How can I befriend Undyne in a non-pacifist run?

[GRIDLINES]

Something that bothered me when I tried to do my first semi-pacifist run early on is that I only killed Toriel and yet Undyne still got mad at me for killing monsters in Waterfall. She never saw me kill anyone and yet she accuses me of murder. Is there anything I can do?

[Michelozzo]

Its bit of a logic flaw, but I'm pretty sure she is just a no-go on friendship if you've killed anyone, even if there's no way she could tell...but then again, you have Toriel's dust on your hands, don't you? ; )

[GRIDLINES]

Originally posted by Michelozzo:

Its bit of a logic flaw, but I'm pretty sure she is just a no-go on friendship if you've killed anyone, even if there's no way she could tell...but then again, you have Toriel's dust on your hands, don't you? ; )

Sans has some way of knowing your LV so it's plausible Undyne can as well. I just wish she didn't accuse me of killing kids in Snowdin/Waterfall when the only people I've killed are those in the RUINs.

[Michelozzo]

Originally posted by Rothnihalias:

Originally posted by Michelozzo:

Its bit of a logic flaw, but I'm pretty sure she is just a no-go on friendship if you've killed anyone, even if there's no way she could tell...but then again, you have Toriel's dust on your hands, don't you? ; )

Sans has some way of knowing your LV so it's plausible Undyne can as well. I just wish she didn't accuse me of killing kids in Snowdin/Waterfall when the only people I've killed are those in the RUINs.

Are you sure you didn't? 100% sure? It can be so hard to tell one spec of dust to another...

I'm kidding of course. Mostly ; )

[Sriracha]

i'm not entirely sure if you can befriend her in a non-pacifist run? however, if papyrus calls you when you're trying to run away from undyne and suggests hanging out with undyne, then give undyne the water and go back to her house in waterfall (near napstablook's place). if you're not sure if you got the call, check her house anyway. if papyrus is there, then you got it.

[GRIDLINES]

Originally posted by mariguana:

i'm not entirely sure if you can befriend her in a non-pacifist run? however, if papyrus calls you when you're trying to run away from undyne and suggests hanging out with undyne, then give undyne the water and go back to her house in waterfall (near napstablook's place). if you're not sure if you got the call, check her house anyway. if papyrus is there, then you got it.

That's very similar to what happens in my situation except Undyne refuses to speak to me and Papyrus tells me Undyne refuses to hang out with murderers.