If the doom marine switched with the halo marine

[PlayerOnline]

How would they fare respectively if they switched scenarios ? Halo marine fights the demons while the doom marine fights the aliens.

[Grampire]

Master Chief can only carry 2 guns at a time. He would get his ♥♥♥♥ wrecked.

The rest of the Spartan force could retire because The Slayer would exterminate the Covenant singlehandedly.

[MattCryptid]

Chief would do okay given that Doomguy was kicking ass before the Divinity Machine enhancements.

Doomslayer would realistically have the Halo series end prematurely.

[shadowflash]

Doomslayer would realistically have the Halo series end prematurely. [/quote]
Pretty much. Doom Slayer vs enemies in Halo is like a huge steamroller vs a pile of chicken eggs.

[xspNoble33]

You're compared God (slayer) and Human (Master Cheif).
It's NOT even a fair fight.

[Grampire]

Originally posted by Anarchist Jurisdictor:

I think I would win because I can wipe my ass without needing to chainsaw a grocery aisle first

I'd rather chainsaw a grocery aisle and use a bidet.

[Littlefoot]

Master Chief would be destroyed by the demons, he has neither the mobility nor the carrying capacity that Doomguy has access too.

[🎃MaximusBlastalot🎃]

At this point the doom gu...slayer is a cross between the shrike from the hyperion novels and a yautja (predators).

Its like the old silly superman vs captain america, theres an obvious winner if a green rock or some other magical magufin isnt involved. Ones a "demigod" the other is a "super soldier" in both contexts.

Same result with the scenarios.

[Irish]

Chief is just as good as Doom Guy if not better. People forget Doom Guy was just a guy. Fueled only by rage. Until he was givin the gifts of the divinity machine. I like Chiefs chances if he went through the same thing. In fact, along with his already awesome super human upgrades, he may actually be super OP.

[Dr. Professor Commander]

Originally posted by Civilian X:

How would they fare respectively if they switched scenarios ? Halo marine fights the demons while the doom marine fights the aliens.

The spoiler-free way of saying this would be that DOOMguy is a bit more superhuman than the Master Chief because of the divinity machine. So Master Chief is superhuman, but Doomguy is much closer to being part godlike than he is to being superhuman. He could probably wreck just about anything from Halo including the Master Chief himself, and that's even coming from a serious Halo nerd lol. MC wouldn't stand a chance.

[Irish]

Originally posted by The Dubious Doobie:

Originally posted by Civilian X:

How would they fare respectively if they switched scenarios ? Halo marine fights the demons while the doom marine fights the aliens.

The spoiler-free way of saying this would be that DOOMguy is a bit more superhuman than the Master Chief because of the divinity machine. So Master Chief is superhuman, but Doomguy is much closer to being part godlike than he is to being superhuman. He could probably wreck just about anything from Halo including the Master Chief himself, and that's even coming from a serious Halo nerd lol. MC wouldn't stand a chance.

But what if you put Chief through the divinity machine?

[chester]

Originally posted by Irish:

Chief is just as good as Doom Guy if not better. People forget Doom Guy was just a guy. Fueled only by rage. Until he was givin the gifts of the divinity machine. I like Chiefs chances if he went through the same thing. In fact, along with his already awesome super human upgrades, he may actually be super OP.

Classic Doomguy was still much stronger than Master Chief though. He moved faster, had a higher carrying capacity, and he could take a good beating without needing to run from enemies every time his health got low.

[Irish]

Originally posted by chester:

Originally posted by Irish:

Chief is just as good as Doom Guy if not better. People forget Doom Guy was just a guy. Fueled only by rage. Until he was givin the gifts of the divinity machine. I like Chiefs chances if he went through the same thing. In fact, along with his already awesome super human upgrades, he may actually be super OP.

Classic Doomguy was still much stronger than Master Chief though. He moved faster, had a higher carrying capacity, and he could take a good beating without needing to run from enemies every time his health got low.

Yeah, you're right, I was just thinking more along the lines of stripping away the game mechanics and looking at them as they are.