I have Atomic Edition on GOG. Would you recommend playing it with eduke32, or getting this version?

[Nemorac]

Just curious as to what people think. I remember at least when this version came out people were bashing it.

[haha nerds...]

This version is good for the new episode, which is well worth playing. Otherwise, if you're just interested in playing the base game and no multiplayer, EDuke32 is more than sufficient and really the best port (yes, far better than Megaton).

[ghml]

Some differences between this version and GOG version:

Advantages of 20th Anniversary World Tour:
- Extra episode (Alien World Tour)
- Extra weapon (flamethrower)
- All Duke talk re-recorded with better quality
- Better global illumination and true-3D rendering
- Flashback feature (you can flashback to any part of the level after dying)
- Steam Workshop compatibility
- Online multiplayer compatible with Steamworks

Advantages of GOG/Eduke32 version:
- Eduke32 engine (OpenGL polymerer)
- Original sprites (Cross shaped medkit, for example)
- Level editor included (Mapster32)
- Better for modding
- Nice graphics options (from original to heavily modded and enhanced)

If you want to see a comparison of all official versions, check out this video I made. GOG version is at 14m21s mark and 20th Anniversary is at 17m06s mark.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuWyyDoxt4k&t=14m21s

[Nemorac]

Originally posted by ghml:

-snip-

Thanks for the video. From what I'm seeing and hearing, the GOG/eduke32 version has better sounding audio, and moves faster. While the visuals may look a bit better in World Tour, the audio sounds...muffled or something and the voice lines from Duke sound a bit phoned in.

[haha nerds...]

Originally posted by Nemorac:

Thanks for the video. From what I'm seeing and hearing, the GOG/eduke32 version has better sounding audio, and moves faster. While the visuals may look a bit better in World Tour, the audio sounds...muffled or something and the voice lines from Duke sound a bit phoned in.

You can toggle the original Duke recordings in World Tour if you prefer them (of course, the new lines for Episode 5 only have a "new" recording).

[Nemorac]

Originally posted by haha nerds...:

Originally posted by Nemorac:

Thanks for the video. From what I'm seeing and hearing, the GOG/eduke32 version has better sounding audio, and moves faster. While the visuals may look a bit better in World Tour, the audio sounds...muffled or something and the voice lines from Duke sound a bit phoned in.

You can toggle the original Duke recordings in World Tour if you prefer them (of course, the new lines for Episode 5 only have a "new" recording).

I think since I already have Atomic edition, I'm just gonna play it with eduke32. But I do thank all of you for informing my decision.

By the way, am I correct in that World Tour is slower than the original? It seemed that Duke didn't move as fast compartively in the video.

[haha nerds...]

Originally posted by Nemorac:

I think since I already have Atomic edition, I'm just gonna play it with eduke32. But I do thank all of you for informing my decision.

By the way, am I correct in that World Tour is slower than the original? It seemed that Duke didn't move as fast compartively in the video.

I haven't experienced or noticed any speed differences, and I think I would have considering how much I've played Duke 3D over the years.

[ghml]

Originally posted by Nemorac:

By the way, am I correct in that World Tour is slower than the original? It seemed that Duke didn't move as fast compartively in the video.

I don't think it is slower than original too. At least, I didn't notice (I have all released versions of DN3D). Maybe it is something related to "Run Mode" being toggled on or off (it can be done by pressing Caps Lock in-game), which can be done in any version. Anyway, good decision. Both versions are great.

[Turbo Nozomix]

World Tour isn't nearly as refined and content-rich as Megaton, that's for sure. Can't even get World Tour to play acceptably because the mouse movement lags behind moving the mouse around.

[Zeroxel]

I own the 3 versions of Duke Nukem 3D on Steam, each one has their pros and cons:

- Duke Nukem 3D by 3D Realms (Anthology Pack) (IDK if this is the same as the GOG release)

The best version for the hardcore fans in my opinion, includes the Atomic Edition, the 3 expansions and also Duke!ZONE II, which is exclusive for this version of the game. You can choose to play via Eduke32 or DosBox, so you will experience the same presentation as back in the day, plus it's really easy to add extra add-ons/maps like the official one "Penthouse Paradise", or use the Hi-Res Textures if you like that kind of stuff.
The only downside in my opinion is how each of the expansion episodes are presented on the selection menu, each one will replace some of the episodes of the Atomic Edition. This shouldn't be an issue for the ones who experienced the original Duke Nukem 3D back in the day, but could be a kind confusing for newcomers to the game.

- Duke Nukem 3D: Megaton Edition by Devolver Digital

For many (myself incluided) the definitive version of the game. Hands down this version has the best overall presentation, beautiful artwork and menus for the Atomic Edition and each one of the expansions. You can collect trading cards, get achievements and easily enjoy the multiplayer with your friends. Also includes the DosBox launcher for the Atomic Edition, but not for the expansions (I guess it should be easy to fix).
The only downside is that the in-game v-sync option cause some mouse acceleration, you can overcome that setting the v-sync on your graphics card control panel or completely ignore that if you enjoy a G-sync or Free-sync monitor.

- Duke Nukem 3D: 20th Anniversary World Tour Edition by Gearbox Software

The current and only digitally available version of the game. In my opinion the 20 Anniversary gets unfairly hate just because the stupid bussiness decisions by the current IP owner, completely ignoring the itself quality it offers this version.
Here we experience an improved game with new optional 3D perspective visuals, new voice recordings by the legendary Jon St. John, a new flamethrower weapon... and last but not least a brand new 5th episode made by the original developers. Same as the Megaton Edition, you can collect trading cards, get achievements and easily enjoy the multiplayer with your friends. For it's price this version it's really a good deal for newcomers to the game, but I completely understand that owners of previous versions claim it's expensive, considering that we're only getting a little new content in comparison with the other versions.
The downsides in my opinion are the completely lack of any of the expansions and the inferior sound quality in comparison with both previous releases.

Finally, as you can see each one has their pros and cons, the most important thing at the end of the day is to enjoy wherever you choose to play at. Also, I must say that each version complement the overall experience very well, considering that each one offers some unique features and content.

[ghml]

Zeroxel, great summary of every edition. I agree with most of your points. Just to add something:

- The muffled sound issue of 20th Anniverary Edition was 99% addressed on the November 2nd, 2016 patch (https://gearboxsoftware.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/216438263-PC-Duke-Nukem-3D-20th-Anniversary-World-Tour-Update-Notes)

- The Megaton Edition lacks of global illumination effects which is available in both Eduke32/GOG (Polymerer rendering) and Anniversary Edition (True 3D rendering) versions.

- Part of the original expansion packs are available for the 20th Anniversary Edition through Steam Workshop.

[Nemorac]

Originally posted by ghml:

Zeroxel, great summary of every edition. I agree with most of your points. Just o add something:

- The muffled sound issue of 20th Anniverary Edition was 99% addressed on the November 2nd, 2016 patch (https://gearboxsoftware.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/216438263-PC-Duke-Nukem-3D-20th-Anniversary-World-Tour-Update-Notes)

- The Megaton Edition lacks of global illumination effects which is available in both Eduke32/GOG (Polymerer rendering) and Anniversary Edition (True 3D rendering) versions.

- Part of the original expansion packs are available for the 20th Anniversary Edition through Steam Workshop.

I see. If the muffled sounds were fixed, maybe I will snag WT since it's on sale at the moment. If nothing else I can play both WT and Atomic with eduke32 and decide which I prefer.

[MrMuffinz]

The sounds honestly don't sound muffled to me at all.
IDK if they changed it at some point or something, but it sounds the same as when I last played Megaton (albeit it's been awhile).

Edit: Just played Megaton, sounds were barely different once I got them to the same level. Megaton has just a little more bass I think.

[haha nerds...]

Originally posted by McLovinz ʕಠᴥಠʔ:

The sounds honestly don't sound muffled to me at all.
IDK if they changed it at some point or something, but it sounds the same as when I last played Megaton (albeit it's been awhile).

Edit: Just played Megaton, sounds were barely different once I got them to the same level. Megaton has just a little more bass I think.

The initial sound issues were changed in a patch.