PLEASE, dont capture every Monster u can kill

[Nik]

okey nvm

[TVMAN]

Originally posted by Nik:

There are materials that you only get throught carving the monster.

That's not true in MHW. Killing and capturing shares the exact same loot table.

[Retrox]

Pretty sure this is incorrect.

(in reference to OP)

[Lenny]

you get more mats from capturing, want to kill everything? play solo.

[Dr. Tran]

Correction: There are some materials you can only get as bonus rewards by breaking parts of a monster. Such as breaking both of Nergi's horns. But, the carve and capture reward pools are the same.

Edit: So if there are parts you haven't broken it's worth considering if you should continue fighting or capture immediately.

[Inner★Universe]

Not so. Also, if you join my game, I'm capturing my monsters. I burn through research points like crazy.

[Azreak]

Originally posted by Nik:

There are materials that you only get throught carving the monster. So when someone says dont capture the monster, please listen to them...

Stop circulating this lie. The loot tables for carves and capturing are the same.
There is nothing you cannot get from carves that you can't get with capturing, yes, this includes gems too.
Capturing gives more rewards. If you really want to be efficient about it, have anyone with cutting weapons cut the tail off first before capturing.
If you can't manage to do that, thats on you.

[TVMAN]

Originally posted by Nik:

the deviljho sclap can only be optained by carving

Again, not true.

https://monsterhunterworld.wiki.fextralife.com/Deviljho+Scalp

Breaking the head will give you a chance at getting one in the end-of-quest rewards.

[Castor Daedalus]

i've gotten the scalp as a reward without carving

[Keeves]

Originally posted by Nik:

the deviljho sclap can only be optained by carving

Wrong. All the Jho runs I did I would capture him. I have the fully upgraded Jho bow without a kill or investigation. You sir are just wrong lol

[Nik]

i broke his head so many times never got a scalp

[Keeves]

Originally posted by Nik:

i broke his head so many times never got a scalp

It's RNG.

[Nik]

okey

[TVMAN]

Originally posted by Nik:

i broke his head so many times never got a scalp

Your bad luck really doesn't have anything to do with how the game actually works. Aside from the material cost for traps, there's no downside to capturing.

[Meowser has not]

Originally posted by Nik:

There are materials that you only get throught carving the monster. So when someone says dont capture the monster, please listen to them... (the Deviljho Scalp for example)

Not even close, just break his head b4 you capture, its a break only reward not a carve only reward, they dont exist in MHW

[Shirokumo]

Killing is even worse, imo if you kill you throw loot away. If I can't break a part before the monster is near death I capture it because you have 4-5 rewards for capture while you can only carve 3 times (Not counting Elders) So you throw away a sure drop for a potential drop. If you kill it before you can break the part you leave with less then if you had trapped it.