Chivalry 2 vs Mordhau

[Nyx Assassin]

If mordhau would get Special attacks and Charge attacks for each weapon as chivalry 2 did,
then mordhau would wipe the floor with it, before it was even released.

change my mind

[Jack]

Honestly finding chiv 2 pretty fun which is worrying for mordau, The combat i prefer in mord to be honest. But the battles in chiv2 are waaaay more fun, also heavy attacks are pretty good.

[Bresker]

Chiv's game modes are way more fun and engaging, also it is more forgiving to casuals, that itself will make it a better game for those who are not interested in 1 v 1 duels regardless what you add to Mordhau.

[Kleinyre]

Having played some chiv 2 I can say I prefer mordhau combat, chiv's feels more clunky, slower, and too complex for its own good.

[Anon]

Sometimes less is better. It's true for music, and gaming too. Just like how adding sprinting to kf2 broke kiting when compared to kf1. Too many attacks make the game unpredictable and unreadable. Mordhau's combat is decent the way it is, we don't need more.

[Jack]

Originally posted by ФWоlФ:

Originally posted by Jack:

Honestly finding chiv 2 pretty fun which is worrying for mordau,

Why is it "worrying for mordau"? Just why? There is only two hack and slash games in the whole world. And they are quite different from each other. Live in peace, people. Everything will be fine. Promise.

As much as i love Mordau, on average it has 4k players. If a whole bunch up and go to chiv its not good on the longevity of the game.

[ChaoticGamer]

Originally posted by Jack:

Honestly finding chiv 2 pretty fun which is worrying for mordau, The combat i prefer in mord to be honest. But the battles in chiv2 are waaaay more fun, also heavy attacks are pretty good.

I play the beta, I hate to say it but chiv 2 got this in the bag

Originally posted by Bresker:

Chiv's game modes are way more fun and engaging, also it is more forgiving to casuals, that itself will make it a better game for those who are not interested in 1 v 1 duels regardless what you add to Mordhau.

it is more fun but the duel is type of issues need fix up but the funny thing is you still can duck under the blade.

Originally posted by -toErIpNid-:

Having played some chiv 2 I can say I prefer mordhau combat, chiv's feels more clunky, slower, and too complex for its own good.

played it and no I don't feel clunky or slower that probably depending the update on your computer / how much space memories / or you have very old computer which I just recently have a new computer for it is rocking for both for mordau and chiv 2 beta. This is pretty much we discuss about the archer in the game for yes the archer bow and arrow feel very "weird" and when you grabbing throwing block of giant stone pretty much that also felt weird but in some what weirdly right in chiv 2 but the only problem is mordau follow the correct point of dmg on a person who is and not wearing armor because details about ppl wearing armor from simple throwing a rock at the air still do attend to kill no matter what.

Originally posted by Anon:

Sometimes less is better. It's true for music, and gaming too. Just like how adding sprinting to kf2 broke kiting when compared to kf1. Too many attacks make the game unpredictable and unreadable. Mordhau's combat is decent the way it is, we don't need more.

not entirely true we don't need mordhau's combat, but still the dev can work it's kink to "correcting" it and if the dev thought of "ok we will give that long block like chiv 2 and have stamina drain" that system is easy apply for mordhau's combat because both game can be forgiving or both can work with each other. Heck, come think about it I remember my friend yammering about the 2 game and saying "why not just have these 2 dev work with each other so it can be truely made to be fair game" I don't know it would be wise but if they ever do for I prefer be the 1st one wanna tested it if they ever work with each other.
*edit*
For yes the chiv 2 is quite chaoticly out of hand, but the players aren't aware being mordau players and regular wham ppl but the only reason why it is chaotic because chiv 1 pretty much was the one who cause the cake to fall (short meaning, chiv 1 was everywhere in xbox 360, ps4 in thous old version game that why we have so many casual players or dumb block players who never experinces mordau)

At the mean time, mordau is only on the PC and never on other gaming station because the design was never meant for controllers for it would be wise if they did release for other gaming stations for the players could of had compare it better and not being weeb of chiv 1 and thinking "this should be casual day like chiv 1" so we mordau player can at least pour the salt on their wounds. Yet again, I understand the "dev" don't want go on "the other gaming stations" for he could of gain giant bucks of money there if he did and servers would a stablish severs a whole some more and also the biggest funding money could of had ever roll up into this "dev's pocket".

[ChaoticGamer]

Originally posted by ФWоlФ:

Originally posted by Jack:

As much as i love Mordau, on average it has 4k players. If a whole bunch up and go to chiv its not good on the longevity of the game.

Do you have problems finding matches? No, right? You worry too much. Ommmmmmmmm.

u do have a point, we could wait the dev make mordau 2.

[Jack]

Originally posted by ФWоlФ:

Originally posted by Jack:

As much as i love Mordau, on average it has 4k players. If a whole bunch up and go to chiv its not good on the longevity of the game.

Do you have problems finding matches? No, right? You worry too much. Ommmmmmmmm.

Im not worried the thread is about chiv2 vs mordau, i said its worrying for mordau?.

I think the reason some people find chiv2 combat clunky is because mordau combat its incredibly fluid specifically in the non duel servers, where hitting the top of the scoreboard means running around naked with a 2H doing 180 swings.

[Lord tOFU]

Mordhau has better controls + combat. The best way to put things in perspective is to look at how players reacted when Mordhau first released, all the revolutionary combat changes they added, weapon collision, blocking arrows, throwing weapons, alternative weapon modes, etcetera

I can't say that I feel that excited about how Chivalry 2 has added new elements. Things are far clunkier in Chivalry 2. Animations are far worse, movement is janky, the combat system is a lot messier. But I guess this is what the devs wanted. Torn Banner wanted the game to feel like a drunken brawl, not a medieval combat simulation, which Mordhau is.

They both offer something unique, so I love that players have variety in what they want to play, but lets be honest, when Mordhau first released, they changed the game. I can't say the same about Chivalry 2.

[Langrel]

" not a medieval combat simulation, which Mordhau is." - please refrain from making claims like that, Mordhau has detailed combat mechanics, just leave it at that.

[Bahamut]

The combat in Chiv 2 doesn't feel as satisfying as it does in Mordhau. The potential is there though, they just need to tune things more, which will no doubt happen over time. If they can get it right, it'll be a real alternative to Mord.

[Lord tOFU]

Originally posted by Langrel:

" not a medieval combat simulation, which Mordhau is." - please refrain from making claims like that, Mordhau has detailed combat mechanics, just leave it at that.

Oh boohoo boyo. it's a discussion thread, you can agree or disagree with my claim.

I guess if I were to put it better I'd argue that Mordhau combat is usually treated like a fencing match as opposed to Chiv 2s brawler combat.

[Lee]

From what I saw of Chiv 2 I think it looks underwhelming, I didn't expect it to be great but it looks worse than I imagined. Not that it matters to me really, I won't ever touch the Epic Game Store, so I won't even try Chiv 2 out to find out if I like it or not.

[Anon]

Originally posted by Bahamut:

The potential is there though, they just need to tune things more, which will no doubt happen over time.

I doubt it. Imo they will mostly work on further dlc.

Originally posted by tOFU:

Oh boohoo boyo. it's a discussion thread, you can agree or disagree with my claim.

That's not an opinion, Mordhau is not a simulator you clown.

[48 YEARS OLD VIRGIN]

Mordhau does 1v1 and individual strikes better, like both underhands. Most Chiv2 weapons don't have those. But that's about it. Everything else Chiv 2 does better. Graphics, performance, maps, 1vx combat... At least bring Mordhau up to speed with these quality of life changes :

-Give dodge to everyone
-Make feints cost more stamina
-Make missing parries less punishing