Golf It! or Golf With Your Friends?

[Takk806]

Hi!

Thinking of buying one of these 2 titles for me and my gf.

Any ideas what are the pros and cons of each? Maybe some features that one has and the other doesn't?

Lemme know!

Thanks! :D

[Skooma Dealer]

Both are lots of fun with friends, but I think I enjoy Golf It! more. Golf It has a bit of a learning curve when it comes to figuring out the power you need to use which makes it more challenging but also more fun in my opinion. I also have more fun with the maps in Golf It, and the editor is much easier to use if you and your girlfriend ever wanted to try to make your maps. Since they're both on sale for the Winter sale, I'd recommend getting both, but if not I definitely find Golf It to be more enjoyable, but Golf With Your Friends is still an amazing game and better for beginners.

[秋]

Golf with your friends is WAY better in every way. Honestly I kinda regret buying this game.
But its still EA and there are not many golf games out there.
This game feels clunky and unpolished ( I mean its still in EA) and the courses are just alpha placeholder courses. They are not fun to play.
Meanwhile the courses in golf with your friends are really fun, varied and you have multiple game modes like normal golf, hockey and dunk.
I really want golf it to get good as a final product, but hold off for now!

[Frank Psiquiatra]

Golf It!. Next question

[theVillageIdiot]

Golf It is quite a bit better IMO. The level editor in GWYF is much less robust, leading to a much smaller variety of custom courses, and a game like this really thrives on the custom courses.

GWYF does have some physics objects though (like the black hole) and object solidifier thingy, and the stock courses are better.

I also prefer the golf swinging in Golf It - in things like GWYF, having a Power meter shown on screen basically guarantees that you can always dial in a shot

[NM9G]

The way I look at it is...

If you like memorizing the exact power with a dial that allows you to control your exact power to always score hole in ones, then Golf with your friends is the way to go.

If you like power to be unreliable and harder to get really good at, allowing for different results every match like a real mini golf course. Then Golf It is for you.

[Lina]

golft it is cool

[Draktok]

Originally posted by H19H3N3RGY:

Golf with your friends is WAY better in every way. Honestly I kinda regret buying this game.
But its still EA and there are not many golf games out there.
This game feels clunky and unpolished ( I mean its still in EA) and the courses are just alpha placeholder courses. They are not fun to play.
Meanwhile the courses in golf with your friends are really fun, varied and you have multiple game modes like normal golf, hockey and dunk.
I really want golf it to get good as a final product, but hold off for now!

IDK who this guy is talking to but he's out of his mind.

Golf it is more skill based, has better collision, a better workshop, are more active workshop, better custom map scripting and soon to be VR. Golf with your friends is probably worse in every way, tbh. I mean, the statement makes no sense. "The courses are just placeholder" ... what? No one plays these games for the 5 base maps, we all play for workshop maps. lol

[Zinx]

One reason i prefer golf it over GWYF is that there is some skill to it. Getting the accuracy down is hard, with GWYF it doesn't feel as realistic as you are just aiming and clicking the power level. GWYF was fun but once golf it came out, I had my answer. And now with VR, i don't think there is even a question at stake, imho of course.

[Arthur]

i agree