Do 2 Marbles STACK their wonder production bonuses?

[Lickmajora]

, as in 15% + 15% = 30% wonder production bonus anceint era? capitalized STACK?

[Timbermaw]

Nope, each resource only counts once pretty much

[Laluzi]

No. That would be absurdly overpowered. (Besides, you could have answered this yourself by mousing over the tooltip for production inside your city.)

[just.nuke.em]

Nope. It will stack with the 15% pantheon belief and tradition policy, and then Egypt's 20%, for a grand total of +65% if you are that lukcy as Egypt.

[lewosch]

This question made me think about luxury placement of standard Civ 5 maps. (pangaea, continents, fractal, archipelago etc.) I have never seen 2 different marble tiles so close enough that both can remain in a specific city's working range. They are usually spread out on the game's map, unless it's a mod/custom one. I have a long gameplay time on Civ 5 and frequently leave the game and restart a new one when I get past 80 or 100 turns if I don't like the map's layout or decide to try something new.

As for the question; no, the bonuses don't stack, it will still be 15% for ancient and classical era wonders.

The game also has a hidden rule for marble and salt : Marble and Salt never spawn inside a city-state's 3-tile working range. In very rare occassions, city-state borders can reach beyond 3 tiles and acquire a marble/salt tile which is 4 tile away. The city-state will improve the resource with its worker and give it to you if you're allied to them, but city-state itself doesn't get the tile yield (food, production, gold) of it.

I know, my post is somewhat off-topic, but I think it was interesting trivia which is "possibly" never mentioned anywhere.

[Laluzi]

The only time I've ever seen two marble in range of a city was on an Earth map, which has very different rules for luxuries. Marble does seem to be a 'bonus' luxury that doesn't behave quite like any other.

I never knew that about salt!

[Lickmajora]

Originally posted by Laluzi:

No. That would be absurdly overpowered. (Besides, you could have answered this yourself by mousing over the tooltip for production inside your city.)

i never had such a situation with 2 of them, it was just a hypothetical,... oops i meant HYPOthetICAL

[Lickmajora]

Originally posted by lewosch:

This question made me think about luxury placement of standard Civ 5 maps. (pangaea, continents, fractal, archipelago etc.) I have never seen 2 different marble tiles so close enough that both can remain in a specific city's working range. They are usually spread out on the game's map, unless it's a mod/custom one. I have a long gameplay time on Civ 5 and frequently leave the game and restart a new one when I get past 80 or 100 turns if I don't like the map's layout or decide to try something new.

As for the question; no, the bonuses don't stack, it will still be 15% for ancient and classical era wonders.

The game also has a hidden rule for marble and salt : Marble and Salt never spawn inside a city-state's 3-tile working range. In very rare occassions, city-state borders can reach beyond 3 tiles and acquire a marble/salt tile which is 4 tile away. The city-state will improve the resource with its worker and give it to you if you're allied to them, but city-state itself doesn't get the tile yield (food, production, gold) of it.

I know, my post is somewhat off-topic, but I think it was interesting trivia which is "possibly" never mentioned anywhere.

I got interesting trivia for someone like you... on the Huge Earth Map, on the geographically representative tile for the west side of the Suez Canal, despite it being clearly a river tile, it is NOT considered a river tile. Some tributary vs outlet rule.

[Laluzi]

Originally posted by Lickmajora:

Originally posted by Laluzi:

No. That would be absurdly overpowered. (Besides, you could have answered this yourself by mousing over the tooltip for production inside your city.)

i never had such a situation with 2 of them, it was just a hypothetical,... oops i meant HYPOthetICAL

Still doing that, huh.

It's obnoxious. Like somehow the rest of the world can't understand your sentences unless you're screaming them.

Interestingly enough, I just rolled a continents map where I had marble in my capital - and found another marble 3 tiles away. Granted, this was on Legendary Start resource rules, so it's possible the capital marble was spawned after that other marble.

[Lickmajora]

nah, dont get mad, i just think its funny that you're the SOLE person that gets irritated by it enough to bring it up multiple times.., like you have a low threshold for what you find obnoxious...and that you associate caps with screaming....

for example, I just received an email message from ebay with the subject line "ORDER CONFIRMED" .... how dare they scream at me and not just politely write "order confirmed" ? the audacity.., i will call customer service and complain....lol

anyway, most associate exclamation marks !!!!! with screaming tho

[Lurksmore]

Exclamation points are emphasis, caps are yelling.

https://newrepublic.com/article/117390/netiquette-capitalization-how-caps-became-code-yelling

[Lickmajora]

well then how dare ebay and amazon yell at their customers.

[SamBC]

As far as I'm concerned, capitalising isolated words or short phrases for emphasis is fine. Whole sentences is yelling.

[billgordon10]

I'm not 100% sure, but I think Marble and salt will be within 3 tiles of a city-state. You say that it is 4 tiles or more, and that may be so. I know I have seen marble in a city-state.