*spoilers* The Gallows Brothers/A Rock and a Hard Place

[Evil Overlord]

So I've been running around finishing up side quests and this ones really bugging me, I can't decide if I want to frame Andrew to save Mathew and Fritz or let the two of them sleep in the bed they made. I'm aware there's an achievement tied to framing all 3 but not gonna do that one this play through.
I mean my Henry isn't perfect but they want to turn into bandits and drag me down with them.

[Carinth]

I had a really hard time with this one. What I did originally was I said I wouldn't help them, went with Andrew's suggestion alerting the guards and then told them Andrew wanted me to rat on them but to leave Andrew be.

When it came to the day of the heist, I saved it beforehand.
That night Mathew and Fritz died during the robbery and you were to go back and tell Andrew.
I didn't like that outcome and went back to the save beforehand.
I then spoke to Mathew and Fritz and decided to frame Andrew, knocked out the guards in the camp and stole the money. I created another save at this point.

I then told on all 3 to get the Judas achievement, but they are hanged and the glade becomes un-usable as Andrew is hung outside on the road.

I reloaded my save and just framed Andrew after, but same thing he gets hung and the glade becomes un-usable.

So I went all the way back to my first save just before the robbery, in which I had not agreed to help them or frame Andrew. I then snuck into the camp and stole the money before Matthew and Fritz arrived. The quest failed, but no one died and there seemed to be no repercussions.

Failing the quest seems to have the best outcome, but I did run it through 4 times before deciding that and did get the achievement which you don't lose even if you go back and change the outcome.

[Lieste]

Glade is still usable (via the Maid), but you cannot use Andrew in other sidequests, which will block another achievement.

[Carinth]

All the maid did was cry when I went back, only having pickpocket as an option when I tried to speak to her and it said i was trespassing in the inn. I guess if I waited longer she would have become usable, but I reloaded at that point.

[Evil Overlord]

Originally posted by Carinth:

I had a really hard time with this one. What I did originally was I said I wouldn't help them

I was in the same boat that's why I made this post, after following your post through many of the options and being unsatisfied with how it turned out I put them down myself during the robbery. my town wont have them now but they had it coming.

[deserthamster]

these two were just horsing around. they do not deserve death. they really need that money after all the hardship that they suffered.

[Axxius]

The inn gets back to the normal state after a week (minus Andrew if you framed him).

That's the single worst quest in KCD. The best outcome is to fail it, as described above, without causing the death of your best friends or a friendly innkeeper.

[Gorok Delvedeep]

Originally posted by Evil Overlord:

So I've been running around finishing up side quests and this ones really bugging me, I can't decide if I want to frame Andrew to save Mathew and Fritz or let the two of them sleep in the bed they made. I'm aware there's an achievement tied to framing all 3 but not gonna do that one this play through.
I mean my Henry isn't perfect but they want to turn into bandits and drag me down with them.

This is why you never leave sidequests alone and instead pretty much abandon the actual main story quest for sides instead.

if you address your merry gang of reprobates soon enough those two are never in that quest, since you already covered them in a seperate quest for pribyslavitz, ending up with them in fairly good armour working at your inn as heavies.