Disputes and how to solve them! (Judgement in From the Ashes DLC)

All Judgements and what they do, so you know how to choose :P

General Guide-related Info

This is a sibling Guide to ...

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1322099232

Check out the Main Guide if you need more help. There is a full step by step guide under "From the Ashes" DLC Achievements on how to rebuild Pribyslavitz in the easierst/fastes way - make the most profit and get the achievements! :)

This guide is working as of the 1.6 Update!

What are Disputes? Why should i do Judgements?

Disputes happen everywhere - specially in your little village Pribyslavitz! Thats why as Bailif you have to judge whos right and whos wrong in order to have a stable population and order. This is real medival practice and in Kingdom Come will be done under a big tree (called court linden in medival ages, as it was a linden tree)...
There you'll find a little lectern to hear about what troubles your people and speak judgment to them... for the good or worse of the village.

In Kingdom come, your decisions matter a lot for the village Income or its population.

You can make some achievements missable if you decide badly a couple of times and loose a lot of money respectively wich is why i wrote down all disputes, their possible judgments and their outcomes!

It can make a difference ranging from a bonus +370 Groschen (with bakery) to a negative -145 (all bad judgements). So as you can see, thes a lot to lose but also to gain!

Note: in the beginning you'll likely get a Judgment/Dispute everyday after 10 AM and you get new ones with new buildings and/or hired NPCs.
At some day you'll only get a Dispute every second day and once you did them all they'll just stop.
You can save right before judging to randomize the event and load if you made a bad call

All Disputes and their Judgements

G/d obviously means "Groschen per day"

Also pp. will mean "people/citizens"

- wich can only be increased by building and judgement, there are 40 needed for the "From the Ashes"-Main quest.

Best/most profitable decision marked in blue!

If theres none, they have different kinds of benefits (mostly more money or more people. Depends on what you need)

Problem	Prequisite	Decision 1	Decision 2	Decision 3	Decision 4
Locators Wage	First decision when you start out	stay = -55 G/d	raise = -80 G/d	overpay = -120 G/d	-
Poaching	Your people break the law	Leave them be = +30 G/d	Warn them once = -10 G/d	Punish them = +40 G/d -1pp.	-
Streams and Sh!t	None.	100 ft = +5 G/d	150 ft = -5 G/d +1 pp.	whereever = -2 pp.	-
Woman and Witchcraft	None.	dont waste my time = +30 G/d +2pp.	its nothing serious = +30 G/d +2pp.	she is envious = +30 G/d +2pp.	punish Herbwoman = +45 G/d +1pp.
Lumir vs Luch	None.	Sided w. Lumir = Luch leaves	Sided w. Luch = Lumir leaves	-	-
trouble with Fritz & Matthew	hired F&M after thier Questline	Let them off = nothing	kick them out = +30 G/day as their -15 each get removed	give them a last chance = +50 G/day, as their -15 each gets turned into +10 each	-
Raspberry's wife	hired Raspberry	let Rasberry stay = +5 G/d	let him leave = -35 G/d?	Give Dowry = 1000 G (one time)
Two Butchers	Butcher build	hire Kochwurst (dishonest) = +50 G/d	hire Brisket (disgraced) = +45 G/d	-	-
Baker Silvester wants to join	Bakery build	hire = +75 G/day	let go = no change	punish = no change	-
Weight of Bread	Silvester hired	Municipal Scales + Maintenance Skill level 4 = +20 G/d +2pp.	dont change = -2pp. ?	Black Bread = - 10 G/d +30 G/d	Bigger Bread = -40 G/d
Ambushed Wagons	None? Trader?	Take from your citizens = -2pp.	Ask Hanush = 500 G (one time)	-	-
Drunken Husband	Tavern?	Nothing happend = Nothing?	Forbade him to drink again = +5 G/d	Banish the woman = -30 G/d -1pp.	-
Guard needed	build Gardhouse	Volunteer none = -2pp. on Rathaus	Volunteer Labourers = -10G/d	Volunteer Woodcutters = -10G/d	Volunteer both = -20 G/d (-10 on each)
Woodcutters Work	Finished reconstruction of the village	No longer needed = +90 G/d -10 pp.	Stockpile = nothing	Sell Wood = +180 G/d	-

Last words and thank you...

Made from my own gameplay experiance and some research on...

• http://kingdom-come-deliverance.wikia.com/
  
• https://www.reddit.com/r/kingdomcome

Also thanks to my helpful & patient commenters [Sexy]Brummbär and Verto! :)

If something is wrong, please let me know in the comments below! Also leave a like if this was helpful to you - so that i make more helpfull things in teh future <3 xD

[Ary]

Other than that thank you guys for the comments, i'll check on these later and see what/how to add them :)

[Ary]

@Zanthe :
"people/citizens can only be increased by building and judgement, there are 40 needed for the "From the Ashes"-Main quest.

[Zanthe]

The wiki says there is a 5th option now for the second baker decision, where you keep the things the same at the cost of 2 people, but you get +50 gp. Also, are the +- people a daily thing, and should I care? What does having max people even get us?

[RoadToFistinière]

Not sure it is useful since it is not the best outcome anyway, maybe as a side note for the fun fact. But I suspect that you might be able to pickpocket your money back from the locator for the "Ambushed Wagons dispute". I have not tried it so i can't be sure.

[Ary]

Wow really? thats cool and funny xD Thanks for mentioning this! Not sure if i should write this into the guide though?

[RoadToFistinière]

I would like to add that when you give the dowry you can pickpocket back your money with no consequences (unless you get caught obviously).

[Jackie]

Yeah, I totally get that, no worries :)

[Ary]

No that wasnt implemented for the choises noted here when i wrote this guide. I mean it would make sense that they would influence your village but.... well good to know. I'll think about replaying the dlc but atm i dotn even have time to finish the main guide and so its not one of my priorities anytime soon (since its not game breaking or really important as far as i can see) :S

But big thanks for bringing it to my attention :D

[Jackie]

Oh really? Sorry, I didn't know that they've made many changes since release. I meant the Reputation one has in the different cities/areas. Like, when you steal or hit someone you lose reputation or when you trade successfully you gain reputation.
I thought that was some cool element to add to your guide bc the decisions you make in P. have consequences like that too and there's also an achievement for which one has to have a lot of reputation in all the cities. But ofc if that's new to you I totally get why it's not included :)

[Ary]

@Jackie excuse me, but what kind of reputation do you mean? I dont remember that part at all...? maybe it got patched in? Bc if it was in the game before i probably would have put it in the table above....but i cant remember any of this, i'm really drawing blanks rn :O