Suggestion

[krana]

Maybe an extra achievement for solving all puzzles perfectly? That would be a nice challenge!

[Tudwell]

This topic has come up a lot. There are plenty of people who would prefer not to worry about solving every puzzle perfectly -- that's why there's an option to continue when you make a mistake.

Adding an achievement like this would only make it harder for those people to enjoy the game. I also don't think it would add a whole lot for the perfectionists, since hopefully it's already rewarding just to have solved the puzzle perfectly.

[whisper]

Yeah speaking as a perfectionist, just having the game acknowledge it is enough.

[NonlinearFruit]

Being able to see the stats on how many of the logicians solved each puzzle perfectly would be pretty interesting

[McFly]

Originally posted by Tudwell:

This topic has come up a lot. There are plenty of people who would prefer not to worry about solving every puzzle perfectly -- that's why there's an option to continue when you make a mistake.

Adding an achievement like this would only make it harder for those people to enjoy the game. I also don't think it would add a whole lot for the perfectionists, since hopefully it's already rewarding just to have solved the puzzle perfectly.

What´s the point in solving the puzzles making mistakes? That don´t take reasoning. Only guessing and eventually revealing tiles by mistakes.
The perfectionist achievement makes a lot of sense in this game. Specially on a pretty difficult like this one in it´s genre.

[McFly]

Originally posted by NonlinearFruit:

Being able to see the stats on how many of the logicians solved each puzzle perfectly would be pretty interesting

Agreed. Achievements don´t have to be 100% completed all the time. If you can´t, you can´t. Some achievements are made for specially gifted people.

[Jimbly]

Being a perfectionist, or, at least, completionist, and seeing the game was tracking perfect levels, I just assumed there was already an achievement for this... which meant I was painstakingly re-doing (or, screenshotting and pasting back in when it was an input issue, not a logic issue ^_^) each puzzle... I think I'm going to be enjoying this game a lot more now =).

Originally posted by McFly:

What´s the point in solving the puzzles making mistakes? That don´t take reasoning.

Depends how you play - most of my failures have been due to input issues (real easy to accidentally click instead of right click on my laptop touch pad), and when they were due to a logic issue, I undo, figure out what I missed (usually actually a counting issue, not logic ^_^), and go from there without marking the mistaken tile unless it's logical at the time. Others don't have to play that way, play however you find the most fun =).