Finishing Advocate's AND Jahan's quests.

[gungadin22000]

In my attempt to gain maximum rewards, I just killed all the guys around the enchanted tree on Bloodsomething Island. The Advocate then appeared and congratulated me on being super evil. I am doing a Good Guy playthrough and don't want to be associated with demons later in the game - does this mean that I can just attack Advocate now and then finish Jahan's quest or do I need to kill Advocate first and then the Black Ring members guarding the tree?

[Berengar]

just kill everyone on that island :D :) theres evil everywhere

[Shirome Artiste]

The cultists around the tree are not "Good Guys". Killing them is doing the world a favor.

After the Advocate congratualates you on your murderous prowess you can turn around and kill him.

Do note that the Advocate collects most of his stray followers spread around the island to wander around the tree with him once you clear out the cultists though, so expect a fight with a bunch of adds.


Welp, at least the necro involved relevant information.

[Eliof Astora]

lol he will ditch you after you help him kill the black ring peeps around the tree....
Help the advocate's quest first though, it wont ruin Jahan's quest... but im not sure if that may be considered as an evil playthrough

[Dauntless]

Black Ring - basically fantasy satanists

Advocate and pals - demons

They both Evil

[greyfeld]

Yeah, I just killed the Black Ring dudes first, then killed the Advocate. They both needed to die, so I took care of it.

To avoid getting swarmed with adds, I teleported the Advocate a couple screens away before engaging in combat. I managed to down him just as like 3 more enemies were getting there, then cleaned up the dregs.