Don't let AJ kill Lilly geez

[Igris]

Are you seriously gonna let this little ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ who didn't even exist when we first met Lilly to kill someone who we've been waiting for years to return as a villian ? Only Clementine should kill her , oh and thing about James is , he will just ditch you in the next episode for disobeying his request that we don't let AJ become the heartless killer , I mean that part is clear as day.

[Poildanlnez]

ikr.
It's one of those choices, you know : there is no good or bad choices.
And even more true because we don't know what Carver Junior - sorry Alvin Junior - will become after that.
He is a "broken toy"...

[Dethlane]

Let little dude kill that beatch we've been waiting for years to get revenge on for Carley/Doug? Hella yes, please. She should be killed at the first opportunity, not let hurt others more. Oh and you don't know about James, maybe he'll come around. And even if won't, he still can help keep walkers at bay

[Igris]

引用自 Dethlane：

Let little dude kill that beatch we've been waiting for years to get revenge on for Carley/Doug? Hella yes, please. She should be killed at the first opportunity, not let hurt others more. Oh and you don't know about James, maybe he'll come around. And even if won't, he still can help keep walkers at bay

Oh he won't , he will just leave you as soon as possible and AJ will become a legit monster pike James said.
The only person who should kill Lilly is Clem.

[Poildanlnez]

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

引用自 Dethlane：

Let little dude kill that beatch we've been waiting for years to get revenge on for Carley/Doug? Hella yes, please. She should be killed at the first opportunity, not let hurt others more. Oh and you don't know about James, maybe he'll come around. And even if won't, he still can help keep walkers at bay

Oh he won't , he will just leave you as soon as possible and AJ will become a legit monster pike James said.
The only person who should kill Lilly is Clem.

Exactly, thing is we don't know if there will be a way to do so in Ep4.

[Dethlane]

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

Oh he won't , he will just leave you as soon as possible and AJ will become a legit monster pike James said.

Good riddance then, Clem doesn't need people she can't rely on. And no, AJ won't become a monster, James was delusional.

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

The only person who should kill Lilly is Clem.

Not at all. Lilly should be put down the moment good opportunity presents itself. Doesn't matter who gets the kill. Besides, Clem tells AJ to kill, so you can say she kills Lilly with AJ as her proxy.

[Igris]

引用自 Dethlane：

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

Oh he won't , he will just leave you as soon as possible and AJ will become a legit monster pike James said.

Good riddance then, Clem doesn't need people she can't rely on. And no, AJ won't become a monster, James was delusional.

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

The only person who should kill Lilly is Clem.

Not at all. Lilly should be put down the moment good opportunity presents itself. Doesn't matter who gets the kill. Besides, Clem tells AJ to kill, so you can say she kills Lilly with AJ as her proxy.

Dude. He is. James isn't worth him turning into a complete psycho.
There are only 3 people who should kill Lilly , Lee , Kenny or Clem , but since both of them are dead , only Clem remains.

[Dethlane]

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

Dude. He is. James isn't worth him turning into a complete psycho.

AJ isn't a monster or complete psycho. You wanna think otherwise, whatever, be my guest.

引用自 It'sJustCasey：

There are only 3 people who should kill Lilly , Lee , Kenny or Clem , but since both of them are dead , only Clem remains.

Not at all. Lilly hurt way more people than just Lee, Kenny and Clem, so that list is way longer.

[Moongazer]

Are you serious? I killed that ♥♥♥♥♥ without hesitation

[Poildanlnez]

引用自 SatinGoldfish92：

Are you serious? I killed that ♥♥♥♥♥ without hesitation

Technically, you didn't kill Lilly.
AJ killed her.
That's the thing with this choice and also the fact that we don't know how this is going to impact AJ and Clem's fate...

[Moongazer]

I meant "I killed" as me, a person, a player

[Poildanlnez]

引用自 SatinGoldfish92：

I meant "I killed" as me, a person, a player

Again, as the player, you tell AJ to kill or spare Lilly.

[Dethlane]

引用自 Poildanlnez：

引用自 SatinGoldfish92：

I meant "I killed" as me, a person, a player

Again, as the player, you tell AJ to kill or spare Lilly.

And in telling AJ to kill Lilly, you kill that beatch. AJ is like a mediator between you and a gun, even if participating.

[Punished FMJ]

WHY LET LILLY LIVE? SHE"S BEEN A ♥♥♥♥♥ FROM LE START. Like you know where you can kill Larry or save him? Yea if you Try to save him he still dies, but guess what Lilly shot whoever you saved making IT MUDAMMDIUMDAMDAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDMAUDM *btw muda means useless* then she trys attacking you. WHO CARES. SHE STOLE THE VAN. ♥♥♥♥♥♥ everyone over, making it so the only way they can get anyone in a fast way is to pray to god that train worked. ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ SHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOTSHOOT HER.

[WeirdScienceX]

James killed lots of people, think walkers are peaceful and innocent, keep an idiot like that around and it's going to cause you problems.

Lilly is too dangerous to keep alive, so what that AJ is a kid, Clem has killed lots of people, it didn't turn her into a raving psycho, it's a zombie apocalypse, she is the biggest threat so needs removed

[Silver Blur]

Clementine comes from a world without walkers. Yes, she did grow up fast in an unforgiving environment, but people forget that she still has the old moral values going (thanks to Lee as well), so whether she turned into a cold blooded killer or not was entirely up to her.
AJ has no sense of said morals. You've seen how radically different his way of thinking is compared to someone that wasn't raised in the zombie apocalypse. He's not adapting to the world as much as the world is molding him
The decision doesn't weigh in whether or not AJ should kill people, but rather than it's about him being able to value life and not casually disposing of it