Knight's honor achievement

[yds]

As usual, the online sources tell different things. Some say Artorias' weapons are needed for this achievement (but no other DLC weapons for some reason), others say no DLC weapons are needed at all.

I would appreciate anyone who actually got the achievement here on Steam to point me to a valid and complete list of weapons I need.

Getting all of them would be pretty annoying, but I still want to do it, since I have so few achievements left.

* I understand that it's quite difficult to make a complete list of ONLY the weapons needed for the achievement. Because I'm sure most players who got the achievement, also obtained a lot of extra weapons as well.

---

I found this Steam guide, which also has Artorias' weapons listed, but no other DLC weapons (and it's for prepare to die, not rematererd) . https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=169482240

[Lumina]

I think this different sources about Artorias' weapons are caused because of translation issues.
You don't need the weapon you can make from Artorias' Soul. ( Abyss Greatsword)
But you need 3 Souls of Sif , to make one shield and two swords. Players often don't figure out the difference between the 2 swords and accidently make two times the same.

But I'm sorry I can not point you to a complete liste. I got the achievements already 4 times, and that's why I know the requirements now without to use a liste. Not able to remember all and write them down.
Hm, I think this one is correct.
https://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Knight's+Honor+Achievement+Guide

[yds]

Originally posted by Lumina:

I think this different sources about Artorias' weapons are caused because of translation issues.
You don't need the weapon you can make from Artorias' Soul. ( Abyss Greatsword)
But you need 3 Souls of Sif , to make one shield and two swords. Players often don't figure out the difference between the 2 swords and accidently make two times the same.

But I'm sorry I can not point you to a complete liste. I got the achievements already 4 times, and that's why I know the requirements now without to use a liste. Not able to remember all and write them down.
Hm, I think this one is correct.
https://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Knight's+Honor+Achievement+Guide

Thanks, I guess I'm stupid. I forgot that Artorias' weapons are made from Soul of Sif. And yeah, I gotta be careful about the two versions of his sword.

[Lumina]

Btw: nobody here can see your achievements. Don't you want set your profile and games to public ?

[yds]

Originally posted by Lumina:

Btw: nobody here can see your achievements. Don't you want set your profile and games to public ?

Um, my achievements were already visible. My playtime was hidden, but I opened it now too just to check if it works. But again, I could see my achievements before when I opened my profile in browser, so they were public

[⎛ PlamAtom ⎞]

Artorias of the Abyss DLC is not required as you can see on my screenshoots and trophy date i found it very late after completing the Knight's honor achievement.

[damoclez]

Originally posted by Lumina:

Btw: nobody here can see your achievements. Don't you want set your profile and games to public ?

He has set them to public? He has 37/41 atm.
More than I have, but I don't 'chase' achievements, tbh..

[Lumina]

Originally posted by damoclez:

Originally posted by Lumina:

Btw: nobody here can see your achievements. Don't you want set your profile and games to public ?

He has set them to public? He has 37/41 atm.
More than I have, but I don't 'chase' achievements, tbh..

Yes, it is to see better now, he changed some privacy seetings. :)

[yds]

I'm getting this achievement on my overleveled character, and turns out it's not that hard to collect most of the weapons. I'm on NG+ now and have nearly everything I need. Killed Smough and Super Ornstein with Pyro, it's still easy.

Now I just need to cut Seath's tail, farm for BK shield, and (ouch) Channeler's Trident. I guess I'll spend some quality time in the Archives. Oh, and buy Stone Greatsword/shield from the Forest clan dude (I think he sells them).

And then on to NG++ to get the 3rd soul of Sif. Hope I don't mess up anywhere else.

I also need to collect all the miracles and all the spells, but I might do that in a separate playthrough.

[yds]

I got it! Now I have way more weapons than I know what to do with lol