NieR:Automata™

NieR:Automata™

View Stats:
Red Star, Blood Moon Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:31am
14
2
4
Is there any reason to play this game?
Or is it literally just marketed towards 12 year olds and unemployed weebs? Because judging by just the reviews on front page alone, I'm leaning more towards all the hype this thing got came just from a bunch of unemployed anime watching weebs who never would've played it otherwise.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 265 comments
Red Star, Blood Moon Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:32am 
Or to phrase this another way, if the main character was just a C3PO looking robot, and your sidekick was also clearly just an android, and there wasn't even a hint of skirts, would you have still played it and recommended this game?
Kyururun Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:40am 
Yes I would still have played it. Automata is over represented by 2B's ass, even more so when it was just released. But having finished the game I can say the story, character development and music alone would keep me playing even if all the characters are replaced with robots.
Last edited by Kyururun; Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:43am
Red Star, Blood Moon Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:50am 
Originally posted by Vanilla:
Yes I would still have played it. Automata is over represented by 2B's ass, even more so when it was just released. But having finished the game I can say the story, character development and music alone would keep me playing even if all the characters are replaced with robots.
>anime avatar
You know, I just was in another thread where the OP asked a very valid question about choking a robot, and your phrasing itself has forced me to ask: these are robots right? I mean in the sense of, it's literally robots and humanity is extinct, basically SOMA tier plot. Probably barely worth the effort of spoilering since that much is obvious but may as well not be a ♥♥♥♥ about it.
> Automata is over represented by 2B's ass,
This still seems to be the case and this morning I'll give one shred of benefit of doubt to it still, since I remember so many people trying to claim it was allegedly "deep" back in the day, but then I see well just this forum itself on top of the front page reviews, and it's at best done a massive disservice to the game. The little I did see about it made the gameplay look pretty weak to just outright terrible, seemingly openly bad combat for the sake of a skirt lift. But even then, even with atrocious gameplay or illogical plot, enough people said the story was good, but just reading these reviews I have to ask:
is the story "good" in the same way people tried telling me Life is Strange or a TellTale game is some "masterpiece"? Or is this another sappy anime tier plot about "what if we're all just feeling robots and here's a romance plot and my adopted sister-niece" type thing?

Because sheesh ten minutes of these reviews makes me want to be insulting. Is this an actual scifi story, or it is just anime?
idkfa67 Mar 19, 2022 @ 6:16am 
Depends. The game's not bad, it has a distinctive style, alright story and is enjoyable in many ways. However, now that it's few years old, it doesn't seem to become classics or have any replay value. Probably if you're asking then you'd better just go get Elden Ring.
FeiCaSh Mar 19, 2022 @ 7:47am 
Originally posted by BlackSun:
Is there any reason to play this game?
2B
Last edited by FeiCaSh; Mar 19, 2022 @ 7:47am
2B's ass seems like more then enough a good reason to play this game. Aside from that though I think the game itself is pretty fun with an interesting story.
Kyururun Mar 19, 2022 @ 9:22am 
Originally posted by BlackSun:
Originally posted by Vanilla:
Yes I would still have played it. Automata is over represented by 2B's ass, even more so when it was just released. But having finished the game I can say the story, character development and music alone would keep me playing even if all the characters are replaced with robots.
>anime avatar
You know, I just was in another thread where the OP asked a very valid question about choking a robot, and your phrasing itself has forced me to ask: these are robots right? I mean in the sense of, it's literally robots and humanity is extinct, basically SOMA tier plot. Probably barely worth the effort of spoilering since that much is obvious but may as well not be a ♥♥♥♥ about it.
> Automata is over represented by 2B's ass,
This still seems to be the case and this morning I'll give one shred of benefit of doubt to it still, since I remember so many people trying to claim it was allegedly "deep" back in the day, but then I see well just this forum itself on top of the front page reviews, and it's at best done a massive disservice to the game. The little I did see about it made the gameplay look pretty weak to just outright terrible, seemingly openly bad combat for the sake of a skirt lift. But even then, even with atrocious gameplay or illogical plot, enough people said the story was good, but just reading these reviews I have to ask:
is the story "good" in the same way people tried telling me Life is Strange or a TellTale game is some "masterpiece"? Or is this another sappy anime tier plot about "what if we're all just feeling robots and here's a romance plot and my adopted sister-niece" type thing?

Because sheesh ten minutes of these reviews makes me want to be insulting. Is this an actual scifi story, or it is just anime?

>anime avatar
I take no offense but just for your info i have played my share of games (soulsbourne, monster hunter, assassin's creed, gta V etc)

>robots
They are robots. But what i meant was like if they looked like robots (Like the C3PO looking robot you mentioned) instead of looking more human.

>gameplay
Well it is a typical hack and slash more on the simplistic side compared to combat systems you can find in like elden ring, the witcher 3, breath of the wild etc. It does have twists from time to time that changes the gameplay with a bigger change happening after starting from the second play through.

>story
Well it's not your typical save the world or everything goes good crap for sure. Yoko Taro's stories tend to fall on the darker aspects and more philosophical side (Other than the main plot, it can be seen in most of the side quests as well). The game goes in the direction of stuff like "What is the meaning of life", "Why are we here just to suffer". "2B or not 2B" (XD) etc.

Regarding the romance, pretty sure there are only like small hints of it in the game. leaving much to interpretation. It may not even be in the romantic sense, from a different perspective I can see it being familial instead. The romance probably got blown out of proportion due to it being what most people want and so they interpret it as such.

Automata is also a sort of a sequel to the previous game (Nier replicant/Nier). While not a direct sequel it happens like way way way long after the previous game. A lot of stuff can be found that is linked to the previous game which allows for moments of "I KNOW THIS" or "SO THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED TO IT AFTER XXXX YEARS" for those who played the previous. These stuff are not extremely necessary for the main plot though (Different characters and unlinked main plot) which is why you can play Automata without playing the previous or do it the other way around.

The story presentation though deserves a point in my book. Yoko Taro likes to tell his stories with more than one medium other than the game (Stage plays, novels, books, manga etc) which gives out new information about the world or plot that cannot be found from just the game alone. Hell. the series started from being a stage play itself before even becoming games. There's even a whole wiki dedicated for what to read or do after finishing the game.

In the game itself though, most of the side quests are some what connected and have a degree of relevance to the main plot. If you dig further like the weapon stories, you can find more hidden information as well.

And the game does have a very special and memorable moment (Not for the characters but for you as the player) that can only be experienced in this game (So far have not found any similar) if you pull through all the way to the end of the game.
Last edited by Kyururun; Mar 19, 2022 @ 9:30am
Bun Mar 19, 2022 @ 12:13pm 
Has one of the best soundtracks in games.
Desert area: https://youtu.be/Iyaex2JRMzU
Last edited by Bun; Mar 19, 2022 @ 12:13pm
Sola Di Ryuvia Mar 19, 2022 @ 4:44pm 
One of the best soundtracks in gaming history tbh. Same with NieR Replicant. Automata started me down the rabbit hole that was NieR universe and Drakengard universe. Story is pretty massive and consists across 2 different game series. Yet the story is made well enough you don't need to play Replicant or Drakengard to enjoy the story of Automata. It just makes it hit pretty different when you've played Automata or Drakengard 1 and 3. (don't touch drakengard 2 though)
gthk4 Mar 19, 2022 @ 6:44pm 
BGM, story and the characters.
Last edited by gthk4; Mar 19, 2022 @ 6:44pm
River Victor Mar 19, 2022 @ 9:54pm 
The story is probably one of the best RPGs of all time. The philosophical aspect of it, the emotional aspects of it, the music, all top-notch. That 2B has nicest as is just a plus. I'm gay and I have absolutely no trouble with or without her ass.
East Mar 20, 2022 @ 4:05am 
Music is amazing, story keeps you going for dozens of hours.

Not my type of games usually, and Square Enix is an awful awful dumpster full of wasps, that is set on fire.

I'd play it and send Squenix' President a letter with poop.
Nyx Mar 20, 2022 @ 6:18am 
Originally posted by BlackSun:
seemingly openly bad combat for the sake of a skirt lift.
What are you even talking about?
Originally posted by BlackSun:
But even then, even with atrocious gameplay or illogical plot, enough people said the story was good
Why are you just choosing that everything negative you read about the game is fact and everything good is just dubious opinion?
Originally posted by BlackSun:
is the story "good" in the same way people tried telling me Life is Strange or a TellTale game is some "masterpiece"? Or is this another sappy anime tier plot about "what if we're all just feeling robots and here's a romance plot and my adopted sister-niece" type thing?
Heck, what even is "good" story for you? DOOM? Dark Souls?

Yes, the story is amazing, we are telling you. It goes deep into philosophical questions about sorrow and existence, though this game is definitely that meme where the average person is looking at it and make some dumb comment about some trivial thing while the point goes completely over their head.
If you are a rock without feelings and just want a "plot" of "pick up gun, walk over there, shoot things, win", then I don't know what to tell you other than this game is not for you.
MShields Mar 20, 2022 @ 7:18am 
A friend recommended this game to me. Bought because of an android ass, left traumatized.
Cloud McFox Mar 21, 2022 @ 2:02am 
Originally posted by BlackSun:
Or to phrase this another way, if the main character was just a C3PO looking robot, and your sidekick was also clearly just an android, and there wasn't even a hint of skirts, would you have still played it and recommended this game?
Yes.

The game is not defined by 2B's ass, and you are losing an amazing 40 hour-long experience by believing that this game is overglorified because of a juicy ass.

Just make sure to play this with a controller, or you'll have to install a mod that makes the KB&M controls bearable (although the process is not at all complicated, so you'll manage to do it just fine)
< >
Showing 1-15 of 265 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Mar 19, 2022 @ 5:31am
Posts: 265