Unqualified Ratings 2

[Hund]

Woo-hoo. After popular demand (I think like one person) I've decided to bring this back. Send me an SCP, and I will rate it out of ten, despite having no skill at writing or judging writing.

One at a time, since SCPs can be quite long and I prefer to spend my time doing other things as well. As well as giving the rating I will also try and briefly explain what I liked or didn't like about it.

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door Otávio,o avestruz radical:

Now for a more serious submission...

SCP-3001[scp-wiki.wikidot.com]. Surprised when I checked that this particular skip only got a mention and not a full review. Also I just realized this is the 900th message. Nice!

i like it. i think my biggest issue with it is the formatting in the last dialogue bit was... not great. and it made it a bit unclear who was speaking at times. however the actual main logs manage to keep me invested which is fairly impressive considering the lack of... an environment, other characters, literally anything to play off of. scranton reads like he genuinely knows what he's talking about which is surprisingly not particularly common, and it makes his descent into whatever the hell that is even more horrifying. 9/10 i like it a lot actually

[zistix1]

SCP-3449

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door zistix1:

SCP-3449

neat. it's one of those articles that takes a fairly simplistic concept and manages to make an interesting article out of it. creative use of audio and video helps as well, very much appreciate that in an article as it isn't common. 7/10 it's just kinda solid all round

[MECHA ENGINEER]

SCP-7966

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door MECHA ENGINEER:

SCP-7966

the sense of dread at what i'm going to have to go through whenever i see you have commented on this thread has never waned

honestly? if they dropped it being jim davis, the idea of jesus being reborn and not actually knowing it is... kinda fun. i feel like you could do stuff with that. as it stands, though, it's an unfunny joke that barely even tries to explore the concepts that it sets out. at least it didn't overstay it's welcome, i suppose. 4/10

[zistix1]

SCP-015-IT

IT means it's from the Italian SCP Branch if you're wondering

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door zistix1:

SCP-015-IT

IT means it's from the Italian SCP Branch if you're wondering

definitely interesting. also definitely very series 1 lol. although it retreads the ground of a couple other scps that have done similar stuff, and although overall it's not the most complex thing in the world, i kinda think it's just quite neat. 7/10 it's solid

[zistix1]

SCP-439

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door zistix1:

SCP-439

i like this one. not particularly complex, but it's handled well, and the ending reveal was fun. there's a few iffy bits but most of them can be chalked up to it being series 1 - specifically i think some of the bits that were expunged don't make sense. 6/10 it's fun

[zistix1]

SCP-4195

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door zistix1:

SCP-4195

cool concept, and i will admit it took me a moment to piece together the story aha. i'm a wee bit unsure of whether the flowers themselves have any connection, or if they're just an unrelated detail, but either way it's cool. 6/10

[Hazardous Env Combat Unit]

SCP-8206

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door HECU Soldier:

SCP-8206

i like this one. i feel like i... definitely didn't pick up on a fair amount of symbolism, but still. the core concept is interesting, dialogue's cool, and it's executed well all around. 8/10

[zistix1]

SCP-039

[Hund]

Origineel geplaatst door zistix1:

SCP-039

poor monkeys :(

i like it. initially it felt kinda just like... shock stuff, in a way. but i think the last bits kinda pulled it past that and into the realm of being actually interesting. good balance of being weird and mysterious while still actually telling you enough to keep you engaged. 7/10