Ending Where 55% Did not

[BtwRant]

55% did not kill lilly..
Damn you guy belive in the good of people.
And now ur james dead.
Bruuh da fuq

[xlightthefuse]

I might just go back and replay and do the opposite and not kill her, tempted to

[MShields]

she still had a knife, so i didn't give her any chances and let aj do it

[BtwRant]

Ursprungligen skrivet av MShields:

she still had a knife, so i didn't give her any chances and let aj do it

thank you i was she has the knife in her leg and if i dont shoot her she will murder.
I would so. yea..

[Dixon]

Hi, i didn't kill her, AJ shouldn't to do it. I want, that would Clem killed Lilly (maybe it's will be happen in 4 episode). In advance, sorry for my english.

[Pitchooz]

Ursprungligen skrivet av Captain_Dope:

I don't think she died. She was "only" shot in the cheek. So she might be back to have a final showdown against Clementine.

Dude, she died. Even if she somehow manage to survive bullet in the cheek I don't think she can survive being shot multiple times afterwards.

[mbz]

Ursprungligen skrivet av Captain_Dope:

I don't think she died. She was "only" shot in the cheek. So she might be back to have a final showdown against Clementine.

Carley also "only" got shot in the cheek, she died. The ending scenes confirm Lilly's death.

[Mooman]

Like all determinant fates in the end it probably won't matter, Lilly and James will both die.

James to this point has served his story usefulness and by removing him walkers can be a hazard again.

Lilly was just the ultimate bad guy to push your descision to make AJ shoot or not which will affect him somehow in the future.

Both have fulfilled their story role and can be discarded like so many other characters have throughout the series (Carley, Doug, Duck, Kataja, Michael, Ben, Clarrisa, Omid, Chuck, Luke, Carlos, Sarah, Rebecca, and even Lee).

[Dimanyc]

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ spoilers...

[BtwRant]

Ursprungligen skrivet av KorsaTuS:

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ spoilers...

yea the titel was not clear enough on that x'D

[Sea-shroom]

its bull we could have tied her up but noo james had to stand infront of her nice

[Nuarda]

i was like... oke... i can't let AJ do this... but then again i can't let lilly live either.. not after everything... the woman is crazy and many many people will die...
AJ can be fixed, just friggin kill her.

Now im reading that James would die if i chose to not kill lilly... im kinda glad i went for this ending of the episode.
Not that i care about James, more that i wouldn't care about him dieing.
And i do care about the psychological effects that it will have on AJ.
Now if sparing Lilly would had caused Tenn to die, that having another psychological effect on AJ and me caring about Tenn would had hit me. (it was what i expected to be the other ending tbh).

brings me to the final thing, was it just me or was this entire episode a little dissapointing?
the choices where not really choices (clearly as for most part more then 90% of the players made the same decissions untill the last one that was about 45-55) the story was alright, it was interesting but there just been better choice moments in a telltale game i think...

[Vladislak]

Like I said in another thread, for me it wasn't about Lilly and what she'd done in the past. It was about the kind of person you wanted to guide AJ into becoming. To that end I don't regret sparing Lilly at all. Lilly needs to be stopped, but not in a way that pushes AJ even further down the mental slope he's already rapidly sliding down.

And honestly I don't think James would regret it either, he seemed like the kind of guy who'd be willing to die to prevent a 5 year old from becoming a monster. But that's just my take on his personality.

[Stellifera]

She had the knife in her leg so... I was like "SHOOOOTOOOOOOOOTTTT HEERRARARARRA!"

[KoalaTux]

Ursprungligen skrivet av BtwRant:

55% did not kill lilly..
Damn you guy belive in the good of people.
And now ur james dead.
Bruuh da fuq

It's not about the good of people, it's about AJ. I just dont want him to be some ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up serial killer, I mean he could grow up to be just as bad as Lily's group if he isnt raised properly. Usually you can get little foreshadow dialouge from other characters, for example James talks about how the killing in his childhood made him an emotionless killer. Dont forget that the point of this game is to create a balance in AJ for him being able to survive, but grow up properly, also in my opinion I feel like James wasnt developed enough for me to feel full emotion for his death.

[KoalaTux]

Ursprungligen skrivet av Nuarda:

i was like... oke... i can't let AJ do this... but then again i can't let lilly live either.. not after everything... the woman is crazy and many many people will die...
AJ can be fixed, just friggin kill her.

Now im reading that James would die if i chose to not kill lilly... im kinda glad i went for this ending of the episode.
Not that i care about James, more that i wouldn't care about him dieing.
And i do care about the psychological effects that it will have on AJ.
Now if sparing Lilly would had caused Tenn to die, that having another psychological effect on AJ and me caring about Tenn would had hit me. (it was what i expected to be the other ending tbh).

brings me to the final thing, was it just me or was this entire episode a little dissapointing?
the choices where not really choices (clearly as for most part more then 90% of the players made the same decissions untill the last one that was about 45-55) the story was alright, it was interesting but there just been better choice moments in a telltale game i think...

Telltale games have a pattern, you can pick up on it if you have played their previous games. If you have the option to kill Lily now, then no matter what option you picked (whether you killed her or not) she will die eventually, because Telltale dosent simply make completely different paths for people that choose such game changing decisions. I'm assuming that you and the rest of you crew will end up escaping the boat explosion in the next episode leaving Lily and her crew to get blown up.