Tales of Abyss or Tales of Xillia>?

[Reyson Fox]

One of these has to be next ><

[Vashe]

I'd rather have Xilia 1/2, I never played them. I know every bit of Abyss

[Shadow Esper]

I'd rather have Graces F. It wasn't the strongest title, but it was the last one I enjoyed, because it had very likable characters.

Xillia 2 was the worst Tales Game I ever played.

But I never had the chance to play Abyss, so it'd be nice to get that sometime.

[Rayanna]

theres still that german leak about a Xillia remaster for PS4 so most likely that but I'd rather have Abyss anyday

[Flavio Branford]

Tales of the Abyss >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Tales of Xillia

[BlueDragonXD]

Yes Shadow Esper is right. Xillia 2 is in my opinion the worst Tails game I have played by far! Not even close to the second worst. Second worst is maybe..... actually no I almost like every other Tales game tied in there own way.

Vesperia, Beseria, Zesteria, Graces F, Xillia.... they are all great games! I have only just started Abyss...

Xillia 2 is horrible.... But Xilla part one on PC would be nice. I would also welcome Graces F here.

[Mermidion]

Abyss > Xillia

[Winged One]

neither, Tales of Phantasia Cross Edition



Also, if you guys think Xillia 2 is the worst, you clearly never played Legendia (I think I threw up a bit just typing its title)

[Terranigma23]

Originally posted by theseraph1:

neither, Tales of Phantasia Cross Edition



Also, if you guys think Xillia 2 is the worst, you clearly never played Legendia (I think I threw up a bit just typing its title)

People don't like Legendia because of the battle system but the character and the story is awesome. My favorite soundtrack (Go Shiina) and a lot of humour.
I discover the tales of serie with him when I was in highschool so maybe nostalgia hit me

[Smurf]

Originally posted by theseraph1:

neither, Tales of Phantasia Cross Edition



Also, if you guys think Xillia 2 is the worst, you clearly never played Legendia (I think I threw up a bit just typing its title)

I loved Phantasia X! I played the crap out of that and Narikiri Dungeon X a few years ago. Would totally love to see it on PC, but I don't think it'd ever happen and would be pleasantly surprised if it does.

I don't like Legendia either, but it's one of the better written ones. Post game for character stories is gold. Only thing bad was the English version didn't record any VA for it. The gameplay is just terrible because it went an entire step back at the time. Soundtrack was amazing.

Everyone wants Xillia or Abyss and both of those are terrible for me. Xillia 2 is the better one among those choices. An earlier poster said Graces F and I have to agree that'd be the one I'd want because they're never going to do Phantasia X. At least the gameplay in Graces is solid. Plenty of people don't like it though, and I respect it. It's fast, furious, and actually unique compared to the other titles. Story isn't anything to write home about, but that's literally most Tales games. The writing for the skits is great though.

Abyss takes me back to simpler times. Back when Shinryu had been making videos of destroying the game. Part of me likes the game, but I don't think I'd ever want to see it on PC until Bamco decides it wants to put several older Tales games on PC all at once.

Graces F or Xillia 1/2 for me.

[Giro]

Between those 2 definitely Abyss a million times over.

And I liked Xillia

[zachillios]

Abyss can be played on the PS2 emulator quite while and has no DLC to bundle. Xillia has both a sequel, an array of DLC and still can't be properly played on PC. I love them both, but a Xillia remaster would work out much better.

[CerusSerenade]

Abyss>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Xillia

It has a story that is actually compelling and not UGUUUU THE POWER OF FRIENDSHIIIIIP

Seriously, Xillia was a major letdown along with Zestiria and Berseria.

[Dr. Gori]

Originally posted by Shadow Esper:

I'd rather have Graces F. It wasn't the strongest title, but it was the last one I enjoyed, because it had very likable characters.

Xillia 2 was the worst Tales Game I ever played.

But I never had the chance to play Abyss, so it'd be nice to get that sometime.

No way, Xillia 1 was pure trash and had the second worst lead and party (after Zesteria). At least Xillia 2 let you have the best ending via murder.

I would kill for Graces F, it still has the best combat in the series.

[xiammes]

Xillia will probably be sooner then later, those of the best selling tales titles and they fit snugly as a remaster. With all the reused assest in Xillia 2, shouldn't even be that hard.

[бобоваяпанда]

Story-wise. Tales of the Abyss >>>>>>>>> Tales of Xillia


Gameplay-wise. Tales of Xillia >>>>>>>>> Tales of the Abyss