Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley

View Stats:
anita Feb 26, 2020 @ 1:23pm
Ok my cows and my goat have no milk the second day in a row.
The first day I just thought that I had forgotten I had already milked them. The second day I know there is something wrong. No it is not using the wrong click because it is coming up with the saying that the animal has no milk today. They have both fodder in the barn and grass outside and I pet them every day and they are full hearts for my character. I quit without finishing out the second day so it would not save any further. Any idea of a problem?
Originally posted by Turtleswatter:
Have you got the deluxe barn? Exactly the same problem as this was posted earlier this month and it turned out that they had an auto grabber and didn't realise it. Have a look around and see if there's something that looks like it.
< >
Showing 1-13 of 13 comments
The author of this thread has indicated that this post answers the original topic.
Turtleswatter Feb 26, 2020 @ 1:58pm 
Have you got the deluxe barn? Exactly the same problem as this was posted earlier this month and it turned out that they had an auto grabber and didn't realise it. Have a look around and see if there's something that looks like it.
Iroh Feb 26, 2020 @ 2:02pm 
if you look at the wording in the wiki it says cows can "usually" can be milked each day and goats "usually" milked every 2 days, so it's not 100%.
Now as far as things you can check: What season is it and do they have a heater if it's winter? Is the door closed/open in the appropriate season? After you pet an animal you can click em again and check their mood. This affects their ability to produce. The wiki has an extremely in depth guide and formulas for this and is worth looking at.
Iroh Feb 26, 2020 @ 2:06pm 
Originally posted by Turtleswatter:
Have you got the deluxe barn? Exactly the same problem as this was posted earlier this month and it turned out that they had an auto grabber and didn't realise it. Have a look around and see if there's something that looks like it.
How would they not realize they spent 25000 gold? Upgrading to a deluxe barn doesn't automatically grant you an auto grabber. It grants an auto FEEDER so you don't have to refill the hay trough, but you still have to buy the auto grabber that milks and sheers them for you
MightyJean Feb 26, 2020 @ 2:14pm 
Originally posted by Boboturk:
if you look at the wording in the wiki it says cows can "usually" can be milked each day and goats "usually" milked every 2 days, so it's not 100%.
It is though. Cows give milk every day and goats every 2 days, it's as much 100% as it can be.
Iroh Feb 26, 2020 @ 2:21pm 
Originally posted by MightyJean:
Originally posted by Boboturk:
if you look at the wording in the wiki it says cows can "usually" can be milked each day and goats "usually" milked every 2 days, so it's not 100%.
It is though. Cows give milk every day and goats every 2 days, it's as much 100% as it can be.
Yes, IF all of the appropriate conditions have been met. That's why there is a massive list of formulas and data on the wiki. If it was just 100% no matter what then this post wouldn't be here lol
Turtleswatter Feb 26, 2020 @ 4:37pm 
Originally posted by Boboturk:
Originally posted by Turtleswatter:
Have you got the deluxe barn? Exactly the same problem as this was posted earlier this month and it turned out that they had an auto grabber and didn't realise it. Have a look around and see if there's something that looks like it.
How would they not realize they spent 25000 gold? Upgrading to a deluxe barn doesn't automatically grant you an auto grabber. It grants an auto FEEDER so you don't have to refill the hay trough, but you still have to buy the auto grabber that milks and sheers them for you

Don't ask me, I'm not them. Happened though.
anita Feb 26, 2020 @ 4:59pm 
Sorry it is the autograbber. I completely forgot I bought it the day before and then shut the game down before I actually used it. I think I am going senile or something. After I posted this I though maybe it might be something going on with my hard drive cause I had done a restart on my computer and it had warned me it needed to do a scan so decided to scan it. I need a freaking minder now days. LOL
Turtleswatter Feb 26, 2020 @ 5:08pm 
As I said before you're not alone. Giving me a giggle though.
MightyJean Feb 26, 2020 @ 6:47pm 
Originally posted by Boboturk:
Yes, IF all of the appropriate conditions have been met. That's why there is a massive list of formulas and data on the wiki. If it was just 100% no matter what then this post wouldn't be here lol
As far as I know, the only requirement is being fed. Rest isn't about if they produce or not, but what they produce and what quality the product will be.
Iroh Feb 26, 2020 @ 7:29pm 
Originally posted by MightyJean:
Originally posted by Boboturk:
Yes, IF all of the appropriate conditions have been met. That's why there is a massive list of formulas and data on the wiki. If it was just 100% no matter what then this post wouldn't be here lol
As far as I know, the only requirement is being fed. Rest isn't about if they produce or not, but what they produce and what quality the product will be.
Moot point now anyway. The op has figured out their problem
Turtleswatter Feb 26, 2020 @ 9:21pm 
Originally posted by Boboturk:
Originally posted by MightyJean:
As far as I know, the only requirement is being fed. Rest isn't about if they produce or not, but what they produce and what quality the product will be.
Moot point now anyway. The op has figured out their problem

Ahem. Not so much figured it out as followed the advice I gave them which you poured so much scorn on XD
Lunacy Feb 26, 2020 @ 9:23pm 
I see a lot of threads about people who buy an auto-grabber then forget they used it and wonder why they have no produce. :T
Also i like to make enough cheese and mayo machines to use all the milk and eggs after 7 days.
Last edited by Lunacy; Feb 26, 2020 @ 9:23pm
Iroh Feb 26, 2020 @ 9:44pm 
Originally posted by Turtleswatter:
Originally posted by Boboturk:
Moot point now anyway. The op has figured out their problem

Ahem. Not so much figured it out as followed the advice I gave them which you poured so much scorn on XD
It'll be ok, pal
< >
Showing 1-13 of 13 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 26, 2020 @ 1:23pm
Posts: 13