Can you Rebirth and still continue Sirris' questline?

[the ultimate white girl]

Not too happy with my stat investment on this NG, decided to swap playstyles midway through. I know giving Rosaria pale tongues, or equipping the covenant item, will make Sirris bugger off.

[Spider]

Yes, as long as you don't give a PT to Rosaria directly or equip the covenant item you can remake your character/respec all you like without pissing off Sirris.

[Crux]

Yeah, respeccing or changing your appearance doesn't halt Sirris' questline.
Only handing in pale tongues will.

[Cohnway]

What Spider said. Just don't put on the covenant item or give that woman a single Pale Tongue as offering. Respecs are ok-dokey.

[Crux]

I'm pretty sure I've equipped the fingers cov and still was able to do Sirris before, hell idk, maybe I've played too much and don't really remember.

[Valky]

Originally posted by Gameo:

I'm pretty sure I've equipped the fingers cov and still was able to do Sirris before, hell idk, maybe I've played too much and don't really remember.

No deal, i've done that and Sirris immediately went berserk on me lol.

[Crux]

I reeaallly remember doing that.. I remember equipping it and then talking to her in the shrine and thinking to myself, 'I thought this made her hostile', but nope, still fought Creighton and still finished the quest.

Now I gotta go do it all over again to satisfy my ignorance. -_-

[Sausagetalk]

I rebirthed and it failed her questline. You have to give a pale tongue to rebirth.

[Crux]

Nope, 100% certain rebirth does not fail questline.
I've done it multiple times.

[XERXES_II]

To be safe you can just wait until Sirris dies to interact with Rosaria.