Baldr Sky

Baldr Sky

View Stats:
Koyomi May 26, 2020 @ 9:49am
Best girl.
Aki is best girl in my opinion.

For you, who was your favorite character? :Chiaki_DGR:
Last edited by Koyomi; May 26, 2020 @ 9:49am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 21 comments
Adamine May 26, 2020 @ 9:55am 
Aki best girl. :mbpraise:
Tiasmoon May 26, 2020 @ 3:43pm 
Kuu. :ys_dana:
Rain-D Jun 1, 2020 @ 2:44pm 
Rain, Chinatsu, & Aki.

Rain is absolutely the best wingman. Unfortunately her route suffers from the usual "first route syndrome" where her screentime is taken a bit for the sake of worldbuilding. Thankfully DiveX has two sidestories that focused on her. One of them is the story about how Kou & Rain trained to be mercenaries and their fights before Kou & Rain finally returned to Suzushiro. I find it hard to believe how Kou still considers Rain as "we're just licking each other's wounds" seeing how much she cared for him there.

As for Chinatsu, I love strong militaristic girls, but more than that, she is the tragic character in the game. Seeing a cheerful tomboy gets broken into a cold killing machine and then helping her regain her smiles just hits the right spot with me. Yeah, she is a bit annoying in the earlier routes, especially in Nanoha's where she's completely antagonistic, but given what happened to her, I guess it's understandable. Seeing her make up with Nanoha in Makoto's route really warms my heart. Also, to be honest, I find almost all of the H-scenes in Baldr Sky meh, but Chinatsu's in Midspire nearly had me in tears. Unfortunately the last part of her route felt super rushed, and her promise with Kou? ...really?

Aki... to be honest, it's mostly just her bubbly personality and voice performance, but damn it is really great haha. Also, that clone twist/tease thing? That made me scream, "OH, ARE WE GOING THERE? WE'RE ACTUALLY GOING THERE?! Too bad they kind of backtracked on it. The topic of rights, laws, and moral ethics toward clones are very intriguing to me.

As for the others, they're not exactly bad either.

Nanoha is probably the least important heroine to the overall plot, as aside from the tiny aspect of her being Kou's reason for wanting to be a hero of justice, she might be able to be written off the story completely and not much changes. I don't hate her, but I do felt from the beginning that she would most likely be the heroine that I care the least. Thankfully her route ups the ante amazingly from Rain's route and kept me glued to the screen as to see what's going to happen next, a strong point of Baldr Sky as a whole.
Her best performance is whenever she gets dragged by other dorm members/friends off-screen. No, I mean, I always laughed whenever she's screaming as she gets dragged away.

Makoto is a nice character, but I find her lack of screentime in the routes before her and her being not on the same page with Kou for the first half of her route kinda makes her character suffers. I also find that she is perhaps the heroine with the least chemistry with Kou. I get why she would love Kou, but not the other way around. While Nanoha route's story makes me care for Nanoha more, I find Makoto's amazing route actually worked against her as the interesting twists and changes are happening to characters other than her.

Sora is interesting. Beside being a tsundere to Kou, she is actually written like a main character of a story, a somewhat idiotic hothead that will try their best to help everyone and it makes for an interesting parallel in the last route. Unfortunately I find she has the same problem as Makoto, which is the lack of screentime in other routes, and because of that, lack of chemistry with Kou. Sora in her route interacts with Kou even less than Makoto in her route, and I felt the last half of the last route felt a bit rushed. It's also not helping that I find the reason Kou & Sora started dating pre-Gray Christmas just felt really sudden. I think they should've expanded a bit more on the week after the feedback incident. I'm also not a big fan of a "fated lovers" story. Sora's a great character, but I just find the interactions with her in her route too lacking unless you count Sora & Kuu as a set. Also, Chinatsu's VA was great for portraying her cheerful past self and her cold present self, but Sora & Kuu's VA took it to another level.

As Dis said, Noi is surprisingly deep and her dialogues and performance are fun. At times I did think she kinda went too far and maybe too wacky, but thankfully she can be serious when the times calls for it.

Shizel, another strong militaristic girl, YAY! Probably the most explored and interesting character among the Fenrir group, and that's saying a thing because they're all amazing. She has a side story in DiveX that covers her funnier side, but it lacked a punchline/ending :(
Tiasmoon Jun 2, 2020 @ 4:51am 
None of that felt added in to me. Remember that we learn new plot points, or learn more/different things about old plot points in every single route, pretty much up the end of those routes as well.

Taiketsu Jun 4, 2020 @ 6:55am 
If i had to say my fav heroine would be either Rain or Aki. Rain i guess most can agree with and Aki well she did stood out a bit better for me.

Also now that u say that Makoto is also a clone of Yae (totaly oversaw that) makes me wonder about Sora again. Her past (as far i remember) is not really explained much. We know her father/parents were scientists and she was with Makoto early on even while she was in the vat. But what excatly happened to her is not explained well (or i rly oversaw a few things x.x).
What i found funny is that she is the girl Kou's Simulacra hugged when she was a child and that that was the reason they were destined to fall in love. Not a bad idea but makes me feel bad for Chinatsu during her school days.
Rain-D Jun 4, 2020 @ 9:44am 
Originally posted by Taiketsu:
Also now that u say that Makoto is also a clone of Yae (totaly oversaw that) makes me wonder about Sora again. Her past (as far i remember) is not really explained much. We know her father/parents were scientists and she was with Makoto early on even while she was in the vat. But what excatly happened to her is not explained well (or i rly oversaw a few things x.x).
What i found funny is that she is the girl Kou's Simulacra hugged when she was a child and that that was the reason they were destined to fall in love. Not a bad idea but makes me feel bad for Chinatsu during her school days.

Sora's parents aren't Ark scientists, it was a false memory she had after the shock from being hugged by Kou's simulacra when entering Ark's restricted zone with Makoto. IIRC, Makoto is implied to be the embryo Eiji brought back from the Fenrir's South American incident along with Sora.

After getting Sora's ending and getting a plug in for an extra scene in Sora's route, Sora mentioned that when Yae was first pregnant with Eiji's child and before anybody else noticed (including Yae & Eiji), Neunzehn took the cells off her and modified on it, probably implying that it become the basis for his next set of clones, if not Sora herself. Aki also mentioned in Sora's route that Makoto & Sora could be considered "genetically a family" to Kou, and even gives a player choice on whether the player would feel bothered about it or not.
Last edited by Rain-D; Jun 4, 2020 @ 9:46am
Tiasmoon Jun 4, 2020 @ 11:03am 
From what I recall that wasnt young Sora. Hence why she didnt sound young. Without ''its complicated'' stuff Kou's simu was the one to first meet Sora iirc.

Also, as far as I know none of the ''Sora'' appearances (like the one where she stands at the tree when Kou and what's-his-face are walking to the dorm) had a singularity present. I dont think those appearances are ever explained.

I might just have forgotten tho. Well. Either way ''its complicated''.
Taiketsu Jun 4, 2020 @ 11:24am 
Ok i remember the thing about 19 removing the egg from Yae but my thought process didnt connect it that he might grow it into Sora. Makes this even more fked up if u think that Sora and Makoto are "half-sisters" of him in a way then.
Also the part about the Sora's appearing at Kou's home, on the way to school etc. i thought that would be Singularity only because it seemed like Kou himself never did remember meeting her as child. And as u sad before she sound to "mature" as child which made me think that she was Agent like many others i guess. The problem is that we saw mostly parralel worlds and know that Agent did appear there to help prevent destruction while World 0 was already "dead".
So if Sora and Kou rly meet as children in W0 or not is not rly explained well i think.
Rain-D Jun 4, 2020 @ 12:57pm 
Ooookay, so here's the thing about Sora appearing in Kou's childhood and in Spring before Kou moved to Kisaragi dorm. It was revealed in the good ending part of Sora's route that among the dreams when she's witnessing/interventing with other worlds, she also saw one of much further past, including the one when Kou's crying when Yae passed away.
https://i.imgur.com/29fyCtJ.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/pPI7GUQ.jpg

It was never explained why she was able to go back that far which is way before the divergences. She probably also didn't actually manifest the physical world then, perhaps just a visual-auditory feedback from the brainchip like how Kuu was in Kou's head in Sora's route. Anyway, the question of "who meets/falls in love first between Kou and Sora" becomes an infinite loop, which is why I called them fated lovers. And again, not a big fan of that.
Mr. Manual Jul 7, 2020 @ 4:54am 
Aki takes the gold medal for me. She's really supportive of Kou, just as much as Rain is, but I just adore her sleepy personality that belies a caring personality. If I had to pick a silver medal, I'd say Rain, for the reasons above, but she's got significantly less moe power than Aki does. I mean, none of the other heroines popped up in a stunning wedding dress just to show off to their lover! Bronze medal goes to Nanoha, solely because her h scenes hit all the right notes for me, even more than Aki's. Solely because of that. Because otherwise I tire of her crybaby bunting tendencies. Then Sora, then Chinatsu, then Makoto. I can't STAND Makoto! She hasn't done a single thing right in my opinion, except in the optional ending scene in the final route. Besides that, her personality is nonexistent.

Also, Eiji best bro, fite me Mohawk. If I had to put Noi in there, I'd put her where I'd put Nanoha, because she's a pretty complex character, but I'm not a lolicon so her h scenes are a turn-off. Points to her, though, for that one H scene in Nanoha's route. You know the one. Shizel doesn't even rank.
Last edited by Mr. Manual; Jul 7, 2020 @ 4:54am
Morthra Jul 18, 2020 @ 2:30am 
Having played DiveX, Rain is easily best girl.
prociona Aug 13, 2020 @ 3:11am 
Kuu... or maybe Sora.
Aki has an interesting personality, and Makoto is ok.
Lain and Nanoha are boring. And Chinatsu is a beech, as it was said already.
Last edited by prociona; Aug 13, 2020 @ 3:12am
bill5499 Sep 9, 2023 @ 9:45pm 
They're all good. Though I do have a bit of a bias for Rain and Sora in particular. I feel like Sora would easily take best girl if they had just give her more screentime in the last route and maybe show her merc days in comparison to Kou
jabberwok Sep 10, 2023 @ 1:58am 
Definitely Sora. The most fun, best chemistry with Kou, imo. Also twin tails. Aki is cool, though.

Originally posted by bill5499:
They're all good. Though I do have a bit of a bias for Rain and Sora in particular. I feel like Sora would easily take best girl if they had just give her more screentime in the last route and maybe show her merc days in comparison to Kou

Yeah, I was hoping for more of her in the last route. She kind of gets stuck playing the princess to be rescued, and doesn't get to interact with anyone else. That's why I'm planning a fan game focused on bringing her into the main (route 1-5) plot.
Last edited by jabberwok; Sep 10, 2023 @ 1:58am
bill5499 Sep 11, 2023 @ 8:24pm 
Originally posted by jabberwok:
Definitely Sora. The most fun, best chemistry with Kou, imo. Also twin tails. Aki is cool, though.

Originally posted by bill5499:
They're all good. Though I do have a bit of a bias for Rain and Sora in particular. I feel like Sora would easily take best girl if they had just give her more screentime in the last route and maybe show her merc days in comparison to Kou

Yeah, I was hoping for more of her in the last route. She kind of gets stuck playing the princess to be rescued, and doesn't get to interact with anyone else. That's why I'm planning a fan game focused on bringing her into the main (route 1-5) plot.

Oh cool. What are ya gonna call it? I might just take it a look at it
< >
Showing 1-15 of 21 comments
Per page: 1530 50