[futureGhost]

Thanks Taye for the guide! Thanks so much Dayashi for coming in with the new content!

[Dayashi]

New Characters:
Jonah loves A Potted Succulent, Bouquet of Daisies, Chocolate Truffles, Concert Tickets, Digital Camera, Fine Leather Gloves, Love Letter, Marskye Cologne, Racing Game, Sneakers, and Surfboard.
Jonah rejects Black Nail Polish, Blue Lipstick, Bracelets, Cat Toy, Crimson Lipstick, Dark Eyeliner, Fried Mackerel, Glitter Eyeshadow, McQueen Perfume, NetTV Subscription, Paintbrushes, Pepperoni Pizza, Sewing Machine, and Tarot Deck.

Leah loves Ballet Tickets, Bouquet of Daisies, Chocolate Truffles, Crimson Lipstick, Dark Eyeliner, Fine Gold Chain, Gourmet Cupcake, Love Letter, McQueen Perfume, Pepperoni Pizza, Racing Game, Raspberry Liqueur, and Sewing Machine.
Leah rejects Black Nail Polish, Cat Toy, Digital Camera, Frying Pan, Marskye Cologne, Opera Tickets, Paintbrushes, Surfboard, Sword Cufflinks, and Tarot Deck.

[Dayashi]

New Gifts (if an option is left out, everyone else has that judgment):
Black Nail Polish [Loved: Sunder] [Rejected: Isaac, Jonah, Leah, Pocket]
Cat Toy [Loved: Pocket] [Liked: Rowan]
Frying Pan [Loved: Sawyer] [Rejected: Leah, Pocket, Rowan, Seven, Sunder]
Lighthouse Keychain [Liked by everyone]
NetTV Subscription [Loved: Seven] [Liked: Leah, Sawyer]
Paintbrushes [Loved: Valeria] [Liked: Pocket, Sawyer]
Sewing Machine [Loved: Leah] [Liked: Rowan]
Surfboard [Loved: Jonah] [Liked: Sawyer]
Tarot Deck [Loved: Rowan] [Rejected: everyone else]

[kawaiineko333]

So I don't see Jonah on here since he must be a new addition, but... he doesn't like Fried Mackerel.

[Jam]

THANK YOU! I've been purposefully trying to give bad gifts (for the achievement) and it never works. They keep liking my gifts! :(

I ended up giving Seven the blue lipstick, thanks for the guide.

[Dayashi]

Aight, now that it's complete, here's my notes of conflict:

A Dozen Red Roses [Liked: Sawyer, Seven, Valeria]
Bouquet of Daisies [Liked: Rowan]
Chocolate Truffles [Loved: Rowan]
Fine Bourbon [Rejected: Pocket] [Loved: Valeria]
Raspberry Liqueur [Liked: Sawyer]
Single Malt Scotch [Loved: Valeria]
Travel Guide [Liked: Isaac]

[Ridley_Lizzard]

Seven: Loves (+75) the Sword Cufflinks.

[Ridley_Lizzard]

Rowan: Likes (+50) the Teddy Bear. (NEW!)

Sunder: Likes (+50) the Bracelets. (confirmed)