The scene with the wind chime was stupid.

[Noah]

Am I the only one that felt this way? It seemed so over-dramatic with the emotional music and everything. I mean, wow, walkers are attracted to sound, big woop. Were we supposed to be surprised that they went to the noise?

[Pvt. Martin]

Thats what i thought at first, but after pondering for awhile im begining to think that its going to become a variable thats going to factor into the ending.

Possably in how AJ will deal with Clem if bitten; come the finale....just a theory.

[Noah]

Originally posted by Pvt. Martin:

Thats what i thoguht kinda at first, but after pondering for awhile im begining to think that its going to become a variable thats going factor into the ending; come the finale.

Possably in how AJ will deal with Clem if bitten...just a theroy.

That's actually a pretty interesting thought...

[RM1985]

I hope not, cause if Clem gets bitten, then the francise should've been buried alongside Telltale!!

[Zaloza]

Nah, I iked it. The music might have been a bit over-the-top, but I think the scene was quite touching, and the questions raised by the scene, and by James' beliefs in general, are very interesting.
The fact that walkers respond to stimuli like sound shows that they still have some kind of awareness, some kind of consciousness, and they're not just mindless, evil monsters - more like stupid animals who don't know any better. Like sheep who eat people.
I don't know, maybe there is still something human inside walkers, like James thinks. Maybe there's still something inside a walker that allows them to not only respond to a beautiful wind chime sound, but to... appreciate it, maybe?
Like Clem says, there's no way to know for sure. But I found it really interesting to take a deeper, more compassionate look at the walkers - creatures who, until now, were depicted as nothing but terrifying threats.

[Jaldhuar]

It could have been interesting if James was more present in this scene or if this scene was longer, it could have show better how much James is rly crazy. Because to say walkers have a soul because they react to sound (like they always have done so far) is maybe the single dumbest idea I ever heard in this story (and we had some pretty dumb characters).

[mutantbeth]

It was interesting how AJs point of view changed after that. but yea it was a dramatic scene fo no reason. lol