所有讨论 > Steam 论坛 > Off Topic > 主题详情
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 5 日 上午 11:59
My grandfather was in the Afrikakorps (DAK)
My grandfather was in the Afrikakorps (DAK).
Since in real life, people are really interested in hearing about it, have so many questions and like to see items he gave me from that time, I thought some people on here might be interested in this topic and want to ask questions.

Also, he was a POW with the British and then a POW with the U.S, located in the United States in a POW camp, so if you wanna know anything, ask.

So if this is your thing, shoot !

PS: I will only answer questions that are meant serious, I hope you understand. THx.
最后由 Zeno 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 12:07
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 39 条留言
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:05 
引用自 Morkonan
引用自 Gungnir

He was a musician with the Luftwaffe.
This means, he was attached to numerous companies and so on. At the beginning he was with the FLAK, then later on reconnaisance and infantry companies/divisions that somehow the Luftwaffe was attached to, to some extend.

What I can tell you is, he was riding a bicycle with his comrades, when one or two British soldiers stopped them on some road and decided to take them hostage. lol. So the bike was probably a Wehrmacht bike.

Sorry to not have any cooler vehicles to offer, I assume he was riding on the usual Opel Blitz, Kubelwagen and so on, all kinds of transport vehicles, SDFK and such.

Cool!

What instrument did he play and how many were in the band?

What was the most popular, contemporary, non-military song that was requested or that he played most often? (some popular, catchy tune, of the day)

Did he, or was he allowed, to perform as a PoW?

Did he pursue music after the war?

I think there were around 8-12 people in his actual band ?
But due to his rank, he hada " Zug " with him which were a lot more people.

He played numerous instruments, guitar, trumpet and so on, unfortunately I suck at all instruments so I would not know all the names. But I think he could play most instruments pretty well.

He did not play so much in the military marching group, it was more about officer mess and such, music in pubs and such, when soldiers wanted to drink and have fun. The official songs he only played at the beginning, during the war no one wanted to hear this and you won't believe it, but he mostly played American Jazz/blues music, which was what the German soldiers wanted to hear the most.

Yes he performed as a PoW, in fact he had to perform. He was also allowed to leave the PoW camp and play for local civilians and soldiers in pubs to earn some extra coins. The Americans treated him super human and never felt like an enemy to him, he even taught U.S soldiers to play.

Yes, he kept being a musician after the war.
He unfortunately lived in East-Germany, so funny enough, they wanted him to get a new certificate to be allowed to work as a musician...its a joke really ! But yeah, he stuck to it until the day he died and my father learnt everything he knows about music from him

His band by the way, played also in the USSR during the 70s and 80s, his son, so my grandfather, met them in soviet Ukraine in some worker's camp, he was sent to as a German worker. Its funny, he greeted them and was surprised to see his fathers band playing, since his father retired.

I could probably write a book about all this and I eventually will.
Stranger 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:07 
Alright, so how do you know he's your grandfather? Just given his promiscuity this seems reasonable enough to ask, but I don't mean any offense.

And how do you know he's not a robot? He might be working for the King.
最后由 Stranger 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:07
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:10 
引用自 Stranger
Alright, so how do you know he's your grandfather? Just given his promiscuity this seems reasonable enough to ask, but I don't mean any offense.

And how do you know he's not a robot? He might be working for the King.

...
Morkonan 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:11 
Thanks so very much for sharing, Gungnir!

引用自 Gungnir
...
He said, don't even start doing that, once you have started, you can't stop anymore otherwise you are in trouble. lol.

That's true. I brought my wife flowers every single Friday. :) After awhile, I changed it up a bit and would pick up something different on Fridays. (Am now divorced, so I guess the whole "demonstrating love, affection, and thoughtfulness" thing didn't work so great? :))

On wounded - Yeah, I thought as much. And, yes, leaving wounded to the care of the "enemy" was a thing between professional militaries... Well, up to a point, because there were some one did not leave the wounded behind, for.

By all accounts, PoWs of the US generally had it much better than some others. Part of that was that they could be shipped overseas with little possibility of escaping and returning to combat. In many PoW camps in the US, PoWs were paroled daily to take up actually paying jobs (not at full rate, I don't think) in the nearby community. Some even volunteered for community projects - A street where I once lived had a wide median and the nearby German PoWs took up a "beautification" project for it. AFAIK, there was never a bad report of German PoWs in such parole programs where I used to live.

On wounded - I know they couldn't get shipped to Europe, but it just seemed nearly impossible to get a load of wounded to any nearby kind of catchment area that's suitable for further treatment. (I don't know enough about Africa, obviously. :)) I can certainly see being pressed and forced to leave the wounded behind for enemy medical teams to deal with. (PoW Medics were, AFAIK, treated well by both sides and Medics treated the injured in their care, regardless of their uniform as best as I understand it.)
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:16 
引用自 Morkonan
Thanks so very much for sharing, Gungnir!

引用自 Gungnir
...
He said, don't even start doing that, once you have started, you can't stop anymore otherwise you are in trouble. lol.

That's true. I brought my wife flowers every single Friday. :) After awhile, I changed it up a bit and would pick up something different on Fridays. (Am now divorced, so I guess the whole "demonstrating love, affection, and thoughtfulness" thing didn't work so great? :))

On wounded - Yeah, I thought as much. And, yes, leaving wounded to the care of the "enemy" was a thing between professional militaries... Well, up to a point, because there were some one did not leave the wounded behind, for.

By all accounts, PoWs of the US generally had it much better than some others. Part of that was that they could be shipped overseas with little possibility of escaping and returning to combat. In many PoW camps in the US, PoWs were paroled daily to take up actually paying jobs (not at full rate, I don't think) in the nearby community. Some even volunteered for community projects - A street where I once lived had a wide median and the nearby German PoWs took up a "beautification" project for it. AFAIK, there was never a bad report of German PoWs in such parole programs where I used to live.

On wounded - I know they couldn't get shipped to Europe, but it just seemed nearly impossible to get a load of wounded to any nearby kind of catchment area that's suitable for further treatment. (I don't know enough about Africa, obviously. :)) I can certainly see being pressed and forced to leave the wounded behind for enemy medical teams to deal with. (PoW Medics were, AFAIK, treated well by both sides and Medics treated the injured in their care, regardless of their uniform as best as I understand it.)

Yeah I didn't even start that habit :D

Regarding the wounded, I assume you are right. But he was a musician so I truly don't know how they handled the wounded part in Africa. I know he became SUPER SICK at some point in Africa.

My other family members ,so my mother's side's grandparents or my grans brothers were all fighting in Europe not in Africa. Mostly eastern frontline. So the stories are completely different.

All I know is, ALL of my grandparents and great-grandparents only spoke in the highest tones about U.S soldiers. Every single one of them had only positive experiences with them.

They were very humane and respected us Germans to the core.

This is very different when it comes to Soviet soldiers and the British as well as the French.

You are welcome btw, I wish more people would ask decent questions.
最后由 Zeno 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:20
Morkonan 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:20 
引用自 Gungnir
...
He did not play so much in the military marching group, it was more about officer mess and such, music in pubs and such, when soldiers wanted to drink and have fun. The official songs he only played at the beginning, during the war no one wanted to hear this and you won't believe it, but he mostly played American Jazz/blues music, which was what the German soldiers wanted to hear the most...

Yup, I've heard that as well - Jazz was extremely popular on all fronts. :)

...I could probably write a book about all this and I eventually will.

History dies if it is not written down.

This is a truism and we all do well to remember it. Nothing on the Internet is forever and it will ALL go away, eventually. A book is the most accessible, longest-lived, form of communication outside of stone tablets... Well, maybe safely stored bronze, but that's getting a bit fancy. :)

Stories that could be told of these experiences are priceless.

I listened to a remembered a German neighbor of mine's stories with something of that intent. Her family had it rough, as many Germans did at the height of the war. They got by on trading potatoes to soldiers and, then, making vodka out of them and trading that to whoever would trade.

In another place I lived, my neighbor was one of the first women who landed on the beach at Normandy. (General staff)

“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” – George Santayana

He was talking about... libraries. :)
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 5 日 下午 1:26 
引用自 Morkonan
引用自 Gungnir
...
He did not play so much in the military marching group, it was more about officer mess and such, music in pubs and such, when soldiers wanted to drink and have fun. The official songs he only played at the beginning, during the war no one wanted to hear this and you won't believe it, but he mostly played American Jazz/blues music, which was what the German soldiers wanted to hear the most...

Yup, I've heard that as well - Jazz was extremely popular on all fronts. :)

...I could probably write a book about all this and I eventually will.

History dies if it is not written down.

This is a truism and we all do well to remember it. Nothing on the Internet is forever and it will ALL go away, eventually. A book is the most accessible, longest-lived, form of communication outside of stone tablets... Well, maybe safely stored bronze, but that's getting a bit fancy. :)

Stories that could be told of these experiences are priceless.

I listened to a remembered a German neighbor of mine's stories with something of that intent. Her family had it rough, as many Germans did at the height of the war. They got by on trading potatoes to soldiers and, then, making vodka out of them and trading that to whoever would trade.

In another place I lived, my neighbor was one of the first women who landed on the beach at Normandy. (General staff)

“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” – George Santayana

He was talking about... libraries. :)

Man..I could tell you some stories.. its insane.
Now my wife is Ukrainian, so the stories expanded, now we have soviet and modern era UA stories, its crazy.
Sherasonni 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 3:22 
1. Did he have a girlfriend during that war? Has he ever dated any of the locals outside of Germany?

2. During which years did he serve? Was he in Poland, the Netherlands and France before he went to North Africa? Did he take part in Czechoslovakia before WWII?

3. Does he know Bert Kaempfert and/or Charly Tabor?

4. Did he play this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nqelq9NfvxU

5. It has been said that on the arrival date of the Afrika Korps, the military vehicles went around in circles (around one or more blocks?) to make them look more numerous. Has your grandfather ever mentioned this?

6. What did he say about his Italian allies?

7. What did he say about the British/Australians and the Americans in North Africa?
最后由 Sherasonni 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 3:30
TGC> The Games Collector 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 3:31 
A war musician?

hah, what is his opinion on "Entry of the gladiators", and what it's used for now?
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 3:41 
引用自 Sherasonni
1. Did he have a girlfriend during that war? Has he ever dated any of the locals outside of Germany?

2. During which years did he serve? Was he in Poland, the Netherlands and France before he went to North Africa? Did he take part in Czechoslovakia before WWII?

3. Does he know Bert Kaempfert and/or Charly Tabor?

4. Did he play this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nqelq9NfvxU

5. It has been said that on the arrival date of the Afrika Korps, the military vehicles went around in circles (around one or more blocks?) to make them look more numerous. Has your grandfather ever mentioned this?

6. What did he say about his Italian allies?

7. What did he say about the British/Australians and the Americans in North Africa?

1. He was married and had kids, but we are all certain he had numerous girlfriends outside of Germany.

2. He was right there in 39, invasion on Poland, France, Netherlands I don't know.

3. Maybe by hearing about them? But I don't think he met any of them.

4. I am 100% certain he did.

5. No. And it does not sound anything the German military would do.

6. I can't remember him ever mentioning Italians.

7. Nothing about Australians. He mentioned the British and Americans. He said the Brits did not treat him well while the Americans did treat him very well.



A war musician?

hah, what is his opinion on "Entry of the gladiators", and what it's used for now?

No, just a musician who happened to also become a musician during the war :)

I never heard him mentioning this song, keep in mind, I did not discuss particular songs with my grandfather, he was a musician, I mostly wanted to know about his experience during the war and read his diaries.
Sherasonni 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 4:28 
引用自 Gungnir
引用自 Sherasonni
5. It has been said that on the arrival date of the Afrika Korps, the military vehicles went around in circles (around one or more blocks?) to make them look more numerous. Has your grandfather ever mentioned this?
5. No. And it does not sound anything the German military would do.
I see. I read it in an old history book, but I can't remember which one. I think it's in one of Time-Life's World War II series: 'The War in the Desert.' I didn't know if that story was true and was wondering if your grandfather ever mentioned it. Thanks for answering.
最后由 Sherasonni 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 4:28
Zeno (已封禁) 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 4:55 
引用自 Sherasonni
引用自 Gungnir
5. No. And it does not sound anything the German military would do.
I see. I read it in an old history book, but I can't remember which one. I think it's in one of Time-Life's World War II series: 'The War in the Desert.' I didn't know if that story was true and was wondering if your grandfather ever mentioned it. Thanks for answering.

Its possible. I did not read it though.
De Hollandse Ezel 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 5:13 
never heared that afrika song...
interesting to hear a song I not yet knew..

there is a song that my dad remembered the germans singing in ww2.. that I never quite heared anywhere..

he offten metioned a strofe :

wir sind von k und von k infratrieregiment, wir sind heimmaster numbero EINZ
wir sind von k und von k infratrieregiment, wir sind heimmaster numbero EINZ
wir wollen weiter machieren uber der ganzer welt
heute geheurd uns Deutchland, morgen der ganzer welt.

das k&k song however if you find it today is some tiroler carnaval song..
how he remembered it is was a marching song..
最后由 De Hollandse Ezel 编辑于; 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 5:18
Pieshaman 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 5:32 
I once painted the africa korps in 1:72 scale. I also had a halftrack painted in their colours.
the layer of dust they under is as thick as the sahara desert by now though, somewhere in the garage attic of my parents house.
With a bit of bad luck they been put in the same box as the US marine corps, fighting over the garage for almost 3 decades now.
Sherasonni 2024 年 3 月 6 日 上午 5:54 
I posted my previous questions before reading the others' posts. I realize that you already answered some of my questions. Here are more of my questions:

引用自 Gungnir
引用自 Morkonan
3) How in the world did the Afrika Corps deal with wounded and casualties operating in such mobile conditions, sometimes seemingly far South of the Coast? I know that they had ports available, sometimes more than others, but in the regions a lot of the fighting took place, it would seem impossible to transport wounded to a friendly area or through non-hostile regions.

4) Africa is big... It's nearly impossible to fathom the distances traveled by major elements of the Afrika Corps to/from various engagements. (It's just very hard to truly conceptualize conducting mobile warfare at such a scale.) What's the farthest your grandfather may have traveled during operational movement, maybe in a week or so? (Depending on how long it took to get where they were going. :))
3. He was in " El Alamein ", so everything he said or shared is based on his experience there. Remember ,they had no internet back then but his 10 brothers who all died in war, were in combat units across the globe in various units. So some of what I know is based on that as well.

As you know, El Alamein region is close to the sea, when they had wounded, they usually had to transport them back with combat units or used planes for local " Med Points ". It was extremely rare that soldiers were actually transported back to Germany or Italy for treatment, this was only in extreme cases, they did manage to heal people up over there in Africa as well.

My grandfather said in some extreme scenarios he heard about, they did send wounded to the British, just so they can survive, the same happened the other way around by the way.

4. I would have to lie to be honest. I don't know. He was a musician, so he was mostly in larger Luftwaffe bases or in camps, but never in an actual trench directly on the frontline. However, when he travelled this was either by " Opel Blitz " , " Camel " or some other type of KfZ.
The battlefront in North Africa moved back and forth in great distances multiple times. I heard that El Alamein was the furthest that the Afrika Korps and the Italian divisions reached into Egypt. Did your grandfather witness or hear about the British artillery barrage against the Afrika Korps at El Alamein? Britain's counterattack began after that. The Afrika Korps withdrew all the way to Tunisia.


引用自 Gungnir
引用自 steven1mac
He was luck to be captured earlier in the war, otherwise he could of ended up on the Eastern Front or one of the many German prisoners who were killed (this happened on both East and West front) as revenge once the fate of the war was decided on who was going to win.
He was not captured early. He was captured in 1944 or 1945.

He was sent to France, then Italy, then Africa.

His brothers were fighting on the eastern-front though and I do know their stories, one of which went to Siberia as a POW and walked back from there to Germany (there is even a movie about such prisoners).
If he was captured in 1944 or 1945, then he must've escaped to Europe before getting captured. The Axis forces in North Africa surrendered in 1943.

Was your grandfather's brother in Stalingrad? Where in the USSR did he get captured?

引用自 Gungnir
引用自 Morkonan
What was the most popular, contemporary, non-military song that was requested or that he played most often? (some popular, catchy tune, of the day)
He did not play so much in the military marching group, it was more about officer mess and such, music in pubs and such, when soldiers wanted to drink and have fun. The official songs he only played at the beginning, during the war no one wanted to hear this and you won't believe it, but he mostly played American Jazz/blues music, which was what the German soldiers wanted to hear the most.
That reminds me of this movie...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YibBVIYwQWs
...and a documentary about the popularity of US and British jazz and culture in Germany during that time.


引用自 Gungnir
He unfortunately lived in East-Germany, so funny enough, they wanted him to get a new certificate to be allowed to work as a musician...its a joke really ! But yeah, he stuck to it until the day he died and my father learnt everything he knows about music from him
Did he talk about the USSR's occupation of eastern Germany during that war?
< >
正在显示第 16 - 30 条,共 39 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

所有讨论 > Steam 论坛 > Off Topic > 主题详情
发帖日期: 2024 年 3 月 5 日 上午 11:59
回复数: 39