Scout Weapon Tier List (Now with Melee)

[fakeloo]

Basic tier list for scout weapons, comment if you see something you disagree with and I might change its placement.

Note: This is geared towards gamemodes like CP, PL, Arena, and CTF, not really MvM. Sorry for not making this clear earlier.

PRIMARIES

S
Baby Face's Blaster

A
Scattergun
Soda Popper
Shortstop

B
Force of Nature

C
Backscatter

SECONDARIES

S
Crit-a-Cola
Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol

A
Pistol
Mad Milk

B
Winger
Bonk! Atomic Punch

C
The Flying Guillotine

MELEE

S
Atomizer
Sandman

A
Boston Basher

B
Candy Cane
Wrap Assassin

C
Bat
Fan O'War
Sun on a Stick

[fakeloo]

Цитата допису Segafan11:

Цитата допису Bangiras:

I put the bat above the Sun on a Stick just because it is more consistent, though they're both godawful so I'll probably abolish D and move them all to C as the crap rank.

Sandman probably deserves a raise, will move it up.

Wrap assassin ball damage does mediocre damage and the melee damage is godawful, though I suppose scout melee as a whole is pretty ♥♥♥♥ damage-wise so I'll move it to B. Basher jumping is more useful than it so I don't want to put it in A.


FaN does enough to heavies on its own, other scatters kill heavies without mini crits just as well as with them.

Good luck meleeing a medic against a competent team.

Demos/Pyros die to two meatshots anyways.

It's pointless most of the time.

Scout Melee Damage doesn't matter since you shouldn't be choosing them for damage but utility and the wrap offers a pretty good one since it's a good alternative of finishing off opponents

It can finish off opponents, but so can the pistols or even just reloading your scatter and shooting them with that. It's better than the stock and doesn't have much of a downside so it should be above the Bat, but it isn't quite on the same level as the Basher so it will stay in B, at least for now.

edit: Whoops forgot to mention the changes I made

UPDATE

Abolished D Rank for melees
Moved Fan O' War up to C
Moved Sun on a Stick up to C
Moved Wrap Assassin up to B
Moved Sandman up to S

[Vallinek]

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

["Old Hickory" James]

Цитата допису Vallinek:

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

Oh yeah.
I offered to help for Spy and Pyro.

[Stake from Jate Farm]

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

Цитата допису Vallinek:

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

Oh yeah.
I offered to help for Spy and Pyro.

Pyro:

S: Powerjack

That is all

[Segatic]

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

Цитата допису Vallinek:

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

Oh yeah.
I offered to help for Spy and Pyro.

I call medic

["Old Hickory" James]

Цитата допису The Slenderborn:

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

Oh yeah.
I offered to help for Spy and Pyro.

Pyro:

S: Powerjack

That is all

C: Stock Axe and Sharpened Volcano Fragment

[Stake from Jate Farm]

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

Цитата допису The Slenderborn:

Pyro:

S: Powerjack

That is all

C: Stock Axe

F: Sharpened Volcano Fragment

Fixed

[Fumo Bnnuy n Frends]

i would move the crit a cola to A if you use the BFB or backscatter
it sorta depletes the purpose

["Old Hickory" James]

Цитата допису The Slenderborn:

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

C: Stock Axe

F: Sharpened Volcano Fragment

Fixed

It goes S, A, B, C.
The "blech" items go in C.

[Stake from Jate Farm]

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

Цитата допису The Slenderborn:

Fixed

It goes S, A, B, C.
The "blech" items go in C.

The SVF is so bad, it gains a whole new lower teir.

["Old Hickory" James]

Цитата допису The Slenderborn:

Цитата допису "Old Hickory" James:

It goes S, A, B, C.
The "blech" items go in C.

The SVF is so bad, it gains a whole new lower teir.

Even the Third Degree outshines it.
Personally, I'd rate the Third Degree as a B item.

[fakeloo]

Цитата допису Vallinek:

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

I plan to do so, though I'm not very good and/or experienced with some classes so I'd have to play with them a bit more.

[Tuwulin :3]

Цитата допису Bangiras:

Цитата допису Segafan11:

Lol at Sandman on A

Wrap assasin at C

Fan O' War at D

And Bat at C

There are a lkt of post explain how the Sandman is Op or Broken so i won't touch that since it's a S class fit more than the atomizer.

Wrap Assain takes your Weak melee damage andgives you a ball that causes bleed and it's great at finishing opponents and you shouldn't be swinging your melee so...A rank

Bat is competing with the Sun on a Stick for worse melle and giving them C rank is a Offense to nature.

Fan O' War gives a way better benefit for a Single hit and are way better that the Bat and SoaS

I put the bat above the Sun on a Stick just because it is more consistent, though they're both godawful so I'll probably abolish D and move them all to C as the crap rank.

Sandman probably deserves a raise, will move it up.

Wrap assassin ball damage does mediocre damage and the melee damage is godawful, though I suppose scout melee as a whole is pretty ♥♥♥♥ damage-wise so I'll move it to B. Basher jumping is more useful than it so I don't want to put it in A.

Цитата допису Xtweeter22x:

FAN O WAR!? THAT LOW?

I beg your pardon, I believe people understimate it because they don't know how to use it for the life of them.

Got a Heavy who didn't look behind him? Tap, 2 FaN meatshots, done.

Got a Medic? Tap, if you die, the rest of your team will get him. Medics are the most obvious targets anyway.

Got any class with a max hp of 150 or higher? Tap. Especially Demos or unwary pyros.

Just need a quick kill on anything? Tap. Meat. if not, meat again.

FaN does enough to heavies on its own, other scatters kill heavies without mini crits just as well as with them.

Good luck meleeing a medic against a competent team.

Demos/Pyros die to two meatshots anyways.

It's pointless most of the time.

Basically its main purpous is to mark important targets for your team to handle. Discouraged a dual-Medic chain just like that.

[Nostril]

Цитата допису Vallinek:

I guess the tier list looks accurate enough.
Hmm... I think it would be a good idea to do something like this for all classes.

just did engineer

[NotSoMewwo]

Guys how about comsetics?