Best RPG ever made!

[Fuhror]

Some will argue that BG2 is better but in my book, Planescape Torment is the ultimate RPG and by a long shot.

[Radene]

BG2 is second to this one, indeed.

[Ar373]

BG1 is the best

[matthew]

depends, I do like BG1,, but both BG 1 and 2 have a balanced amount of combat and story, while PST iis very story driven. then on the other side of the scale, the IWD series is focused on combat.

I really think its down to what type of a cRPG you like playing really, and if you like doing a lot of reading, if so, then I would also class PST to be the best cRPG out there.

[Goral]

Fallout 1, Arcanum and Age of Decadence are better. BG are mediocre.

[Vitowns]

I'd say Planescape Torment is the best rpg of all history of rpg games, with Chrono Trigger and Fallout 2

[rshefland]

i love fallout one of the best no doubt

[Stoibs]

Planescape would get a perfect score from me if it had loads less combat, or if the combat was actually decent/less repetitive. It mostly got in the way of all the dialogue, world building and brilliant writing. For instance I'm loving Tides of Numenera so far and can't at all agree with the reviews that are bashing it for its lack of fighting, since that's what I actually prefer and have used social/alternative routes to avoid as many as I could so far.

I do love me some Baldur's gate and it is certainly up there in my top 5 games of all time list, but once again when it comes to the combat side of things I tend to lose interest and have never really enjoyed these RTwP mash-the-space-button-every-2-seconds affairs.
Tend to engage in way more slaughter than your typical DnD based campaign also, which loses its appeal quickly and especially at the higher levels when you're felling dragons left and right with your legendary artifacts that are seemingly a dime a dozen.

Turn based still reigns supreme for me, and so I gotta give it to the likes of Fallout, Arcanum, Underrail, Dead State etc.
I've heard nothing but good things about Age of decadence, just waiting for the next sale and I'll pick that up too :)

[Ar373]

Dead State is one of the worst games I ever played. I regret every single cent I spent on it. Arcanum is definitely one of the best RPGs ever. Age of Decadence is in my library but haven't played yet. Fallout is good but I never understood the hype, I think its a bit overrated.

[Thadeus]

1st. Planescape: Torment
2nd. Fallout 2
3rd. Baldur's Gate 2
4th. Knights of the old Republic.
5th. Mass Effect 2 & 3

[Drakken]

PT is the best for me, then BG2 and then F2
Today Avellone & crew can't released games like this anymore. :/

[Battlekruse]

I consider Fallout and Planescape Torment to be some of the best RPG I ever played. Icewind Dale and Baldur´s Gate was also good.

[Zed]

Never understood why people think this game is good. I gave it a try, but after playing for something like a dozen hours I was still stuck in the same couple areas of the same city I started in and essentially all that had been accomplished was I got some people to join my party and I completed a couple sidequests by... talking to people. Literally fought nothing but around 15 thieves and one dude I killed in a dual.

I'll admit the setting was cool and some of the story had me intrigued, but holy crap is there anything in this game except talking to people? If I want to read a book I'll go read a book. I've played visual novels with more interactive gameply than this.

And yes I've played BG 1, 2, Fallout 1, 2, IWD, KOTOR, etc and thouroughly enjoyed all of them.

[pseudobrgr]

I loved baldurs gate games (aswell as iwd and nwn), but this game is the ♥♥♥♥.

[Stoibs]

引用自 Zed：

.

That's fine, it's certainly not for everyone.
If the characters, writing and worldbuilding/setting can't draw you in then it's not the game for you.
I'm in the same boat about some other recent releases which have received high praise (Pillars of Eternity; I absolutely hated that. I just could not at any point find a single interesting or relatable thing within the story, the writing was dreadful and I didn't care one iota about any of the characters even after learning their backstories)

Different strokes and all that.

[AdahnGorion]

引用自 Fuhror：

Some will argue that BG2 is better but in my book, Planescape Torment is the ultimate RPG and by a long shot.

We already had a thread with the same premis. The problem is that almost all thinks PS:T is the best! not the way around. I personally don't know any RPG fans that would list BG2 above PS:T