Firewatch

Firewatch

檢視統計資料:
Trianq 2016 年 2 月 10 日 上午 8:19
Who was delilah talking to on day 2
Who was delilah talking to on day2 this hasnt been awnsered throughout the story.
The transcript:
D: "Heyo, I don´t think so. Why, have you?"
D: "Okay. Good."
D: "No. I don´t think he has any idea."
D: "I´m absolutely sure."
D: "Would you?"
D: "Alright, I´ll let you know if anything changes in that regard."
< >
目前顯示第 16-30 則留言,共 35
DG Dobrev 2016 年 2 月 16 日 上午 3:32 
引用自 Trianq
Who was delilah talking to on day2 this hasnt been awnsered throughout the story.
The transcript:
D: "Heyo, I don´t think so. Why, have you?"
D: "Okay. Good."
D: "No. I don´t think he has any idea."
D: "I´m absolutely sure."
D: "Would you?"
D: "Alright, I´ll let you know if anything changes in that regard."

Today I had the pleasure of watching a video on youtube by the Geek Remix that had an interesting premise that D and Ned were in this together and she actually talks to Ned in this situation. The girls in the video really make a good point and I quite enjoyed the hypethesis, even though it's just that :) a hypothesis.
mousemurder 2016 年 2 月 20 日 上午 12:40 
if the fone line was cut how could she be talking to anyone. i guess she had multiple walkies.
Chris 2016 年 2 月 20 日 上午 5:46 
This also really bothers me, I really want to know who she was talking to.
Inverz 2016 年 2 月 21 日 上午 4:03 
引用自 B_Natchez
I think she was talking to Julia, setting something up for Ned, cause later in the game she comes to speak with him during the night.
She didn't know julia at day 2, If I am right, well, MAYBE?? she talked to ned or other lookouts, maybe...
最後修改者:Inverz; 2016 年 2 月 21 日 上午 4:07
emmietiie 2016 年 2 月 21 日 上午 7:54 
It could only been Ned, one of the other two firewatches, or a ranger. The phoneline was already cut, so whoever it was had to have a radio.
Merlin_the 2016 年 2 月 24 日 下午 8:44 
引用自 Queen
It is another one of many plotholes in this 3-6 hour long game. I enjoyed the game, but I am quite surprised that the game has so many plotholes and so many things unexplained, for example how come Ned had all that equipment, how come delilah never saw his radar camp, when it was visible from her tower and stuff like this.
3-6?! more like 3-3.5 hour game. i mean ♥♥♥♥.
Zaph 2016 年 3 月 3 日 下午 11:49 
引用自 Odizee
If you pay attention to what is in Ned's Fake Reports at the research tent you can see that it questions whether she actually broke up with Javier or not and her multiple boyfriends. She was probably talking to the guy she's cheating on Javier with.

This. Absolutely this. Ned had been listening in on conversation for a long time and I think this was a part of it. It's why he knew that.
Vitriol ☧ 2016 年 3 月 14 日 下午 8:53 
maybe is a clue that no one found yet??? i mean, there is a lot of diferent outcomes, i just finished my first playtrough and i didnt found the racoon or the elk, and this game is big, maybe you need to be at the right place on the right time at some point.
Vitriol ☧ 2016 年 3 月 14 日 下午 9:11 
and there is a lot more unexplained stuff, like that fake college shirt, the burned cabin, that Delilah ignores, the fact that you can see clearly her base from the wapiti station, the time when she gives you that second radio, how did she put it there??? she would need to get to our sector, and i guess she never leaves her post, the crashed snowmobiles (i dont know if snows on wyoming, i live om brazil), but that is weird anyway
galacticcorgi 2016 年 3 月 31 日 上午 1:12 
"He doesn't know"

Think about it. There are other lookouts. They aren't the only two up there. She's probably radioing the other lookouts to let them know, was asked abuot a fourth, and said they didn't know yet. That's all.
Stel346 2016 年 7 月 11 日 下午 6:34 
引用自 King Snow
引用自 Trianq
I guess the game either leaves these plotholes open for the player to decide their outcome or the devs just didnt bother adding them. Personally i think that she was talking to her ex boyfriend but thats just my opinion.

Sorry, but if any developers think that way, that plotholes should be filled by the player itself, they shouldn't be making story games in the first place.

My thoughts are that their either changed the story in mid when developing or they simply forgot, either way it is kinda dumb for game this short.

Not everything that isn't spoon fed to you is a plot hole. It's a narrative technique. The idea is that you come to your own conclusions based on what you've learned about the characters and their world. It's supposed to create a sense of mystery, get you to engage more with the story and create depth without adding too much heavy-handed explanatory dialogue. If it works well, you debate with yourself and others about what really happened long after the game is over. This isn't always the case, sometimes games just have legitimate plot holes. But considering this game is completely focused on story and interactions between characters, with very simple mechanics to aid in that regard, it's extremely unlikely that it was unintentional. As a style it's not for everyone and obviously you're allowed to not like it. It certainly doesn't make it a bad story though.
Stel346 2016 年 7 月 11 日 下午 8:00 
引用自 Trianq
Who was delilah talking to on day2 this hasnt been awnsered throughout the story.
The transcript:
D: "Heyo, I don´t think so. Why, have you?"
D: "Okay. Good."
D: "No. I don´t think he has any idea."
D: "I´m absolutely sure."
D: "Would you?"
D: "Alright, I´ll let you know if anything changes in that regard."


Most likely explanation comes from the file Goodwin had on her at Wapati Station. Remember the line "multiple lovers despite long term partner (Javier)". This conversation makes total sense if you imagine she is talking to someone she is sleeping with. If you ask her who she was speaking to, she confirms the speaker was a male, from another station but that the conversation is work related. Except Then she suddenly gets very angry, says that it's none of your business and asks you not to talk to her anymore unless it's urgent. That suggests that she is lying and angry about the situation. So, roughly filling in the blanks:

(mystery guy): Do you think he knows about us?
No. I don´t think he has any idea."
(mystery guy): How sure are you about that?
D: "I´m absolutely sure."
(mystery guy): Look, maybe you should come clean, tell him about us?
D: "Would you?"
(mystery guy): I'm not sure I feel comfortable with this anymore. Look let me know if you change your mind about telling him.
D: "Alright, I´ll let you know if anything changes in that regard."

It could be that delilah had lied to the guy in this conversation and pretended to still have a boyfriend to avoid telling the truth (the story she tells henry). She is angry because she's having to lie to someone she is actually in a legitimate relationship with. Or she lied to Henry and she actually was still with Javier. Personally I'm inclined to think she was being honest with Henry, since it explains why she is out there in the first place. Either way it explains the conversation. It seems likely the note is true since it also mentions about her alcoholism and twice she calls Henry while drunk, both times in a situation were it was very inappropriate to drink; introducing herself to a new co-worker and drinking hard liquor when convinced she was being spied on and was worried for her own safety. Also in her cabin is an empty bottle of tequila and another one on the desk. That all suggest she can't control her drinking so the note is probably at least partly accurate.

Final thought: In their last conversation, Delilah tells Henry he should go to Julia and he responds

"would you?" echoing the conversation he overheard her having. Is it possible that she was talking to someone who was telling her to go to Javier and she was telling them she didn't want to? Just throwing that one out there.
最後修改者:Stel346; 2016 年 7 月 11 日 下午 10:23
Winters 2016 年 8 月 21 日 上午 12:33 
引用自 Snow
It is another one of many plotholes in this 3-6 hour long game. I enjoyed the game, but I am quite surprised that the game has so many plotholes and so many things unexplained, for example how come Ned had all that equipment, how come delilah never saw his radar camp, when it was visible from her tower and stuff like this.

These weren't plotholes. You obviously rushed through the game and didn't pay attention to anything. If you read the notes in his hideout it shows the the camp WAS actually being used by biologists, they were currently off work on their off-season until August 1st. He was using their equipment to trick Henry and Delilah.

Also when you break in to the camp, even Henry says "this camp is hidden in a valley where none of the towers can see it".
Vitriol ☧ 2016 年 8 月 21 日 下午 5:54 
引用自 WintersWolf
引用自 Snow
It is another one of many plotholes in this 3-6 hour long game. I enjoyed the game, but I am quite surprised that the game has so many plotholes and so many things unexplained, for example how come Ned had all that equipment, how come delilah never saw his radar camp, when it was visible from her tower and stuff like this.

These weren't plotholes. You obviously rushed through the game and didn't pay attention to anything. If you read the notes in his hideout it shows the the camp WAS actually being used by biologists, they were currently off work on their off-season until August 1st. He was using their equipment to trick Henry and Delilah.

Also when you break in to the camp, even Henry says "this camp is hidden in a valley where none of the towers can see it".

but from the camp you can clearly see Delilah's tower
Stabbey 2017 年 1 月 1 日 下午 9:47 
The dev's audio commentary says that it was just a red herring to make the player/Henry feel a bit suspicious about Delilah. It was part of an earlier story idea where pitting Henry and Delilah against each other was going to be used, but that was mostly changed or played down.

引用自 Derzu Uzala
and there is a lot more unexplained stuff, like that fake college shirt, the burned cabin, that Delilah ignores

Actually, it turns out that Delilah does have a lot to say about the cabin, but only if you visit it AFTER Day 2 and open the stove, then there's actually a big long tall tale you can get later. I did it on Day 3. The reason for that is in another Dev commentary, it wasn't available on first approaching the cabin on Day 2 because getting all that stuff dumped on before even going in wasn't really as much fun as exploring and getting surprised.


the time when she gives you that second radio, how did she put it there??? she would need to get to our sector, and i guess she never leaves her post,

She obviously did leave her post. She mentioned having to lie to a couple rangers.

the crashed snowmobiles (i dont know if snows on wyoming, i live om brazil), but that is weird anyway

Yes, Wyoming definitely is far enough north and cold enough to get snow.
< >
目前顯示第 16-30 則留言,共 35
每頁顯示: 1530 50