Every f*** NPC die?

[Etxxu]

Hi!!

Does anyone survive? Hahaha
I am finding every NPC hollow or dead haha. I don't know if I am doing something wrong

Thank you so much

[Hoid]

the only way for ALL of them to die is for you to kill them. NPCs being hollow is not a big deal (mostly an artistic/atmospheric choice from devs). some can die on their own.

[Etxxu]

Originally posted by Hoid:

the only way for ALL of them to die is for you to kill them. NPCs being hollow is not a big deal (mostly an artistic/atmospheric choice from devs). some can die on their own.

With hollow I mean like Crestfallen Knight attacking you on New Londo

And for now every NPC I have meet has died end game

[Dexter]

You're welcome! :)

[Etxxu]

Originally posted by gh0stwizard:

Originally posted by Etxxu:

Rhea, Sigmeyer, Logan, Crestfallen, etcétera, all of them die if you are able to finish their quests.

Rhea - depends on you
Logan - depends on you
Crestfallen - depends on you (don't talk with him and he will survive)
Solaire - depends on you
Griggs - depends on you
Domhnall of Zena - not die
Petrus - not die
Patches - not die
Laurentius - depends on you

The question is why do you buy all their spells if you are pure melee/pure mage/pure cleric/etc?

I mean finishing all of their dialogues or quests, I am trying to do everything it was thought to do. I buy everything (not yet because of the stats) to try get the achievements between this first run and the nexts in NG+. Of course they survive if you avoid them haha, but it is like playing Skyrim and only doing the main quest...

Rhea has two ways of dying.
Logan dies
Crestfallen dies if you finish his dialogue.
Solaire is, for now, alive. I don't know where it is supose to die as you say "depends on you" (I prefer not to know hahaha)
Griggs I don't know who he is neither hahaha (I know most of them by their attributes)
Domhall the same
Petrus it is yet alive, always in Firelink haha
Laurentius force me to kill him haha
Patches I don't know who he is
Sigmeyer dies (or in Lost Izalith or later when his child)
The pyromancer dies

[richardson]

Originally posted by gh0stwizard:

Originally posted by Etxxu:

Rhea, Sigmeyer, Logan, Crestfallen, etcétera, all of them die if you are able to finish their quests.

Rhea - depends on you
Logan - depends on you
Crestfallen - depends on you (don't talk with him and he will survive)
Solaire - depends on you
Griggs - depends on you
Domhnall of Zena - not die
Petrus - not die
Patches - not die
Laurentius - depends on you

The question is why do you buy all their spells if you are pure melee/pure mage/pure cleric/etc?

Quelana and Daughter of Chaos don't die.
Sieglinde doesn't die and if you help she even gets to say goodbye to her father
Oswald doesn't die
The Anor Londo firekeeper depends on you
No one who sells you anything dies - blacksmiths or merchants
Dusk does die (of old age since she lived in the past)

[Etxxu]

Originally posted by richardson:

Originally posted by gh0stwizard:

Rhea - depends on you
Logan - depends on you
Crestfallen - depends on you (don't talk with him and he will survive)
Solaire - depends on you
Griggs - depends on you
Domhnall of Zena - not die
Petrus - not die
Patches - not die
Laurentius - depends on you

The question is why do you buy all their spells if you are pure melee/pure mage/pure cleric/etc?

Quelana and Daughter of Chaos don't die.
Sieglinde doesn't die and if you help she even gets to say goodbye to her father
Oswald doesn't die
The Anor Londo firekeeper depends on you
No one who sells you anything dies - blacksmiths or merchants
Dusk does die (of old age since she lived in the past)

Fire keepers has no quests. I have said: NPC with quests or dialogue, so the fat one, Crestfallen, Logan, Rhea, etcétera, etcétera... They die

Logan, Rhea, and other sellers die after sellomg everything WTF hahahaha

[Myrmuz [IRL]]

You can see a list of npcs and their questlines here:
http://darksouls.wikidot.com/npcs

In general most of the characters are Undead and at risk of Hollowing. Hollowing seems to occur when a character either dies too much or loses their purpose.
For example, Laurentius hollows when you tell him of the Great Chaos Fireball pyromancy. You can find him in the swamp. It seems to me that he was either rejected from the Chaos Servants covenant or rejected as a new apprentice by Quelana, or both.
Some never go Hollow, like Marvelous Chester, but those usually don't have distinct questlines.
So complete questline = loss of purpose = Hollow.
Not always but often. If you want to keep them sane, don't complete their questlines, allow them to keep their purpose in life.

[Etxxu]

Originally posted by Myrmuz IRL:

You can see a list of npcs and their questlines here:
http://darksouls.wikidot.com/npcs

In general most of the characters are Undead and at risk of Hollowing. Hollowing seems to occur when a character either dies too much or loses their purpose.
For example, Laurentius hollows when you tell him of the Great Chaos Fireball pyromancy. You can find him in the swamp. It seems to me that he was either rejected from the Chaos Servants covenant or rejected as a new apprentice by Quelana, or both.
Some never go Hollow, like Marvelous Chester, but those usually don't have distinct questlines.
So complete questline = loss of purpose = Hollow.
Not always but often. If you want to keep them sane, don't complete their questlines, allow them to keep their purpose in life.

Thats why Laurentius dies? Definitely this game is a "Prepare to die"... but for the NPC too hahahaha

Thank you so much!!
I don´t like that they all die by finishing the game, but not doing everything it was supose to be done... Poor NPCs, I guess they are gonna die again in my NG+ hahaha