Water carrying quest (spoiler)

[Frosty]

SPOILER

so, what is the correct job to the correct people?
I do by giving the job accept to the dude who is strong in the mine.
The women do the water carrying, but then she become a widow? What? So she suppose to carry poop?
And pickman suicide after he said that do any job is better.
Sigh...
Plz someone explain. Thanks.

[Battleseed]

Gave out the jobs like so:
Pickman poop
Rock poop (heal him w/marigold potion before you speak to baliff)
Vincent water
Antonia water
Tunda water
Agnus cook

Quest completed. No idea if down the line the those choices will work out or not. Might be another part to it later on.

[Big Boom Boom]

There is no correct order, most of the NPC will give you a reward if you give them the water job. The only one with correct order is Agnes because well she's the only person for the job.

Giving Antonia the water job still ends up badly and she gives you no reward. It might be the "bad" decision.

[Battleseed]

If you ask for something in return, you lose rep with Rattay refugee. Asked the guy that ran the mines and lost 5 rep.

[HunZolka]

If you give Pickman the poopy job, will he still reward you?

[Kommissar K]

As far as I'm aware, you just really want to make sure you give Pickman a water carry job, and make sure to ask him for a reward. The rest just doesn't really matter.

[Frosty]

Originally posted by Kommissar Klose:

As far as I'm aware, you just really want to make sure you give Pickman a water carry job, and make sure to ask him for a reward. The rest just doesn't really matter.

I am aware although it already to late. I did not know at that time that this quest tie in with other quest.