What do you think of UnderFell?

[Lucky Bone Head]

Hello guys! You all know UnderFell right? Everyone's favorite Edgy, and "dark" spin on UnderTale? Well the Wiki for it is super bare, and awful, and I decided to make one to help remedy that.

Now I know that you may hate UnderFell (or hate what people did with it.) and I really understand and respect that. However I wanted a place that would log all of the good UnderFell works with the bad ones, and make note of the general consensus of the stories. While I was making it, I started wondering if there's some SERIOUS UnderFell hate, and If I was making myself a target

The other wiki is so unprofessional, and its a shame because I actually think UnderFell has potential as a story line.

It can be as bloody and profaine as it wants to, I actually enjoy bloody cartoons (as long as their funny). What bugs me about Most UnderFell stories is how serious everyone takes them. In my opinion, UnderFell should be fun, bloody and ironic. I'm actually working on a comic like that right now.

What are the general thoughts on this AU?

[Mother of Exiles]

//I don't hate it, but it's edgy 2.0

[MythlyInari]

It's...meh. I don't really see potential in a forcibly dark setting in something like Undertale.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Odyessy:

It's...meh. I don't really see potential in a forcibly dark setting in something like Undertale.

I see the potenial if its used comedicly. If we're trying to make a serious story...

Well, spend 30 minutes on Fan Fiction.net and see how that turns out.

I will admit though, overly edgy stories like that ARE my guilty pleasure.

[filler text]

It seems okay-ish?

[Willow Naibsel]

I don't like the concept of Underfell (either that Papyrus is really cruel to his brother, or Sans is his s3x-slave) but I like Papyrus.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Rhi™:

I don't like the concept of Underfell (either that Papyrus is really cruel to his brother, or Sans is his s3x-slave) but I like Papyrus.

Trust me, there's a LOT I don't like about UnderFell, but the idea of it is pretty cool.

Also, how randomly sexual it is, HILARIOUS for all the wrong reasons.

[Raptor]

I like the concept of a twisted Underground where everyone is evil except the main villain of the original game, but it was executed bad in my opinion.

[MC Screwdriver]

It's dry of thought. It needs a little bit more to it, not just a stupid twist and that's it. Also, the red outlines they have in their battle sprites isn't the easiest thing on your eyes.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Pasta Man:

It's dry of thought. It needs a little bit more to it, not just a stupid twist and that's it. Also, the red outlines they have in their battle sprites isn't the easiest thing on your eyes.

SO true. I'll always use the white and black style over the Edgy red one. I just think the white looks more pleasant.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Pasta Man:

It's dry of thought. It needs a little bit more to it, not just a stupid twist and that's it. Also, the red outlines they have in their battle sprites isn't the easiest thing on your eyes.

Its also very obvious. "Papyrus was nice in he actual game, so lets make him an abusive ♥♥♥♥ in this one!" I could see that coming from a mile away. I still like his design though, but only because it reminds me of Grim from The Grim Adventures of a show with a long as title.

[CaptainKthulhu]

Interesting idea, executed poorly. That's all I have to say.

I actually find it an interesting idea where the only good people are Frisk and Flowey.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Brainzzzz:

Interesting idea, executed poorly. That's all I have to say.

I actually find it an interesting idea where the only good people are Frisk and Flowey. :flowey:

I'm starting to believe that's what most people think. Really I think UF shoots itself in the foot by taking itself too serious

[Absolution]

I'm not intimately familiar with Underfel, but it's intended to be an inversion, right?- All the (ostensibly) good monsters in Undertale are evil, and so on.

From what little I've encountered, one theme that irks me is the prevailing theme of Frisk doing pacifist things. "Seeing the good" and all that. That actually gets under my skin- that's not an inversion, it's missing the point. (Missing the point being a favorite passtime of the general fanbase, but I digress.)

In Fel, pacifism should be off the table. The genocide of all the evil monsters should be the "good" ending, saving humanity forever.
Conquest of the monsters and leading them in war against the humans should be the "bad" ending.

Alternatively, a pacifist run where you are ultimately betrayed after you set the monsters free, and they then release untold hell on earth to illustrate the consequences of your naive ways.

But that's just like, my opinion man.

[Lucky Bone Head]

Originally posted by Absolution:

I'm not intimately familiar with Underfel, but it's intended to be an inversion, right?- All the (ostensibly) good monsters in Undertale are evil, and so on.

From what little I've encountered, one theme that irks me is the prevailing theme of Frisk doing pacifist things. "Seeing the good" and all that. That actually gets under my skin- that's not an inversion, it's missing the point. (Missing the point being a favorite passtime of the general fanbase, but I digress.)

In Fel, pacifism should be off the table. The genocide of all the evil monsters should be the "good" ending, saving humanity forever.
Conquest of the monsters and leading them in war against the humans should be the "bad" ending.

Alternatively, a pacifist run where you are ultimately betrayed after you set the monsters free, and they then release untold hell on earth to illustrate the consequences of your naive ways.

But that's just like, my opinion man.

Oh yeah. The way I'm writing it, Frisk (and some other protaganists) has to kill the boss monsters of the underground Organization 13 style. Killing in this case would be the right, and GOOD/HEROIC thing to do.

[Captain Demozan]

Not really a big fan of it. Though I do like UnderFell Asriel.