Lohse and Saheila Attitude problem

[FatGuySmough]

Hi, i'm in Act 1 still and playing as Lohse for me main, it reach this Saheila lady in the caves and have a tussle, i let them beat me up while the lady is saying it's not my fault and she understands but after it i still get a -45 attitude with everyone in the cave!

Am i doing something wrong?
Is there a way to not take the -45 but still do this quest?
Will the -45 influence the quests that i have with everyone in the cave and will it ♥♥♥♥ me up for the futura acts if i find them again?

[Chaoslink]

You shouldn't have any future issues with the attitude loss. If anything, you can open barter with her and give her a hundred gold or so to fix it. Any time you enter combat against NPCs, you lose 50 attitude at least. You have to offer money or items free to gain that back. Unfortunately you're not going to avoid losing it, its just part of that interaction. If you wish, you can have your allies wait outside while Lohse does this by herself. Doing so prevents your allies from losing the reputation so they can talk to anyone in there without the loss.

Don't worry though, it won't affect the future at all.

[FatGuySmough]

Originally posted by Chaoslink:

You shouldn't have any future issues with the attitude loss. If anything, you can open barter with her and give her a hundred gold or so to fix it. Any time you enter combat against NPCs, you lose 50 attitude at least. You have to offer money or items free to gain that back. Unfortunately you're not going to avoid losing it, its just part of that interaction. If you wish, you can have your allies wait outside while Lohse does this by herself. Doing so prevents your allies from losing the reputation so they can talk to anyone in there without the loss.

Don't worry though, it won't affect the future at all.

Thank you so much for the answer!
I did imagine that it would fail either way since i passed both the skill checks and still wanted to kill her, that kinda sucks, but it's nice knowing it wont affect me because i wanted her to have that piece of story and not ♥♥♥♥ up any plot lines in later acts because of this silly thing where they hate me even if she understands.

Nice tip on letting everyone outside, that should help also if i just buy the things with another character or do the quests for these ones in the caves.

Thanks a bunch for the quick help!

[Chaoslink]

I don't know if killing her is the best idea though. Saheila does make appearances later, though.... well let's just say I don't know if/how killing her in act one affects anything. You're supposed to let Lohse lose and get really low health to break out. The game is designed to let you do whatever you want (though not always without consequence) so you can definitely beat the game by killing her and I doubt it'll have too huge an impact, at least on leveling/gameplay, but I just wanted to chime in again and say that Saheila does reappear later on.

[FatGuySmough]

Originally posted by Chaoslink:

I don't know if killing her is the best idea though. Saheila does make appearances later, though.... well let's just say I don't know if/how killing her in act one affects anything. You're supposed to let Lohse lose and get really low health to break out. The game is designed to let you do whatever you want (though not without consequence) so you can definitely beat the game by killing her and I doubt it'll have too huge an impact, at least on leveling/gameplay, but I just wanted to chime in again and say that Saheila does reappear later on.

Oh in the original post i said i let her beat me up, they get me to about 20% and the fight ends, Saheila understands and all but everyone on the cave STILL gets -45 attitude even if she kept yelling in the fight that i was possessed, really just wanted to see if them having -45 would be a deal breaker on anything.

[J]

When I did this fight, Lohse ended up killing Saheila in the battle, but she came back to life right after.

[ppaladin123]

Originally posted by Chaoslink:

I don't know if killing her is the best idea though. Saheila does make appearances later, though.... well let's just say I don't know if/how killing her in act one affects anything. You're supposed to let Lohse lose and get really low health to break out. The game is designed to let you do whatever you want (though not always without consequence) so you can definitely beat the game by killing her and I doubt it'll have too huge an impact, at least on leveling/gameplay, but I just wanted to chime in again and say that Saheila does reappear later on.

Killing her does change a bunch of things. In the second act you can help her mother get "revenge" against Roost by letting her continue to think that Roost killed Sahelia (he has been hunting and killjng scions other tha Sahelia). You can't get the source point Sahelia would have given you though (though there are many other sources). Later Sahelia is not around to opine on the Ancestor Tree and make requests.