The silent monks who killed gareth's parents... spare? revenge kill? or mercy kill? Which option did you choose?

[Zols]

I am curious as to what others choose to do for this part. I ended up killing all 4 myself. Not out revenge for gareth, but thought of it as a mercy killing.

The dwarf was clearly being tortured so i killed him first, this was a no brainer due to being a dwarf lover and not wanting him to suffer. Next was the elf, part of me felt like it was asking to be slayed and not saved, for killing innocent creature's, some of which it might even know, and thus did not wish to continue to live being used as a weapon. The human male was clearly fully gone, so i lumped him in with the elf.

The human girl though, donna i think her name was i honestly felt bad for killing, since im guessing, inside, she wanted to remain with that pally guy (forget his name) but at the same time, knew that if anyone told her to kill someone, even if it was an angry child telling her to kill, her body would do it even if she did not want it to and thus would forever be used as a weapon. Hence her tears before she passed.

I honestly wanted to spare her, but i went with the cold hard vulcan logic instead.

[Nothing]

I just kill all of them because the alternative is letting them stand there forever or until some jackass magister get to them. If anyone found a way to save them I'm all ear

[Yaldabaoth]

引用自 Nothing：

I just kill all of them because the alternative is letting them stand there forever or until some jackass magister get to them. If anyone found a way to save them I'm all ear

Actually, if you don't do it after some time Gareth comes in, calls you a ♥♥♥♥♥ and kills them himself. At least for me.

[NouH]

I believe there's a way to save his parents, my worst mistake was telling Gareth to spare Jonathan, worst mistake indeed.

[Balalaika]

Possible to save his parents?

[NouH]

引用自 kancho anego：

Possible to save his parents?

If you talk to the ghosts they tell you that Jonathan was who killed them, you can find Gareth and Jonathan in a cabin not far from his house, there Gareth have knocked Jonathan out and prepared to kill him, if you spare Jonathan, he backstab everyone, he kills Gareth family and appear with the Sourcerer in Black Pits.

If you tell Gareth to kill him, you can avoid his parents dying, if you just ignore the cabin and go direct for Gareth house the parents will be dead and jonathan at the black pits.

If you kill jonathan you will have to save gareth family from Void Wokens, so be prepared for that.

[Nothing]

引用自 Yaldabaoth：

引用自 Nothing：

I just kill all of them because the alternative is letting them stand there forever or until some jackass magister get to them. If anyone found a way to save them I'm all ear

Actually, if you don't do it after some time Gareth comes in, calls you a ♥♥♥♥♥ and kills them himself. At least for me.

Not if you persuade him to give up revenge first.

[BigBoss]

引用自 Heleonis：

引用自 kancho anego：

Possible to save his parents?

If you talk to the ghosts they tell you that Jonathan was who killed them, you can find Gareth and Jonathan in a cabin not far from his house, there Gareth have knocked Jonathan out and prepared to kill him, if you spare Jonathan, he backstab everyone, he kills Gareth family and appear with the Sourcerer in Black Pits.

If you tell Gareth to kill him, you can avoid his parents dying, if you just ignore the cabin and go direct for Gareth house the parents will be dead and jonathan at the black pits.

If you kill jonathan you will have to save gareth family from Void Wokens, so be prepared for that.

How the ♥♥♥♥ to save his parents when they are already dead... are you on drugs?

[Singrave]

mercy kill
i've mercykilled all silent monks in Fort Joy.(didn't get to act2 yet :))

[Chosokabe Wariamu]

引用自 BigBoss：

引用自 Heleonis：

If you talk to the ghosts they tell you that Jonathan was who killed them, you can find Gareth and Jonathan in a cabin not far from his house, there Gareth have knocked Jonathan out and prepared to kill him, if you spare Jonathan, he backstab everyone, he kills Gareth family and appear with the Sourcerer in Black Pits.

If you tell Gareth to kill him, you can avoid his parents dying, if you just ignore the cabin and go direct for Gareth house the parents will be dead and jonathan at the black pits.

If you kill jonathan you will have to save gareth family from Void Wokens, so be prepared for that.

How the ♥♥♥♥ to save his parents when they are already dead... are you on drugs?

I think what his trying to say - is that Gareths parents need not actually be dead. When I first encountered Gareth he was digging his parents graves- but that's not so for everyone. I'm not entirely sure what the mechanic involved is.

[NouH]

引用自 BigBoss：

引用自 Heleonis：

If you talk to the ghosts they tell you that Jonathan was who killed them, you can find Gareth and Jonathan in a cabin not far from his house, there Gareth have knocked Jonathan out and prepared to kill him, if you spare Jonathan, he backstab everyone, he kills Gareth family and appear with the Sourcerer in Black Pits.

If you tell Gareth to kill him, you can avoid his parents dying, if you just ignore the cabin and go direct for Gareth house the parents will be dead and jonathan at the black pits.

If you kill jonathan you will have to save gareth family from Void Wokens, so be prepared for that.

How the ♥♥♥♥ to save his parents when they are already dead... are you on drugs?

Before getting triggered like a F*cking snowflake pay attention, if you talk to the Ghosts they tell you that JONATHAN killed them, THIS IS A GOOD INFORMATION if you're on another run or didn't find his house yet, if you find Gareth and Jonathan in the Cabin first then his parents will be alive.

[Martin]

As for the silent monks, there's a quest nearby to the graveyard, with a doctor trying to cure a seemingly mad escaped sorc (one from the dwarf caravan), I failed the persuasions, but maybe if you win those, he finds a cure to the silent monks? Dunno.. But they game seems to hint that there might be a cure..

[Yaldabaoth]

引用自 Martin：

As for the silent monks, there's a quest nearby to the graveyard, with a doctor trying to cure a seemingly mad escaped sorc (one from the dwarf caravan), I failed the persuasions, but maybe if you win those, he finds a cure to the silent monks? Dunno.. But they game seems to hint that there might be a cure..

Eh? How do you cure having your soul sucked out and annihilated?

[Chosokabe Wariamu]

引用自 Martin：

As for the silent monks, there's a quest nearby to the graveyard, with a doctor trying to cure a seemingly mad escaped sorc (one from the dwarf caravan), I failed the persuasions, but maybe if you win those, he finds a cure to the silent monks? Dunno.. But they game seems to hint that there might be a cure..

Yes..it's my last ditch hope on saving the monks - but passing the persuasion checks has you accompany him to save another girl in the basement of that house. I'm hping because she can be saved - that the silent monks can be also. But no joy yet I'm afraid!

[Chosokabe Wariamu]

引用自 Yaldabaoth：

引用自 Martin：

As for the silent monks, there's a quest nearby to the graveyard, with a doctor trying to cure a seemingly mad escaped sorc (one from the dwarf caravan), I failed the persuasions, but maybe if you win those, he finds a cure to the silent monks? Dunno.. But they game seems to hint that there might be a cure..

Eh? How do you cure having your soul sucked out and annihilated?

Apparently it's not souls sucked out in all cases...it's mind maggots!

[Martin]

引用自 Yaldabaoth：

引用自 Martin：

As for the silent monks, there's a quest nearby to the graveyard, with a doctor trying to cure a seemingly mad escaped sorc (one from the dwarf caravan), I failed the persuasions, but maybe if you win those, he finds a cure to the silent monks? Dunno.. But they game seems to hint that there might be a cure..

Eh? How do you cure having your soul sucked out and annihilated?

Well if you watch the second season of preacher.. ;) You can give people without souls 1% of your own.. maybe that'd work here as well.