Worst Undertale AU?

[CupOKawfi]

So, yeah, I've seen lots of weird, sometimes funny, AU'S. But, obviously whats the most cringy?

[SQVeemo]

I don't like Altertale.

[ProxDee222]

Underlust ruined Undertale for me.

[Sans the Hedgehog]

Publicado originalmente por Fgvcx:

Please do not hate me for this. This is entirely my opinion. Every single AU is between bad or horrible.

necro

[marveljew]

Unlike most of the posters here, I actually like the Undertale AUs. However, I do admit a lot of them are terrible. Some examples are:
- Errortale: Sans is a supervillain whose personality boils down to “insanity equal violence”. He wants to destroy alternate universes without much motive. Despite having limited powers (manipulating strings and Gaster blasters), Sans is somehow a nigh-invincible god among men. Also, it is never explained how Sans can destroy universes.

- Undergone: This one was actually deleted by the author. Basically, all the monsters (except Monster Kid) are undead and darkly colored. Meanwhile, Chara is trying to set off the Core to kill everyone. I asked what differences there were between the undead and living monsters beyond the color. He told me that he had no idea and just wanted to mention that.

- Underfell: The premise is Undertale but edgy. In practice, it turns all the characters (sans Flowey, Frisk and Temmie for some reason) into homicidal maniacs. However, that was how view many of the characters already so all this did was exaggerate that one aspect.

[(Edgy) Asriel Dreemurr]

Out of the ones I know, Underswap. It doesn’t even follow its own rule.

Yes, I know this is a necro.

[marveljew]

Publicado originalmente por (Edgy) Asriel Dreemurr:

Out of the ones I know, Underswap. It doesn’t even follow its own rule.

How does Underswap violate its rule?

[(Edgy) Asriel Dreemurr]

Publicado originalmente por marveljew:

Publicado originalmente por (Edgy) Asriel Dreemurr:

Out of the ones I know, Underswap. It doesn’t even follow its own rule.

How does Underswap violate its rule?

It’s just supposed to be certain character personalities swapped, but Sans is a literal baby, and Papyrus drinks and smokes, even though normal Sans doesn’t do any of that.

[Zeox]

Can you guys let this die? is 2 years old and I really doubt OP gives a crap about Undertale AUs anymore.

[marveljew]

Publicado originalmente por Zeox:

Can you guys let this die? is 2 years old and I really doubt OP gives a crap about Undertale AUs anymore.

Can't he unsubscribe to the thread if he is tired of the topic?

[DOOMGUY]

Publicado originalmente por ProxDee222:

Underlust ruined Undertale for me.

Dude, AUs, porn, etc in fandoms don't really ruin the game, just like other games, the game is not ruined and a fanbase can't ruin a game just because they draw porn. In fact, that argument called "the fanbase/porn ruined it for me" argument is a bad argument. And yes, Underlust is a bad AU but it didn't really "ruined" the game honestly. Honestly I can see why the AU that your talking about is not good, but to be fair I gotta say I don't really like that AU at all either but not in the same way.

[RIP2UALL]

Ahem. Gentle might I remind you all of errorsans? He's a Mary sue of the highest magnitude and his AU is Crap!

[RedstoneLPM]

Publicado originalmente por RIP2UALL:

Ahem. Gentle might I remind you all of errorsans? He's a Mary sue of the highest magnitude and his AU is Crap! :spycon:

you mean Ink! sans. Error! sans is the bad guy. He also is a fanmade version of aftertale sans.

[marveljew]

Publicado originalmente por RIP2UALL:

Ahem. Gentle might I remind you all of errorsans? He's a Mary sue of the highest magnitude and his AU is Crap! :spycon:

Yep. I still don't quite understand how he can destroy universes.

[marveljew]

Publicado originalmente por RedstoneLPM:

Publicado originalmente por RIP2UALL:

Ahem. Gentle might I remind you all of errorsans? He's a Mary sue of the highest magnitude and his AU is Crap! :spycon:

you mean Ink! sans. Error! sans is the bad guy. He also is a fanmade version of aftertale sans.

Villains are be Mary Sues too.

[Kirby1783]

Publicado originalmente por CupOKawfi:

Publicado originalmente por Captain Boomerang Jr.:

Underlust. It ruins everyone's character. (Not to mention it completely glazes over how innocent Papyrus is)

Underlust is quality compared to Underhertail *shudders*

I've read that, it hurts my eyes.