[Spoilers] ANF: Eleanor vs. Kate

[Nebulous]

So early in my play through of ANF, I tried to pursue Eleanor instead of Kate which in the end made my relationship with Kate mixed which left me unsatisfied. Clearly Kate was the intended love interest and I realized that somewhere in the middle, but did anyone else do what I did?

[dnc510]

no, you're not alone, my friend. I tried to go after Eleanor as well, cuz I did not feel right goin after Kate, it felt too much like rick/lori/shane from the show, and felt too forced, and I'm just not that kinda person, i aint makin Javi that guy, I can't do that to my brother.

[CB]

Kate, for me, was "Distant." I couldn't disrespect David like that :(

[11:11]

I hate Kate, it is wrong to have a relationship with brother's wife and it is morally wrong to make an affair when David was still alive.
I like Eleanor more but cannot understand why she made Tripp died.

Does women wants a man to die when she know he has a crush on her ? :3

[Vladislak]

Originally posted by Kyal ko pal chit tar par :(:

I hate Kate, it is wrong to have a relationship with brother's wife and it is morally wrong to make an affair when David was still alive.
I like Eleanor more but cannot understand why she made Tripp died.

Does women wants a man to die when she know he has a crush on her ? :3

Spoilers my friend, you may want to edit your post to tag them as such since the OP said they were early in their playthrough.

To be fair Javi and Kate thought David was dead for literally years, they had no way of knowing he was alive so any feelings they may have developed for one another in that time is a bit less immoral than you might think.

I'm not saying I liked Kate much, but things likely would have played out differently if they'd known.

As for Eleanor, I liked her until she suddenly turned into a traitor and then blamed everything on Javi. After that I couldn't care less about her.