Has anyone killed the firekeeper?

[The Subi]

*Warning i dont know the actual value of this piece of info so beware of huge spoilers"



so i went to the untended graves and found the eyes of a firekeeper. and after some talk the firekeeper said "if your heart ever changes kill me and strip these eyes from my body. so that i may come back as i was." or something like that. now i didnt try this but does that mean she will just respawn like nothing ever happaned after the eye transplant? or is it generally like that even before the eye transplant.

[Zander]

nothing bad happens if you do.

[Maechen]

I haven't tried but I hear Andre, the Handmaiden and the firekeeper all respawn if killed.

[yo]

dont do it.

[The Subi]

Originally posted by Valerian van Valmyr:

dont do it.

i cant hurt something so kawaii

[IJONOI]

You can kill her if you've given her the eyes it'f fine. She gives you them back. Not sure what they do.

Also before entering NG+ remeber to kill all NPCS first for their armors / weapons / souls :)

[Locklear]

Originally posted by IJONOI:

You can kill her if you've given her the eyes it'f fine. She gives you them back. Not sure what they do.

Also before entering NG+ remeber to kill all NPCS first for their armors / weapons / souls :)

If you give her the eyes, you'll have the chance to trigger a drifferent ending.

[The Subi]

Originally posted by IJONOI:

You can kill her if you've given her the eyes it'f fine. She gives you them back. Not sure what they do.

Also before entering NG+ remeber to kill all NPCS first for their armors / weapons / souls :)

i am not really that much into fashion souls. fallen knight set is cool enough :D
she says that the eyes show her a world without fire. and asks if that whats you really want if yes she says ok im your servant until your "something something" betrayal. i felt bad i think i am going to take back the eyes.

[IJONOI]

Ha, to each their own! I'm still searching for the best armor. Probably going to go with Yuria's.

Yeah, you don't get penalised for killing her. :)

[Sunohara]

How will you level without her though? lol

[The Subi]

i killed her to get the eyes back. said dont you know i can not die so i assume she would come back without the eyes. also nothing about her changes after killing her. only the ending will change. link the flame or let it fade.

[vinut001]

she is the best waifu lol

[Dr. Uncredible]

You can kill her, she comes back, I can attest to this after accidently flattening her with a drop attack with Smoughs Pancake Press while jumping around firelink. ^^ 1 shot 1 kill, it amused me far more than it should have once i recovered from the surprise and found out I had -not- ruined my run.

[Merilirem]

Everyone who matters is undead. Which in most games would be silly, but it makes perfect sense here. You can kill them, but it will piss them off. Firekeeper is basically your toy though.

[GT-R]

Originally posted by Merilirem:

Firekeeper is basically your toy though.

She is. I love releasing my stress by killing her and listening to her moan. ;)

[SĦINOBI ĴǍĈǨ ︻芫=一一]

Originally posted by GT-R:

Originally posted by Merilirem:

Firekeeper is basically your toy though.

She is. I love releasing my stress by killing her and listening to her moan. ;)

Oh My