Just found this site a few months ago and sad to see it go! I had a bunch of keys for games that I wasn't interested in and traded them very quickly for games that I was. I won't be taking chances on any Fanatical mystery keys anymore without a way to get rid of those that just aren't my type of game.

I would be happy to join in with the others in volunteering to help maintain it in some way, unless there's a legal or other major reason it is actually being shut down.

Would second the idea to run ads and turn it into something that you make a bit of money off of. I don't think anyone using it would mind if you were fairly compensated for the amount of traffic the site gets. It really is the only thing that I've found out there like it.