Buffalo Pile Puzzle

[The Golden Knight]

No guide on this has yet been made, but I can't quite seem to get the recipe right without the valves fusing shut. What I remember "hearing" in-game was "blood before milk" and "ichor before blood." If all that were true, then it stands to reason the combination is ichor, blood, milk. But that didn't work.

Anyone else figure this out?

[No Time to Explain]

Milk, blood, ichor I think. Hide in the closet and read all the hints.

[FormIsContent]

Yeah there should be three separate hints I think.

There may also be other mysteries.

[masterofflys]

It's milk, blood, ichor

Be careful to read the full hint, sometimes they reverse it, like 'ichor before blood, bad idea bud' to throw you off.

Also when you're done, make sure you mix a milk+milk+lemonade to get a jar of fudge (+23 all stats)!

[Elegant Caveman]

The order changes, but milk/blood/ichor seems to be a very common answer.

And there are certainly more than three hints when you hide in the closet.

[Dark Thunder]

Yeah, you have to listen to both parts of the rhyme, not just the first part. If they say, to give the example previously mentioned in this topic (because I can't remember any other "bad" ones offhand), "Ichor before blood, bad Idea, bud", then the order is actually "Blood before Milk".

Milk-Blood-Ichor does seem to be the most common order. I had that order for three different games.

[The Golden Knight]

I don't think the order changes. It's milk-blood-ichor.

[Elegant Caveman]

It's been milk/blood/ichor for me the three times I did it, but I've seen multiple people say it's random, and one person say that milk/blood/ichor didn't work for them.

Originally posted by ARES Five-Five:

I don't think the order changes. It's milk-blood-ichor.

What makes you so sure it's not random?

[The Golden Knight]

Because of how consistent the order has been, it's hard to believe it is random. It might be random, or a few people could just be amusing themselves by administering false information. Either way, I can't prove anything beyond my own personal experiences.

[Elegant Caveman]

Yeah, it does seem to come up a lot, and I've never seen anyone claim any other specific combination.

But this just seems like a strange thing to lie/troll about, so I don't know...

[masterofflys]

To be fair, the answer to the ghost lady's riddle in the reboot cemetry changes, so this could change, but it's three times in a row for me, so...

[jenn]

milk/blood/ichor seems to be the most common, that said in case it's wrong and not always the same i wouldn't want to mess up anyone elses' game. plus, the riddle is fairly easy.

[flamedance58]

Which is weird cause I've tried it and even the tips said it would be correct and yet it was still wrong.

[artofwar]

I've only seen milk/blood/ichor in my multiple runs. And to change the order, they'd have to change the text of the clues, so I'm skeptical that it varies until proven otherwise.

[No Time to Explain]

Originally posted by artofwar:

I've only seen milk/blood/ichor in my multiple runs. And to change the order, they'd have to change the text of the clues, so I'm skeptical that it varies until proven otherwise.

It doesnt vary.