Weapon Tier List

[FeaR]

https://tiermaker.com/create/hunt-showdown-weapon-tier-list---september-2023-16203698?presentationMode=true

*** I think the link shows my selection im correct?
*** The choices are based only on the standard weapons, no variants to make it simple.
*** None of 1 or 2 slots are here, also to make it simple and direct.
*** Prices, ammos and traits are associated with the note
*** This is what i think, but you can change my mind:

Resuming about some weapons that make some people question those choices:

Drilling: Solid A tier, but could be S tier... It´s more of less like a Centenial + a shorty shotgun but costs a house with custom ammo.

Lemat Carbine: Like the Drilling, but with tons of compac ammo and the same shorty shotgun included for just a fraction of the price. I think it is one of the best ''price vs performance'' in the game.

Martini Henry Ironside: Shoots like a Mosin / Lebel, but with even more damage and no traits needed... Nothing is perfect, so you also have a terrible thing blocking some vision in ADS and a bullet speed comparable to compact ammo. For the price, being long ammo, i think it´s a solid weapon.

Terminus is an horrible shotgun in my opinion, but using Levering you just have Crown and King rate of firing for a third of the price with similar performance with regular ammo.

Winnies 1873, Nagant Officer Carbine and Springfields have tons of fans and i get it... They are reliable (if used correct) specially for how cheap they are, but these days with free hunters being an option and weapons without progression make then somewhat obsolete.

-------------------------------------------------

I remember how popular are cheapest Winnies and Springfields back in the day...
One of my friends get so poor that he needed to make some games without a med kit. LOL

Since they add events giving more money, no need to unlock weapons and specially free hunters for people bellow 20K in cash, they also somewhat ''killed'' those weapons.

[Noxx]

When clicking your link I see an empty liest on Tiermaker. But feel free to make a screenshot and upload it to imgur or something like that and then add it to your post.

[Pipakrax]

Romero 77 is supreme S tier

[Noxx]

Well every weapon can be S Tier when you can perform well with it. And Romero is S Tier for sure due to it's high range for one hit kills and cheap price.

My Tierlist would look like this:

- S Tier: Officer Carbine, Uppercut, Winfield M1873 Swift, Martini Henry Ironside, Berthier, Drilling, Romero, Rival, Specter, Slate, Lebel, Sparks, Mosin, Krag, Pax, Conversion Pistol, Katana, Baseball Bat

- A Tier: Crossbow, Uppermat, Dolch, Winfield M1873 (other variants), basic Centennial, Vetterli, Nitro, Martini Henry (other variants), Springfield Marksman, Winfield M1873C, Officer pistol variants, Scottfield Swift, Handcrossbow, Saber

- B Tier: Bornheim, Centennial other variants, Terminus, Crown & King, Springfield (other variants), LeMat Carbine, New Army, Scottfield (other variants), Conversion Chainpistol, Hunting Bow

- C Tier: Officer Carbine Deadeye, Winfield M1873C (other variants), Sparks Silencer, Bomb Lance, Nagant pistol, Combat Axe, Railroad Hammer, Machete

- D Tier: Springfield compact variants, silenced Winfield, Avtomat

- F Tier: Springfield compact deadeye

Since money isn't a limiting factor in this game at all (getting rich in this game is fairly easy) I think that the Drilling is simply S-Tier. It has an incredible two tap range and is also very consistant with the shotgun. It may be a bit more expensive, but it kinda feels like a Sparks with a second shot available, especially if you use it with FMJ ammo.

My list kinda represents what kind of guns I feel confident with or which guns I like to play (except the Dolch on A Tier and Crown & King on B Tier, don't like playing these guns even though they're fairly strong).

[FeaR]

引用自 Noxx：

When clicking your link I see an empty liest on Tiermaker. But feel free to make a screenshot and upload it to imgur or something like that and then add it to your post.

Imgur dont let me sign in for some reason...
In this case:

S: Mosin / Lebel / Krag (after buff?)
A: Crown and King / Berthier / Krag (before buff) / Winfield Slate / LeMat Carbine / Vetterli / Drilling
B: Bomb Lance / Centennial / Martini Henry Ironside / Sparks / Specter / Vetterli Cyclone /
C: Nagant Officer Carbine / Winfield 1873 / Springfield / Romeros / Nitro and Avtomat
D: Winfield and Sparks Silencer / Caldweel Rival 78

--------------------------------------------------------

I love Romero, one of my favorite shotgun to play, but for an S Tier gun, im not sure.
If you miss, you are close to an enemy with a long reload to be made. If you hit and dont kill, same problem. Assuming that im not a good shotgun player overall, my best plays are using the Slate with Slugs or Romero Talon / Specter using the regular buck shot ammo.

For the price i can put in A Tier, but:

To make my decisions i use an ''overall'' scenario.
Hit, miss, overall damage, penetration, bullet speed to hit targets that are far and so on.

If you are close, hitting the chest, there´s almost no difference between a cheap Winfield 1873C that costs $ 48 for a Mosin that costs basically TEN TIMES MORE... Extended the range or durations of that fight at range and you can clearly see why Mosin is the absolute meta and probally the most used gun in higher rops.

Romero is a good gun, but even if you are a super skilled player, Romero isnt very reliable after something like 15 meters. Sometimes you are found in the open at range... Sometimes you are into a compound, sometimes you need to enter a compound... There are many situations where Romero can be too good to almost useless.

[Ciri Facial Elen Riannon]

imo the Krag was strong already with the fast fire rate. Its my (2.) favorite Gun who just got a Buff what makes this good weapon even better.
Mosin #1. + Uppercut.

Nagant Officer Carbine also good for me.

Shotguns. I think (when i play shotguns) The Romero, Specter und C&K deals the same dmg when i shoot them. So all "ok" weapons.

Everything "below" is like, not high-end meta. So, well :)

What did u wanted to get with that post?
You looking for a new loadout? Or wanted to discuss about some weapons?

[Noxx]

引用自 FeaR：

Imgur dont let me sign in for some reason...

Well sad to hear that, but you made it work anyways to get your personal tier list towards us.

引用自 FeaR：

I love Romero, one of my favorite shotgun to play, but for an S Tier gun, im not sure.
If you miss, you are close to an enemy with a long reload to be made. If you hit and dont kill, same problem. Assuming that im not a good shotgun player overall, my best plays are using the Slate with Slugs or Romero Talon / Specter using the regular buck shot ammo.

For the price i can put in A Tier, but:

To make my decisions i use an ''overall'' scenario.
Hit, miss, overall damage, penetration, bullet speed to hit targets that are far and so on.

If you are close, hitting the chest, there´s almost no difference between a cheap Winfield 1873C that costs $ 48 for a Mosin that costs basically TEN TIMES MORE... Extended the range or durations of that fight at range and you can clearly see why Mosin is the absolute meta and probally the most used gun in higher rops.

Romero is a good gun, but even if you are a super skilled player, Romero isnt very reliable after something like 15 meters. Sometimes you are found in the open at range... Sometimes you are into a compound, sometimes you need to enter a compound... There are many situations where Romero can be too good to almost useless.

Well I get that you reason your decisions with an "overall" scenario, though most fights aren't 150 meters plus, so even a Winfield 1873C with High Velocity is as good as a Mosin without Spitzer. Winfield High Velocity has a muzzle velocity of 600m/s and default Mosin sits at 615m/s. And the compact Winfield have a headshot range of 153 meters if I recall correctly. So instead of paying 10 times the money you can actually play a cheap loadout which is still effective. And an out of range headshot with a Winfield would still hurt quite a bit.

So yeah, why in general a Mosin deals more damage on higher distances it's rather short on ammo to spare, so if you miss a few shots (which was your argument with the romero not being a S Tier gun) I'd rather have a Winfield that is a bit more forgiving on the ammunition compared to only play as a meta slave.

And to counter your argument with Romero not being very reliable after 15 meters: You can two tap with a romero buckshot on like 25 meters. This would still be the effective range for romero slugs btw. So yeah, a Romero can miss in theory, but if you don't miss it still packs a punch. I sorted the guns more towards a "how much I like playing them and how rewarding they can be" scheme.

And yeah, as a shotgun player you still need to get towards locations, but that's why you play a secondary that deals a good amount of damage over a fair amount of distance, like the Uppercut or Pax (maybe even Scottfield with FMJ). Like what kind of argument is it that you're in a poor spot once you have to get to locations? I mean if you play a Romero with a Handcrossbow you'd certainly be right, but in normal scenarios you do have a sidearm, no?

I'd agree with most of your list except the Rival being on D Tier, Bomb Lance on B Tier and Avto on C Tier. Rival is extremely strong and can quickly two tap anyone that is barely out of it's effective range. Bomb Lance is mostly a meme weapon in higher elos and Avto got nerfed so hard into the ground that people only play this gun to either meme on people or if they want to create a video. Everything else seems to some point reasonable, cheers.

[Mikamus]

Martini ironside will soon be meta. High velocity for it was leaked. 600 m s.

[Noxx]

引用自 Mikamus：

Martini ironside will soon be meta. High velocity for it was leaked. 600 m s.

Wasn't it 500m/s?

[Mikamus]

引用自 Noxx：

引用自 Mikamus：

Martini ironside will soon be meta. High velocity for it was leaked. 600 m s.

Wasn't it 500m/s?

I thought it was 600 but the image in the video needed more JPEG so you might be right.

[Noxx]

引用自 Mikamus：

I thought it was 600 but the image in the video needed more JPEG so you might be right.

I thought somebody created a post with every data they could get from the deleted video and there the guy said something about 500m/s. Well we'll find out soon enough I guess.