The Silent One & Buttons *Spoilers*

[Max and Omnis]

I don't think it makes sense that I can take just the girl to the ship. The cat is obviously loyal to her and poses no harm. Why leave the cat alone in the dungeon? Why can't I take the cat too? It is animal cruelty.

[Rainy Skies]

I could never take the girl with me without killing buttons, and I still don't know how to wake her up.
I have 80's in my stats for persuasion rolls and it still fails.

[Banana]

You can kill the cat

[Max and Omnis]

Originally posted by Azurus:

I could never take the girl with me without killing buttons, and I still don't know how to wake her up.
I have 80's in my stats for persuasion rolls and it still fails.

Talk to the cat first, offer to help, break the columns, and then talk to the girl. I did the strength check persuasion. Don't know if other persuasions will work.

[Zothem]

I had 3 persuation and 27 memory but had to kill the cat. Pet Pal and high persuation is a must in this game and major disappointment if you don't have it. Sadly when this is discovered it's this disappointment or the disappointment of starting all over and loose the feeling of the characters and story so far. I will not. It is as it is.

[Ozymandias]

If you plan on persuading people, you have to max persuasion on at least one character (preferably your petpal person). Also, the stat doesn't matter as much as the context.

[Stinkehund]

Originally posted by Zothem:

I had 3 persuation and 27 memory but had to kill the cat. Pet Pal and high persuation is a must in this game and major disappointment if you don't have it. Sadly when this is discovered it's this disappointment or the disappointment of starting all over and loose the feeling of the characters and story so far. I will not. It is as it is.

Err... Or you can just use the mirror on your ship to respec characters without losing anything.

[Lyra]

Originally posted by Azurus:

I could never take the girl with me without killing buttons, and I still don't know how to wake her up.
I have 80's in my stats for persuasion rolls and it still fails.

That'a probably because you haven't given any points to the persuasion skill. You need 4 to persuade the cat.

[Lyra]

Originally posted by Potatus Tomatus Greenbeanius IV:

I don't think it makes sense that I can take just the girl to the ship. The cat is obviously loyal to her and poses no harm. Why leave the cat alone in the dungeon? Why can't I take the cat too? It is animal cruelty.

If only that was the only one.. This game was written very badly, It's full of stuff like this.

[Lyra]

Originally posted by Potatus Tomatus Greenbeanius IV:

Originally posted by Azurus:

I could never take the girl with me without killing buttons, and I still don't know how to wake her up.
I have 80's in my stats for persuasion rolls and it still fails.

Talk to the cat first, offer to help, break the columns, and then talk to the girl. I did the strength check persuasion. Don't know if other persuasions will work.

They'll work if you have persuasion 4 or more

[someoneevil]

You respec your skills at the ship. I use it for loremaster I go to ship to identify all items. When i need my main character to get pet pal i respec to that skill. Save before you talk to animals and characters. This game has a lot of customization you wont find on most rpg. This is a slow take your time game. To kill the demon the best way took me a couple hours to fonally knock him down and keep him from getting up so i could save the dwarf.

[someoneevil]

If you think these games are hard try betrayal at krondor in the 90's and many more. Most games you could never beat and you didn't have a wealth of hints online it was awful. Not to mention sega genisis and nintendo with no save games. Spoiled kids with all this technology for help and they whine online that it isnt fair.

[epic meow]

I really wanted to bring the cat like wtf, I teleported it out so it could search for the little girl. But decided that it was best to just let it die as it would never find the girl in time etc.
You can't even tell it where the girl is.

[epic meow]

You can't even tell the spirit that the girl is gone. For the others the spirits would go away and like move on or whatever when you clear the cell. Guess I'll just have to imagine that he wanders in sometime and notices she's gone.

[epic meow]

Originally posted by Allah's Dabsona:

You can't even tell the spirit that the girl is gone. For the others the spirits would go away and like move on or whatever when you clear the cell. Guess I'll just have to imagine that he wanders in sometime and notices she's gone.

Nvm it was just bugged got him to answer eventually

[Strawberry Fields]

I know it's an old thread, but watching Buttons meowing alone in that dark dungeon tears my heart apart. I wonder if developers could update this quest in later editions so the cat would be able to go to the ship too.