Great Club or Large Club?

[Charlie]

I've been looking around threads and people seem 50/50 on which one is the better weapon.

What do you think is the better of the giant clubs? I'm in the mood for smashing things.

[Scraps]

Reason why it's 50/50 is because they're both good weapons for different reasons.

Great Club: Better reach and attack power.

Large Club: Lighter, great synergy with poison buff

I'd say the best way to go about it is to find both, upgrade 'em, and experiment. See what you like best.

[Charlie]

Originally posted by Scorch Sunfire:

Reason why it's 50/50 is because they're both good weapons for different reasons.

Great Club: Better reach and attack power.

Large Club: Lighter, great synergy with poison buff

I'd say the best way to go about it is to find both, upgrade 'em, and experiment. See what you like best.

Which one do you like yourself? So I can get an understanding. I'm leaning very slightly towards the Large Club.

[󠁳⁧⁧ Kuroimaho]

There is no clear winner it's just a matter of personal taste, I switch between them depending on enemies and areas.

[The Great Brambino]

Large club is lighter and has a different moveset than the great club. I personally prefer the large club, but it's personal preference.

[Mr. Oibyr]

Large has a horizontal swing, inflicts poison and is faster, thus making it better for pvp.

Great only has better scaling(best in the game when magic/enchanted) and poise break, it's my all time best wep for pve. With the master key I run straight to Blighttown as soon as I get to Firelink.

[Scraps]

Originally posted by Charlie:

Which one do you like yourself? So I can get an understanding. I'm leaning very slightly towards the Large Club.

I like large club better for the above stated reasons. It's pretty much what everyone else is saying: personal preference.
If you're really unsure, get both to +14 and experiment a bit. See what you really like.

[Mr. Oibyr]

Large is a better "all in one" kinda weapon, but has to be farmed. I hear people get the Great so they can farm for a Large, lol. I have, I farm for 2: one Large +15, one Chaos Large +5.

[Archon]

Just use a katana, sunbro

[maksim.smagin.1980]

A huge club. Damage is the main thing in hammers, even the smallest difference is important. No more arguments are accepted)

[ɮɛǟ ♛]

Large Club