Best to Worst SCP Games in Your Opinion

[shoes]

I wanted to ask people what they thought the best and worst SCP games were and their reasons why. Even if some of the comparisons are apples to oranges. Feel free to add a game if I missed one.

THANKS TO: okbuddysir, Agent ██████

The games are listed here (this is just listed in the order I typed them up).

1. SCP - Containment Breach
2. SCP: Containment Breach - Unity
3. SCP: Secret Laboratory
4. SCP-450
5. SCP-3008
6. SCP: Blackout
7. SCP-087
8. SCP-087-B
9. SCP: Operation Descent
10. Gmod Breach
(The following are mods of SCP games, but some consider them to be different things so I will add them anyways)
11. SCP: CB Nine Tailed Fox Mod (unreleased, but had a demo version out for it awhile ago)
12. SCP - Containment Breach Ultimate Edition
13. SCP:CB - Project Resurrection
14. SCP-087-B Extended Edition
(The following are Roblox SCP games. This doesn't accept group games or shovelware games since those would make this take up a few pages.)
15. SCP RBreach
16. Roblox NTF mod

The following is a list of my opinions. Feel free to skip it and post your opinions first before reading mine. I don't want to mess with your opinions.

1. SCP - Containment Breach Ultimate Edition
At the start this mod was a bundle mod of the other Containment Breach mods, but as time went on this mod became it's own thing and slowly started removing certain things from the other mods. Ultimate Edition is a bundle pack, but it also improves things from the base game (such as making an endroom for the Entrance Zone so it doesn't look like the Light Containment Zone). This mod is not perfect though since it still takes things from other mods, but I would recommend trying it.
2. SCP: CB Nine Tailed Fox Mod
This mod is still in development, but from the trailers and demo it appears that it might be good. (If I remember correctly at least one of the people involved with the mod were involved with the development of the main Containment Breach game.)
3. SCP - Containment Breach
This is called one of the greatest free horror games and for good reason. If I had to compare it to another horror game I would use Silent Hill as an example. It focuses on ambiance rather than straight up horror and knows how to use sound effects (a good example is that it plays a mildly spooky sound when a body falls from the ceiling, but uses the loud jumpscare sounds for an appropriate event such as staring at 096's face or 173 being right in front of you).
4. SCP:CB - Project Resurrection
This mod has stopped development for now, but it can best be compared to Ultimate Edition. The main difference between Ultimate Edition and Project Resurrection is that Ultimate Edition focused on the main game while Project Resurrection focused on adding new stuff (even if it was rough around the edges). The main problem with Project Resurrection is that it doesn't have the same level as polish as the original game or the mods listed above it. This mod ceased development partially due to the Ultimate Edition mod taking content and popularity from it.
5. SCP: Secret Laboratory
This is the best multiplayer SCP game out there (although that might not be that hard with it's "competition" being in Garry's Mod and Roblox). Some might say it is a bad horror game, but it isn't meant to be a horror game. It isn't perfect, but it certainly isn't bad.
6. Gmod Breach
The upside is that you are on Garry's mod and there is a lot more that can happen. The bad news is you are on Garry's mod and if you don't like the memefest that Secret Laboratory goes into then you will probably hate Gmod Breach.
7. SCP-087-B Extended Edition
Like the original 087-B, but better and with multiplayer.
8. SCP-3008
I feel it is too early to get a solid opinion of it, but it does capture the feel of what an SCP game is so far.
9. SCP-087-B
A decent horror game for the time it released in, but it doesn't have a satisfying ending for all the pain you have to go through to get it.
10. SCP: Blackout
After looking at it again (my inital post was based off of the first version) I have decided to rank this above Operation Descent and Unity. The only thing some could consider a major downside is that it has OC (original characters) SCPs.
11. SCP: Operation Descent
A remake of SCP-087, but with new areas. It may make people obsessed with canon rage, but it is better than the original SCP-087 game.
12. SCP: Containment Breach - Unity
(RANT WARNING: SKIP IF YOU ARE A FAN OF UNITY) I am biased against this game. Mainly because it tries to act as a remake of the original Containment Breach, but also tries to claim to be it's own thing while failing at both. If I had to compare this to another horror game I would use Dead Space 2 as an example. It ignores ambiance in favor of in your face horror. An example of this is 106 now running at you rather than the slow walk towards you and teleporting frequently to disorient you (although 106 does teleport just as often Unity). While some might use the excuse that Unity is still in an earlier version they also forget that Unity has donations for it and the original Containment Breach didn't (or at least didn't have as much as Unity did). Unity also has the habit of focusing on things that don't bring development forward and can lessen the experience such as ragdoll physics for bodies (I remember a video of 106 kicking a body forwards while walking towards the player can anyone find that for me), Patreon offices, and the pointless 1762 sidequest. It feels like Unity is a "YouTuber horror" game rather than a "horror" game. The only upside is the improved engine and graphics (although some do argue that the art style change makes the game look less grounded in reality).
13. Roblox SCP rBreach
SCP rBreach tries to be like Ultimate Edition for Secret Lab. The problem is that while it has good ideas it botches the execution on these ideas.
14. Roblox NTF
This game is bad. It tries to be a multiplayer version of the NTF mod, but the enemies are bullet sponges who you need to kill via multiple attempts since enemy health doesn't regenerate, shelling out money for the microtransaction gamepasses to get better guns, or to white knight one of the "goddesses" of the mod to get "blessed" with better damage. (I think the best laugh I got out of the mod was someone describing the goddesses part as a deviantart fetish.)
15. SCP-450
It is in such an early version from what I have seen that I can't really say how good it is.
16. SCP-087
This is the most boring SCP game out there I think. It also has a ton of remakes, but I will only include them if they actually change something rather than just adding an intro or a hole in the staircase.

I am currently updating this list.

[Sex destroyer]

Nangi eredeti hozzászólása:

If you want to rank them by how good they are while only taking into consideration how good they are as a proper game, they'd all be in C-D tier games, including CB.

The only game that had potential of not being stuck on the lower tiers was Unity, and we know how that ended.

man unity would suck ass
that game was just rinse and repeat of cb with fancier graphics and less horror and im not talking just about the the 096 mech fight and warehouse DOOM 939 event

[HECU Soldier]

Sex destroyer eredeti hozzászólása:

Nangi eredeti hozzászólása:

If you want to rank them by how good they are while only taking into consideration how good they are as a proper game, they'd all be in C-D tier games, including CB.

The only game that had potential of not being stuck on the lower tiers was Unity, and we know how that ended.

man unity would suck ass
that game was just rinse and repeat of cb with fancier graphics and less horror and im not talking just about the the 096 mech fight and warehouse DOOM 939 event

Warehouse DOOM 939 event? Now that's a new one. Wtf was that supposed to be??

[Nangi]

Sex destroyer eredeti hozzászólása:

Nangi eredeti hozzászólása:

If you want to rank them by how good they are while only taking into consideration how good they are as a proper game, they'd all be in C-D tier games, including CB.

The only game that had potential of not being stuck on the lower tiers was Unity, and we know how that ended.

man unity would suck ass
that game was just rinse and repeat of cb with fancier graphics and less horror and im not talking just about the the 096 mech fight and warehouse DOOM 939 event

*Potential*

[Sex destroyer]

Nangi eredeti hozzászólása:

Sex destroyer eredeti hozzászólása:

man unity would suck ass
that game was just rinse and repeat of cb with fancier graphics and less horror and im not talking just about the the 096 mech fight and warehouse DOOM 939 event

*Potential*

♥♥♥♥ POTENTIAL
I WANT ACTUAL GOOD SCP GAMES (3 only exist)

[Otávio,o avestruz radical]

HECU Soldier eredeti hozzászólása:

Sex destroyer eredeti hozzászólása:

man unity would suck ass
that game was just rinse and repeat of cb with fancier graphics and less horror and im not talking just about the the 096 mech fight and warehouse DOOM 939 event

Warehouse DOOM 939 event? Now that's a new one. Wtf was that supposed to be??

It’s been a while, but iirc, there was gonna be a shotgun in the warehouse and a whole sequence where you shoot a bunch of 939s.

…huh, now that I think about it, a shotgun wouldn’t do s#it to a 939.

[ZirconZer0]

Thread locked due to necro.