A Skull. It's missing an eye.

[𝐎ᥣᑯ𝐑𝖾ᑯ𝐅ⱺ𝗑]

Where is the eye?

[Chaoslink]

In a bag, through a hatch, unlocked by an amulet, on the guy you're hunting, in a cave, to the West.

[phenir]

Thievery also works

[𝐎ᥣᑯ𝐑𝖾ᑯ𝐅ⱺ𝗑]

Thanks. I had to search for a video that explained it.

[Chaoslink]

Originally posted by Running Red Fox:

Thanks. I had to search for a video that explained it.

Had to is a bit of an exaggeration I think. You could have just waited and figured it out later since, unless you pick it with thievery, it’s something you’re supposed to have to come back later for.