ffxiv,gw2,wow. which one has better raids?

[Stevie Wonder]

i own all of them

now while ffxiv is the only one iv actaully got to end game with and completed all content for

i dont how how its raids stack up with the other 2? being wow and gw2

now this isnt a comparison on anything else but RAIDS

dont come in here with, X game is crap cuz Y reason, when its not about my question which is about raids

i hear good things abaout gw2, which iv just never gotten around to playing it much

and wow, well lets just say im trying to warm up to it.

[Gwyd1on]

FF14 and WoW have the better raids, the difference between the two at that point is personal preference above all else.

Only played GW2 a bit, but I really felt like raids wasn't its strong point.

That being said, I LOVE GW2 and FF14, WoW....not as much.

[:bestgamerchina#1最好的中國]

GW2 has one "mega" raid that takes around 1-2 hours to complete (if they didnt add new one in newest expac) GW2 is much faster when it comes to combat and doesnt have "holy trinity"(tank/dps/healer) idea behind itself, wich means every member of raid group has to do much more and has to perform much better than people who raid in WoW or FF14.

WoW and FF14 seems better when it comes to raids simply from less toxic behaviour from people as nobody is under such huge preasure as GW2 raiders.

[xyz]

guild wars has fractals, raids not so much. they are basically the mini instances that serve as the games content similar to raiding. There is other content but....

Raiding in this is really whatever tier is out at the minute in 4 instance on normal then 4 on saveage. If you are into raiding in this you need to commit to a role like in WoW, and build the gear weekly.

WoW idk raiding. I havent touched that kinda stuff over there in years.

[Drakzen]

I'd say either FF 14 or WoW, both of them have that kind of content in mind from Vanilla onwards and have experiance with them.

GW 2 has really just slapped on their raids and they a pretty bad plus the take away from the games "build your character how you want". So at this point in time I wouldn't consider GW 2 raids that great but maybe later down the line they might be good.

[xxxaziexxx]

GW2 is a lot harder when it comes to instanced content since they don't force you to play certain roles. Even just doing dungeons is hard a lot of the time because most people roll DPS and don't want to do mechanics or target priority.

I haven't played WoW, but I can definitely say FFXIV has better instanced raid/dungeon content than GW2.

[:bestgamerchina#1最好的中國]

Цитата допису xxxaziexxx:

GW2 is a lot harder when it comes to instanced content since they don't force you to play certain roles. Even just doing dungeons is hard a lot of the time because most people roll DPS and don't want to do mechanics or target priority.

I haven't played WoW, but I can definitely say FFXIV has better instanced raid/dungeon content than GW2.

There is no certain roles in GW2, there is onyly DPS and skills that help you to tank/heal (mostly on mesmer and ele.)

[xxxaziexxx]

Цитата допису Lemings:

Цитата допису xxxaziexxx:

GW2 is a lot harder when it comes to instanced content since they don't force you to play certain roles. Even just doing dungeons is hard a lot of the time because most people roll DPS and don't want to do mechanics or target priority.

I haven't played WoW, but I can definitely say FFXIV has better instanced raid/dungeon content than GW2.

There is no certain roles in GW2, there is onyly DPS and skills that help you to tank/heal (mostly on mesmer and ele.)

That's what I mean though. People don't take skills for party utility or survivability. They roll the Warrior GS/Rifle or other damage meta and assume the rest of their party members are going to pick up the slack.

I started running Hammer/Staff Guardian because of those people and am confident doing so is the only reason I got so many clears when all people run is straight damage or SOMETIMES an Elementalist with water attunement.

[:bestgamerchina#1最好的中國]

Цитата допису xxxaziexxx:

Цитата допису Lemings:

There is no certain roles in GW2, there is onyly DPS and skills that help you to tank/heal (mostly on mesmer and ele.)

That's what I mean though. People don't take skills for party utility or survivability. They roll the Warrior GS/Rifle or other damage meta and assume the rest of their party members are going to pick up the slack.

I started running Hammer/Staff Guardian because of those people and am confident doing so is the only reason I got so many clears when all people run is straight damage or SOMETIMES an Elementalist with water attunement.

GW2 was always all about time, it was never about class balance. Guardian is(was) supposed to run staff/sword+focus and GS for best DPS possible he could get(staff for dmg buff for party, sword+focus cos it was best dps on guard).
Its just not possible to play GW2 the same way as games like FF14 or WoW and perform on meta levels.