Most overrated sonic games? (talking about the community)

[DSANIC]

SU and SA2

SU- HUB WORLDS, compulsory medal collecting (even tho I try getting all red rings on gen and LW), long werehog stages (longer than heroes) (I know media got this game as a bad one, but I'm not talking about them, I'm talking about the players and fans... I note most of them like this game)

SA2- knuckles and rouge "baised" stages (sometimes it's easy to fing the stuff... other times is hard as hell), tails and eggman stages are quite slow (gamma was still a but fast-paced on SA1), unfair ranking system in most stages

[LilSoonerFanInMO]

Yeah, I can agree with the SA2 thing

[Cross]

Honestly I've seen the majority of players hate Unleashed for the Werehog stages.
Personally, I think the most overrated games are the classic trilogy.

[DSANIC]

Originally posted by Itsuki:

Honestly I've seen the majority of players hate Unleashed for the Werehog stages.
Personally, I think the most overrated games are the classic trilogy.

I'm on a sonic fans group and they seem all to agree SU is a great game (some of them just ignore the werehog)

[JustThatOneGuy13]

The classic games. I know they're the best in the series, but the only good games is cutting it.

[Captain Poopdeck]

Probably colors, the game is fun, yes, but it has some really ♥♥♥♥ 2D Incorporated into it

[Neutral Star]

Colors, definitely Colors.

[PotterAndMatrixFan]

Adventure 2 is by far the most overrated one.

[SpyroGuy]

I'd say Colors and Generations.

[TGT]

Dunno, more and more people are starting to hate SA2 nowadays. It's becoming more normal to think SA2 is average. But I'd say Generations for modern, Sonic 2 for classic.

[Rukk]

Originally posted by Neutral Star:

Colors, definitely Colors.

Yeah, this. I had no desire to touch the game ever again after collecting all red rings, the whole thing was just incredibly forgettable.

[Cornelius Sludge]

Originally posted by Zera:

Originally posted by Neutral Star:

Colors, definitely Colors.

Yeah, this. I had no desire to touch the game ever again after collecting all red rings, the whole thing was just incredibly forgettable.

Thank, lot of people loved colors which is fine, but the fact that forces is trying to be like colors and people are whining about it is annoying.

[SpyroGuy]

Originally posted by EricPixel:

the fact that forces is trying to be like colors and people are whining about it is annoying.

I'd say that it's trying to represent the exact opposite, your statement is the first time I'm hearing about these so called "complaints" regarding the similarities with Colors. O_o

[Ikagura]

What's wrong with hub world?

[JustThatOneGuy13]

Originally posted by Ikagura:

What's wrong with hub world?

People find them as distractions and unessesary padding.

[temafe7]

Probaly Sonic 3. My first playthrough of Sonic 3 was horrible. It just felt so unfair and I couldnt understand why everyone loved it so much. Yea sure now that I know where the unfair stuff is, it is a fun expierience, but I still dont get why everyone seems to love it so much. Yes, I do know that all classic Sonic games have cheap placement at times, but for me, it just felt Sonic 3 had the most unfair level design.