Attacted Maladie, did I f*k it up?

[Squike Wardmantraut]

So I was on my way to leave the island, I had to defeat Alexander on the beach. After I killed him and his mates, Maladie appeared. She approached me and started talking. At one point, she asked which God I'm "working" for. Since I didn't want to answer her and there was no possibility to end the dialog without telling her, I switched to another player and hit her from behind. Since then, she just disappeared. How do I progress now?

what do I do now?