The graphic is ridiculous, 2D in Deponia style would have made this a very nice game.
The controls are a nightmare instead, and the camera angles are simply stupid and annoying.
The story is nice, the puzzles are ok most of the times.

Graphic: 1/10 simply terrible
Controls: 1/10 a nightmare, mostly becouse of the stupid idea of making this game in 3D
Audio: 8/10 well done, totally monkey island style, music blends perfectly, no memorable theme
Puzzles and jokes: 6/10 they will make you smile from time to time, bring memory of the past games, and keep you engaged. Just a few puzzles are too boring, requiring way too much going back and forth.
Story: 5/10 not that bad, but goes way too far sometimes
Monkey Island feeling: 4/10 you don't get that monkey island feeling very much, except for some rare parts

My vote: 4/10
A missed opportunity. Some poor design choices, for a game that deserved better, and could have been better with a different graphic style, better controls and more attention to some boring puzzles.

The graphic is ridiculous, 2D in Deponia style would have made this a very nice game. The controls are a nightmare instead, and the camera angles are simply stupid and annoying. The story is nice, the puzzles are ok most of the times. Graphic: 1/10 simply terrible Controls: 1/10 a nightmare, mostly becouse of the stupid idea of making this game in 3D Audio: 8/10 well done, totally monkey island style, music blends perfectly, no memorable theme Puzzles and jokes: 6/10 they will make you smile from time to time, bring memory of the past games, and keep you engaged. Just a few puzzles are too boring, requiring way too much going back and forth. Story: 5/10 not that bad, but goes way too far sometimes Monkey Island feeling: 4/10 you don't get that monkey island feeling very much, except for some rare parts My vote: 4/10 A missed opportunity. Some poor design choices, for a game that deserved better, and could have been better with a different graphic style, better controls and more attention to some boring puzzles.